"But then they would clearly decide it was time to remind everyone that this was a "3D Movie". Then a character would kick dirt at the screen, or a gun/bow would be aimed out of the screen, Or we would enter a field of floating bugs. These were clearly moments designed to highlight the 3d nature of the movie. Thus they are gimmicks."
Meh. Watch any other 3d movie. You're defining gimic as any time 3d comes out of the screen rather than going into it? If so yeah, Avatar has maybe 3-5 scenes lasting 2 minutes total where the 3d comes out of the screen. To put things in perspective you should really watch another 3d movie where its 90+ minutes of nonstop crap coming out of the screen in your face. Avatar is so subtle in comparison its not even worth complaining about.
Meh. Watch any other 3d movie. You're defining gimic as any time 3d comes out of the screen rather than going into it? If so yeah, Avatar has maybe 3-5 scenes lasting 2 minutes total where the 3d comes out of the screen. To put things in perspective you should really watch another 3d movie where its 90+ minutes of nonstop crap coming out of the screen in your face. Avatar is so subtle in comparison its not even worth complaining about.