I'm all over this. HL2 is my favorite PC game of all time, while HL1 I never finished due to its comparatively non-interactive style. After going through the intro of Black Mesa, it has the HL2 "feel" that was missing before.
I still have a hunch HL2 is better based purely on design, though.
I still have a hunch HL2 is better based purely on design, though.