Apple “iPhone XS” Leaked

I'm willing to talk, you simply haven't made a valid point. You make the claim that face id and biodata on phones is secure which is empirically false. If it were secure, governments would use them, they don't. They have far different security measures they implement on mobile devices and only use specifically engineered devices for secure lines.



The government does not in any way shape or form use any off the shelf mobile device for secured communications. The fact that you are trying to make this claim tells me how little you know about how security works. You can claim strawman and all that other nonsense all you want, it won't make you suddenly right. Biometric data on any off the shell mobile device isn't secure and it is foolish to pretend otherwise.

Now please provide evidence that either Face ID or Touch ID is insecure and being used by people other than the owners of the devices.
 
I'm willing to talk, you simply haven't made a valid point. You make the claim that face id and biodata on phones is secure which is empirically false. If it were secure, governments would use them, they don't. They have far different security measures they implement on mobile devices and only use specifically engineered devices for secure lines.



The government does not in any way shape or form use any off the shelf mobile device for secured communications. The fact that you are trying to make this claim tells me how little you know about how security works. You can claim strawman and all that other nonsense all you want, it won't make you suddenly right. Biometric data on any off the shell mobile device isn't secure and it is foolish to pretend otherwise.
I'm not sure if you're trolling or actually don't understand what you are doing in your responses.

No one said that the biometric data is secure in a general sense. The only claim any of us made is that Apple can not snoop your biometric data because it is stored locally on the device in The Secure Enclave. Once again, *we* are not calling it a secure location, but Apple is calling the co-processor The Secure Enclave.

It's not secure from theft, it's not secure from hacking, but it *is* secure from Apple harvesting your fingerprints or face scan. They don't have any access to it and do not have the keys to decrypt the information. Those are the facts. Now, you can believe in a huge conspiracy that Apple is lying to the world and they do have a back door into The Secure Enclave (again, that's not a description, it's a noun Noun Examples - Examples on YourDictionary).

The second claim was yours: there are no such things as secure mobile devices.

There are. They exist. The government uses them.

Now, caught in your error, you switched it to, "any off the shelf mobile device"

Yeah, they don't use any old retail device for secure communications and I never said that they did.
The reason they don't, however, is not because it's "mobile" but rather a slew of other reasons that we won't go into and if we tried would surely go whizzing right over your head if for no other reason than you digging your heels in to argue with points you are making up.
 
If it were secure, governments would use them, they don't.
A strawman is an informal fallacy--a reasoning error. This most recent claim of yours, however, is a formal fallacy. The actual structure of your argument is faulty. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirming_the_consequent

Government use of a device is not evidence one way or the other of that device being secure in and of itself.
Government agencies use insecure devices frequently and they also refuse to use some secure devices in favor of others.
 
I'm willing to talk, you simply haven't made a valid point. You make the claim that face id and biodata on phones is secure which is empirically false. If it were secure, governments would use them, they don't. They have far different security measures they implement on mobile devices and only use specifically engineered devices for secure lines.



The government does not in any way shape or form use any off the shelf mobile device for secured communications. The fact that you are trying to make this claim tells me how little you know about how security works. You can claim strawman and all that other nonsense all you want, it won't make you suddenly right. Biometric data on any off the shell mobile device isn't secure and it is foolish to pretend otherwise.

Wrong, they 100% use OTS equipment for some secure comms - including smartphones.

If you want to argue from a place of positional authority i'm certain my positional authority is more meaningful than yours on this topic.

You keep moving the goalposts on this discussion so at this point I'm done. Needless to say the original argument was over biometric security on specifically iOS devices, and on that topic you don't even know what you're talking about.
 
Last edited:
Ill be upgrading to the new release next year. I may squeeze another year out of my 6S+.
Don't forget the $29 dollar battery replacement program if you haven't already swapped it out.
 
Honestly I first hated the fact there was no fingerprint. But my wife has had the X. I have to say that shit is quick and accurate and it just works. I mean you can hate apple all you want, I did that too. But once you use face unlock you have to admit shit is as good as advertised.
 
Don't forget the $29 dollar battery replacement program if you haven't already swapped it out.

Actually if you go online through your account, they don't charge anything. I was about to send a 6s plus even though it has 93% battery health. I haven't yet. It was free to ship and back. But its a 10 day turn around. It does also give me the option to go closest service center to me, geek squad is one of them. I am not sure if they charge in store if I book through my account. But shipping it in was 0 charge for me. I did also check if my serial was on the recall and it said it wasn't. If you go through apple's support site and select your phone and click battery issue as what you need support with it comes up as 0 instead of 30.

Its good until december this year. I am hoping AT&T increases trade in values like they did last year I think when iphone launched. if the give 300 or so tradein I will probably do that.
 
Actually if you go online through your account, they don't charge anything. I was about to send a 6s plus even though it has 93% battery health. I haven't yet. It was free to ship and back. But its a 10 day turn around. It does also give me the option to go closest service center to me, geek squad is one of them. I am not sure if they charge in store if I book through my account. But shipping it in was 0 charge for me. I did also check if my serial was on the recall and it said it wasn't. If you go through apple's support site and select your phone and click battery issue as what you need support with it comes up as 0 instead of 30.

Its good until december this year. I am hoping AT&T increases trade in values like they did last year I think when iphone launched. if the give 300 or so tradein I will probably do that.

It's worth the pain of dealing with selling on eBay if the phone is still in decent shape. You'll score an extra $200 at least.
 
It's worth the pain of dealing with selling on eBay if the phone is still in decent shape. You'll score an extra $200 at least.


No not for an iPhone 6s Plus though. I always sell here or eBay. But no way I expect to get 500 for an iPhone 6s Plus..
 
Don't forget the $29 dollar battery replacement program if you haven't already swapped it out.

Yup got mine already ;) my battery was still at 60% health, wife’s was 30% lol. I remind her of that when she claims I’m glued to my phone.

No not for an iPhone 6s Plus though. I always sell here or eBay. But no way I expect to get 500 for an iPhone 6s Plus..

I’ll probably get $200 for mine, scratches and some other cosmetic stuff but my speaker is bad (no idea why) and I think that’ll hurt my resale value.
 
Yup got mine already ;) my battery was still at 60% health, wife’s was 30% lol. I remind her of that when she claims I’m glued to my phone.



I’ll probably get $200 for mine, scratches and some other cosmetic stuff but my speaker is bad (no idea why) and I think that’ll hurt my resale value.


Did you have any screen protector on it? My battery is at 93%. That’s why I didn’t send it in. But if I send it in via filing for battery replacement online apple isn’t charging me anything so it was tempting Lol. But being at 93% I didn’t. Plus I was afraid it will probably brake my tempered glass protector when they open it up since they are so sensitive.
 
Did you have any screen protector on it? My battery is at 93%. That’s why I didn’t send it in. But if I send it in via filing for battery replacement online apple isn’t charging me anything so it was tempting Lol. But being at 93% I didn’t. Plus I was afraid it will probably brake my tempered glass protector when they open it up since they are so sensitive.
No I didn’t have a screen protector on, they also warn you that you do have one on it may break.
 
Wrong, they 100% use OTS equipment for some secure comms - including smartphones.

If you want to argue from a place of positional authority i'm certain my positional authority is more meaningful than yours on this topic.

You keep moving the goalposts on this discussion so at this point I'm done. Needless to say the original argument was over biometric security on specifically iOS devices, and on that topic you don't even know what you're talking about.

Yea I was about to just dip my toe into the conversation with the OTS comment. If POTUS uses OTS I’m sure most organizations do.

The entire Signal Corps for the Army is OTS for all routing & switching, voice, etc. the only thing not OTS are most of the radios.
 
Back
Top