Apple Borks iTunes Sync with Pre Again

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
If you’re a Palm Pre user enjoying your iTunes syncing, don’t upgrade to the latest version of iTunes (9.0.2). This update breaks the sync ability between your Pre and iTunes again. At first glance, it’s easy to blame Apple for being jerks about this but there are always two sides to any conflict.

When Palm first introduced the Pre earlier this year, a key feature was the device’s ability to easily sync music with iTunes through the USB port. The feature was a clever trick on Palm’s part. Palm masked the Pre’s identity to iTunes. “What Palm did was identify the Pre as a recognizable device for iTunes so iTunes treats it like an iPod, which also meant Palm didn’t have to write a separate application to do this,” Hazelton said.
 
Apple is the embodiment, and purveyor of the death of the principles the internet and democratic access. Steve, you know what, there's a reason you have cancer my friend. Greed seems like such a stupid thing to fight for when you're dying.
 
I side with Apple on this one. Palm is just being too lazy to write their own software. Apple has ready available an SDK for itunes syncing for third party devices, hell, Blackberry uses it. So why can't Palm use it? Answer: LAZY

Apple wrote the software, all decisions regarding it are up to them. Palm is not entitled to Apple's software just because they suck too much to write their own
 
I side with Apple as well.

Palm needs to get off their asses and write their own shit or use the tools Apple as put out. Faking out iTunes making it think the pre is a iPod is not the way to do it.

Hell didn't the people that govern USB come down on Palm about this? If they did they didn't do it hard enough.
 
Surely this is anti-competitive? Apple is using their dominant position in the market for a music sales application to force users to buy their music player. Certainly within the EU this is clear-cut and illegal. It's just like MS bundling their browser and music player with their O/S, or indeed Apple forcing you to buy their hardware to run their O/S. I'm amazed no-one has taken Apple down over this given the way people go after Microsoft for far less egregious offences.
 
Surely this is anti-competitive? Apple is using their dominant position in the market for a music sales application to force users to buy their music player. Certainly within the EU this is clear-cut and illegal. It's just like MS bundling their browser and music player with their O/S, or indeed Apple forcing you to buy their hardware to run their O/S. I'm amazed no-one has taken Apple down over this given the way people go after Microsoft for far less egregious offences.

Because people care more about the company's name than their actions. Microsoft will be prosecuted for antitrust violations because they're Microsoft, and Apple won't be because they're Apple. Regardless of what they've done.
 
I really don't understand what the problem is. I don't have to use itunes to sync my player, but I choose to because it's convenient. Or is it having to use itunes to buy music? Unless i'm missing something you can always just add the music in to another player and sync with that as well.
 
Surely this is anti-competitive? Apple is using their dominant position in the market for a music sales application to force users to buy their music player. Certainly within the EU this is clear-cut and illegal. It's just like MS bundling their browser and music player with their O/S, or indeed Apple forcing you to buy their hardware to run their O/S. I'm amazed no-one has taken Apple down over this given the way people go after Microsoft for far less egregious offences.
iTunes is the property of Apple, why should the government have any say what they do with their property.

I sure as hell wouldn't want gov't coming along and telling me I have to let some vagabonds live in my basement. Or confiscate something I had built, to give it to someone else, based on some arbitrary concept of "they need it more than you, even though you created it". They do this shit already, why push for more violation of rights?
 
iTunes is the property of Apple, why should the government have any say what they do with their property.

While I agree with you 10 million percent, remember what they did to Microsoft for trying to offer the customer a complete computing experience.
 
I can't see people siding with apple, um, why should they have to write an application for something they should be able to do in the first place? obviously there is not a software issue if all they had to do was misidentify the product. if it worked out of the box with itunes then by all means it should continue. making 3 parties jump through unnecessary hoops to avoid competition is simply wrong. if they were bypassing anything but this I could see but that just isn't the case. If its compatible it should not be prevented from running.
 
So by that logic, if I have a bicycle, you should be able to come over and ride it whenever you want?
 
This argument always reminds me of Iron Man movie.. Stark has a brilliant idea, Stane is jealous and tries to kill Stark to take control of the idea: "You think just because you have an idea that it belongs to you???"

Good thing Stark fights back and ultimately wins..

Apple made something special, like it or not. It's their idea, so it belongs to them. If they don't want to support someone else's crap hardware, they can do that, because they write the software.

Like I said, if Palm wants to let the Pre sync with iTunes, Apple has a SDK for that purpose. Palm just needs to take a little time and write an app for it.
 
So by that logic, if I have a bicycle, you should be able to come over and ride it whenever you want?

how about more like "DOS isn't done until lotus won't run"

they do not disallow 3rd party devices so they say, they provide a SDK to do so. Palm just made theirs emulate a supported device. just how is this issue equatable to your statement?

and by your logic you should not be using anything but MS


and really, Apple never directly complained that they were doing something bad, the only thing they could do is bitch about breaking USB standards
 
I have a question. What if MS made Windows incompatible with Itunes?? How would Apple feel?

Windows is by design compatible with iTunes.
iTunes by design isn't compatible with anything but an iPod.

There's a difference.
 
Steve, you know what, there's a reason you have cancer my friend.
Ouch.

Surely this is anti-competitive? Apple is using their dominant position in the market for a music sales application to force users to buy their music player.
The iTunes Music Store and the iTunes iPod sync functionality are separate. You can buy music from iTunes and sync it to any device compatible with AAC audio, including Microsoft's own portable players -- just not with iTunes. If your library consists of the older FairPlay-protected stuff, you can strip the DRM (easily) or simply do what Jobs has suggested in the past: burn it to a CD and rip it, thus stripping the DRM.

Apple's concerns over third-party hardware/software tying into their own software's functionality is unfortunate but legitimate.
 
Why on earth would anyone actually want to use itunes? I only start that laggy, bug ridden POS when I absolutely have to. I refuse to even install it on my primary computer. I think Apple is doing Pre owners a favor.
 
As alluded to above - those are very different circumstances.

Windows is by design compatible with iTunes.
iTunes by design isn't compatible with anything but an iPod.

There's a difference.

I dont think that you understand what im asking.What if windows only mandated that WMP is the only media player for their OS? And Apple wasnt even allowed to have their itunes on their OS? I just dont see what the fuss is about from apple point of view. The more people using itunes service means more potential customers buying from their store. They didnt have a fit with pocket mac okaying blackberries to syncing music with itunes. Or there was another app that let you sync itunes with blackberry phones. But they are going all out against the pre. I just dont get it.
 
Back
Top