Army Migrating Computers to Vista

Sure you can argue that they should be funding these Linux distro groups but they will not do it as it's like I said A) a waste of taxpayer money to move to an entire new platform B) a waste of time to rewrite protocols that have been years in the making C) retraining all current and future personnel to be accustomed to the new operating system.

I'm not a sysadmin ...but I play one on TV .. :p

..and I was wondering, is it really cheaper to pay Microsoft than "rolling" our own version of Linux for U.S. Armed Forces? We already have our Armed Forces IT guys on salary , why pay Microsoft too? ..we would have to devote more bodies to do the work ourselves I would imagine .. but I would think that that would actually save taxpayers a couple bucks here and there over the long run.. ?:confused:
 
I'm not a sysadmin ...but I play one on TV .. :p

..and I was wondering, is it really cheaper to pay Microsoft than "rolling" our own version of Linux for U.S. Armed Forces? We already have our Armed Forces IT guys on salary , why pay Microsoft too? ..we would have to devote more bodies to do the work ourselves I would imagine .. but I would think that that would actually save taxpayers a couple bucks here and there over the long run.. ?:confused:
Nope, not even. You're forgetting about the politics involved regarding transition. Plus bureaucrats likes familiarity, not some unknown operating system that they've never used. You cannot justify retraining all of the personnel to use a different operating system right away and scrap previous protocols. So you're better off just keeping an operating system that most of the country knows how to use and securing it from that point on. If you look at the Army Golden Master program under the ASCP contract, it's extremely complicated as most of them are adopting from previous protocols established and updating it.

That and Microsoft & Softmart Government Services has a dedicated support team with years and years of experience to fix any issues for the Army. As several people mentioned in this thread, they have contractors from Microsoft/various companies on the spot to help resolve any issues that comes up. They're not going to headhunt for guys to provide support for another operating system when the current system works just fine.

The Microsoft Enterprise License Agreement (MS ELA) is for the entire Army program so licensing isn't that really big of an issue. They're paying a fixed 78 million dollars per year in licenses on a 1 year contract with 5 years option (They're in the 3rd year now going on 4).

Plus I found a somewhat of a deal for any Army personnel that may want a copy of Office 2003, not Office 2007 (under the HUP program). Sounds like it costs $20 to get a copy of the package.
http://www.google.com/#hl=en&q="Mic...rosoft+Home+Use+Program+(HUP)"&fp=G7EFg_3LQek
(Hint: very first link, read the PDF)
 
This is common for most companies and government agencies. You don't want to run production material on a brand new os without extensive testing.

Windows 7 will be more compatable than Vista will be, especially with the app virtualization for win XP programs. They shouldn't waste their time or money with Vista seeing as there is already an RC of Win7 out.

No, because they would need to spend three years testing Win 7 as well. Even though it isn't as much of a change, it would still take a while.

It's normal for corporations and government agencies to stay one version behind. While using the previous version, they can be testing the current version.

Anything on Vista should run on Win7 as well.
 
Windows 7 will be more compatable than Vista will be, especially with the app virtualization for win XP programs. They shouldn't waste their time or money with Vista seeing as there is already an RC of Win7 out.



Anything on Vista should run on Win7 as well.
Just because it's more compatible doesn't mean it's the same code. Microsoft has two different versions, the consumer version and the military version. Microsoft's obviously been working to militarize Vista in order to comply with the requirements the military demands. Until then, Windows 7 will remains a long ways off.

Yes they will invest their time using the operating system that is currently out, Windows 7 does not count. As been pointed out in the thread, large organizations and such will not be upgrading to Windows 7 until it meets their requirements to deploy on a large scale.
 
lol @ all the misinformation out there about Army IT stuff.
and
lol @ all the armchair QBs.
If you think you have a better idea for us, by all means, get a security clearance and come help out. There are probably 20 IT positions available in my local area alone for the Army.
BTW, any good IT guy knows that TCO for open source OS (server or workstation) is not really much cheaper than Microsoft and for big customers, Microsoft will beat the stuffings out of everyone else on support.
 
Just because it's more compatible doesn't mean it's the same code. Microsoft has two different versions, the consumer version and the military version. Microsoft's obviously been working to militarize Vista in order to comply with the requirements the military demands. Until then, Windows 7 will remains a long ways off.

Yes they will invest their time using the operating system that is currently out, Windows 7 does not count. As been pointed out in the thread, large organizations and such will not be upgrading to Windows 7 until it meets their requirements to deploy on a large scale.

Lol, "military version".

lol @ all the misinformation out there about Army IT stuff.
and
lol @ all the armchair QBs.
If you think you have a better idea for us, by all means, get a security clearance and come help out. There are probably 20 IT positions available in my local area alone for the Army.
BTW, any good IT guy knows that TCO for open source OS (server or workstation) is not really much cheaper than Microsoft and for big customers, Microsoft will beat the stuffings out of everyone else on support.

So, you aren't an one of those IT positions (at least of any impotance) I see. What kind of armchair man does that make you?????
 
So, you aren't an one of those IT positions (at least of any impotance) I see. What kind of armchair man does that make you?????

I have no idea what this even means. ???

If the question is "is my position important?" then my answer would be that they sure pay me like it is and they would be in a world of hurt were I to quit without notice. :D

If the question is "am I an armchair QB?" then my answer is that I cannot be as I did not make the decision to roll out on Vista. That came from a much higher level than me. Dr. Harding, in the article, is the director at EITS at Big Army G-6. Those are the kinds of people that decide to roll out something major and Army-wide. Just like everyone else working Army IT (contractors, greensuits, and GS) I can only make decisions that affect my Area Of Responsibility.
 
I have no idea what this even means. ???

If the question is "is my position important?" then my answer would be that they sure pay me like it is and they would be in a world of hurt were I to quit without notice. :D

If the question is "am I an armchair QB?" then my answer is that I cannot be as I did not make the decision to roll out on Vista. That came from a much higher level than me. Dr. Harding, in the article, is the director at EITS at Big Army G-6. Those are the kinds of people that decide to roll out something major and Army-wide. Just like everyone else working Army IT (contractors, greensuits, and GS) I can only make decisions that affect my Area Of Responsibility.

Sounds like the army is giving kickbacks and installing Vista ($) for microsoft giving them something that they want.
 
Kickbacks meaning Vista (and Microsoft) gets cred of army using Vista and microsoft gets money from the military without actually being paid off to do something. I'd expect nothing less, honestly, given the way things work here.
 
Lol, "military version".
You can laugh at that all you want but Microsoft definitely has redesigned Windows for the military hence it is indeed a "military version" in the sense. This goes way back to the Microsoft trial when they argued that opening the source code would threaten national security and that is indeed true. As I've stated, we the consumers have a lesser priority because Microsoft is required by contract to provide immediate support for any issues that arises especially pertaining to holes in their system. Don't believe me? Army Gold Master program. It's open for anyone to read. And since Microsoft is on a fixed payment contract, any expenses past their budget is at the loss of Microsoft, not the Army. I'm tempted to say "Troll is serious troll" here.

You can whine, bitch, scream about how they should jump the gun straight to Windows 7 but they have protocols to follow as to maximize their protection.
 
if you know anything about AGM, then you know that it is not a "Military Version"
It is essentially a modified local GPO packaged with a few registry changes that provide a standardized security baseline for the OS.
You too, could use this "military version" if you had the complete list of GPO and registry changes and wanted to take the time to implement them all.
 
Back
Top