Anything wrong with this sub-$1300 system? (another first build)

dusty_p_42

n00b
Joined
Jul 25, 2007
Messages
6
See everything I got on my Newegg wishlist.

Case:
Lian Li PC-A05B

Processor:
Intel C2D 6750 2.66 GHz

Motherboard:
Asus P5K Deluxe/Wifi-AP

Video:
Evga GeForce 8800gts 320 MB

RAM:
Corsair XMS2 DDR2-800 (2 GB)

PSU:
Thermaltake Purepower RX 500W

HDD:
Western Digital Caviar 250 GB (SATA)

DVD:
Lite-On 20x (SATA)

All told it came to about $1230. Did I make any horrible mistakes other than maybe spending too much on the motherboard?
 
The E6750 is cheaper at mwave.com than newegg.

Yah, the main problem is the PSU. Choose a non thermaltake, lol. The XClio Stablepower 460W would be a better choice. If you have the budget for it, go for the Corsair 520W from buy.com ($80AR).

I hope the corsair ram you chose is around $85 without a rebate. If not, choose something else, that doesnt have a rebate. No point lending corsair/newegg your money just for them to give it back after 1.5 months. Look at the 2GBNQ kit from G.Skill, or the Super Talent DDR2-800 kit. For a better deal, go to frys.com and pickup two Patriot LLK 1GB sticks at $40 each. Much better timings (4-4-4-12) than those corsairs, and most likely cheaper.

I hope your primary reason for choosing the P5K Deluxe wasn't for the WiFi. WiFi cards/usb dongles are cheap, so no need for onboard wifi. If you're not using all the extra features of the deluxe, drop down to a GA-P35-DS3R instead and save A LOT of money. The DS3R is a great board, so don't think less of it just because its cheaper than that overpriced Asus.

Personally, I'd drop down to the DS3R, saving you ~$90. Then, you could upgrade some other component, like the CPU, PSU or Vidcard (up it to the 640MB if you need it). What size monitor do you have?

FYI, your wishlist link doesnt work.
 
The E6750 is cheaper at mwave.com than newegg.

Yah, the main problem is the PSU. Choose a non thermaltake, lol. The XClio Stablepower 460W would be a better choice. If you have the budget for it, go for the Corsair 520W from buy.com ($80AR).

I hope the corsair ram you chose is around $85 without a rebate. If not, choose something else, that doesnt have a rebate. No point lending corsair/newegg your money just for them to give it back after 1.5 months. Look at the 2GBNQ kit from G.Skill, or the Super Talent DDR2-800 kit. For a better deal, go to frys.com and pickup two Patriot LLK 1GB sticks at $40 each. Much better timings (4-4-4-12) than those corsairs, and most likely cheaper.

I hope your primary reason for choosing the P5K Deluxe wasn't for the WiFi. WiFi cards/usb dongles are cheap, so no need for onboard wifi. If you're not using all the extra features of the deluxe, drop down to a GA-P35-DS3R instead and save A LOT of money. The DS3R is a great board, so don't think less of it just because its cheaper than that overpriced Asus.

Personally, I'd drop down to the DS3R, saving you ~$90. Then, you could upgrade some other component, like the CPU, PSU or Vidcard (up it to the 640MB if you need it). What size monitor do you have?

FYI, your wishlist link doesnt work.

I've already ordered everything. Probably should've checked here first. Anyway, The RAM after rebate is still going to be like $120, so I guess I got screwed a bit on it. However, Newegg says the timing is 4-4-4-12. As for the board, I let a friend pick it out (mistake). It was mostly for the wi-fi and the SP/DIF, and the fact that it was an Asus. I have a 20.1" Viewsonic HDTV/Monitor which won't even do 1080p, so it's not something I will be able to push up to insane resolutions.

So if I overspent on the board by $90 less $30 for the wi-fi dongle, and on the RAM by about $40, $100 total isn't too awful :rolleyes: Also, I'm not sure why the wishlist won't work, but you can search Newegg's lists for "PC 2007 CDP" if you really want to see it.
 
If I were you, I'd mainly be concerned with that crappy PSU killing every expensive component I just bought, especially since I overpaid by $100.

Asus support sux. SPDIF is available on the alternative boards, but o wellz.

The only compatibility is the PSU... it may not provide enough juice for that power hungry mobo, vidcard, and CPU if you're OCing it. BTW, if you want to OC, you should really pickup a Scythe Ninja Plus Rev.B, Tuniq Tower, or Ultra 120 Extreme w/ sFlex fan.
 
Yep. I'd be seriously considering paying a 15% restocking fee and exchanging the PSU and motherboard both to recoup some of the loss. The RAM, if you sent it back in, would cost too much in restocking fees to have the replacement come out any less expensive. The unfortunate thing is you could have a GTX for all you paid 'extra'.
 
Ok, well what PSU and motherboard (and RAM) should I exchange them for? Preferably nothing with terribly loud fans. Also, it would be great if anybody could make a wi-fi card recommendation (no USB). But I'm not sure what you're talking about the the GTX. Even if I got $100 back on the board and $50 on the PSU and got a wi-fi card for $30 (netting +$120), the cheapest GTX I've seen is still $220 more than the GTS I got.

I already got Newegg to waive the restocking fee for another video card I bought in the same order, so maybe I can have them extend it to the motherboard and PSU. Thanks for the help guys.
 
Whats your budget for the PSU? There were two purepower 500W psu's listed at newegg, which is why I was looking for your wishlist (but couldnt find that either). The two models I listed earlier (460W stablepower and 520W corsair) are similarly priced to the two purepowers, and are of much better quality. The Stablepower is $50 and the Corsair is cheaper from zipzoomfly ($95AR) or buy.com ($80AR) -- Newegg wants $115AR I believe.

As I mentioned earlier, the GA-P35-DS3R is a good alternative. The Abit IP35 boards are popular as well. Go with whichever featureset serves your needs the best.

What size monitor do you have?

Newegg will waive restocking fees if you buy replacements from them.
 
Back
Top