Apple Working on Device Abuse Detection Technology

Take Sears, for a counterexample. I can take my favorite ratchet, and drop it in a bucket of salt water. I can leave it there for a month. Then, I can take the rusted, locked up ratchet to Sears, tell them what I did to it, and walk out of there with a new one. That is how a honorable company handles a product warranty.

That's not really a fair comparison and you should know it. The Craftsman guarantee on tools at Sears has always blatantly stated "return for replacement for any reason" or words to that effect - they could care less what happens to the tool even if you admit you destroyed it on purpose just to get a new one.

The Apple warranty doesn't make such claims, nor allow for such returns - it is very specific and precise to the degree that Apple Legal decides it must be for them to save some ass and some money.

Yes, the "water detectors" give false positives, it can happen because of a big change in humidity (as I've seen it happen personally with my own iPod touch last year here in Vegas). Damned thing changed colors in one day because it rained, literally. The humidity change was so extreme from the prior day to the day after that pretty much every thing and every one sweat... apparently so did the freakin' iPod touch. :D

But they are a bit insane with this stuff. At worst, if they replace the unit and discover that no, there is no actual water damage and the unit does actually have a reason for being returned - and that reason turns out to be the actual problem - then they'll just throw it back on the Apple Store as a refurb.

I mean, with their working 40%+ profit margin, they are never losing money on anything...
 
Just one more reason I won't own anything apple makes. Bleh!
 
If you shook something lose playing the "Shake the baby" game, were you covered?

"Uh, I broke it being abusive..."
 
There's nothing abnormal about this. Apple isn't the only company to put physical water sensors in their devices. It's actually a common practice. Lying customers are a big problem. If someone discovers he can get free stuff by lying, he will usually do so. Even people who are normally honest will lie when faced with the "oh crap, I just broke my $600 iPhone!" moment.

Having said that, I see some potential problems with Apple's new technology. The physical water sensors are quite straightforward; a tech can show you when a sensor is clearly tripped, and nothing can trigger that chemical reaction other than real liquid exposure. With the digital monitors, however, Apple could easily tweak up the sensitivity of those sensors if they are getting too many warranty requests. I'm not saying they will do this, but it could happen. If Apple uses this technology, they better publish the exact conditions that will trigger those sensors.
 
The physical water sensors are quite straightforward; a tech can show you when a sensor is clearly tripped, and nothing can trigger that chemical reaction other than real liquid exposure.

Not so much I have had them go off in my phone and families phones from just being in a humid environment. They never came in contact with liquid at all.
 
When all customers are treated like criminals, your company doesn't deserve to be around anymore.

Microsoft has been treating all of their customers like criminals since XP came out, but they're still around. :(
 
Microsoft has been treating all of their customers like criminals since XP came out, but they're still around. :(

Say what?

Microsoft's business strategy might be questionable against other businesses, but Microsoft hardly bother their customer base.

What has Microsoft ever done to you?
 
Say what?

Microsoft's business strategy might be questionable against other businesses, but Microsoft hardly bother their customer base.

What has Microsoft ever done to you?

http://arstechnica.com/microsoft/ne...-suffers-worldwide-outage-problems-galore.ars
http://arstechnica.com/old/content/2007/01/8690.ars
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/...r-flaw-in-microsofts-anti-piracy-strategy.ars

That was two years ago, but that affected thousands (maybe tens of thousands) of legitimate users.

Not to mention that people have been snagged by this junk by just updating BIOSes or drivers.

I've never quite understood how placing a call to MS and chatting with someone by voice is any extra reassurance that you are using it legitimately.


But the fact is that people who pirate and use the latest workarounds never have to deal with this stuff. How is an anti-piracy measure working if it doesn't affect pirates?

But you knew all of this already, so I guess it just doesn't bother you... Not sure at what point on what item you own that it would finally bother you, though.

I mean, would 12,000 people find it acceptable if they jumped in their Toyotas and the car told them they had to call Toyota before it would start?

How about if in the meantime while you are calling Toyota a car thief came by and stole your car, because they knew how in 30 seconds to circumvent Toyota's authentication system, and just drove off in your car, something 5 minutes earlier you couldn't do yourself...

False positives are treating paying customers like criminals... Knowing that when these snafus occur that someone at MS "isn't sleeping until it's fixed" is just stupid...
 
Upon first read, before i clicked through the 8 links or so to get to the actual article, i figured this was going to be to block the "abuse" of jailbreaking. Im really suprised they havent tried to actively combat people being able to actually use their phones in a manner they want yet (ie, jailbroken = no service)
 

Are you serious? A temporary DRM outage translates to, "MS treats their customers like crap?"

Hey Steve, you better post another RIAA/MPAA-related article soon. We haven't had a chance to complain about DRM for a few days now; people are getting restless. :p
 
Are you serious? A temporary DRM outage translates to, "MS treats their customers like crap?"

I think the point he intended to make is Microsoft's whole product activation scheme revolves around the mentality that you are a pirate until proven legitimate, as opposed to being legitimate until proven pirate.
 
http://arstechnica.com/microsoft/ne...-suffers-worldwide-outage-problems-galore.ars
http://arstechnica.com/old/content/2007/01/8690.ars
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/...r-flaw-in-microsofts-anti-piracy-strategy.ars

That was two years ago, but that affected thousands (maybe tens of thousands) of legitimate users.

Not to mention that people have been snagged by this junk by just updating BIOSes or drivers.

I've never quite understood how placing a call to MS and chatting with someone by voice is any extra reassurance that you are using it legitimately.


But the fact is that people who pirate and use the latest workarounds never have to deal with this stuff. How is an anti-piracy measure working if it doesn't affect pirates?

But you knew all of this already, so I guess it just doesn't bother you... Not sure at what point on what item you own that it would finally bother you, though.

I mean, would 12,000 people find it acceptable if they jumped in their Toyotas and the car told them they had to call Toyota before it would start?

How about if in the meantime while you are calling Toyota a car thief came by and stole your car, because they knew how in 30 seconds to circumvent Toyota's authentication system, and just drove off in your car, something 5 minutes earlier you couldn't do yourself...

False positives are treating paying customers like criminals... Knowing that when these snafus occur that someone at MS "isn't sleeping until it's fixed" is just stupid...

The people against product activations read too much into things. If you bought your product, just activate it and shut up. It's not hard to do. If you used up your activation, take 5-10 minutes to call them up and tell them you need to reactivate. Again, it's not hard.

And for the 10000th time, activation isn't to deter home pirates. It deters stores like Gamestop who sells used product to no benefit of the developers. It deters mom and pop computer stores from making a profit by selling the same copy of Windows and other software on multiple computers. You want to complain about activation? Complain to those people, not Microsoft. Microsoft is just trying to protect their investment.

As for that activation bug a couple years back, it's just a bug. Shit happens. They fixed it and they said they were sorry. It's not like they did it on purpose.
 
Wasn't there an article recently about how great it would be if every phone had thermometers in them reporting back to some central server? Acclimation, my friends. Welcome to your brave new world.
 
Back
Top