Anyone have experience with MSI's Eclipse Plus?

Cannydog

Gawd
Joined
Aug 11, 2004
Messages
669
Ok, so I bought another 920 (this time I paid a bit more to get a D0 core...). Now I'm looking for a new motherboard. And it's not that I'm unhappy with my P6T, but there are a few bits about the layout that could be better. For instance: I'd like to have a x1 PCIe slot above the top video slot for a good sound card. Also, I'd like to have a full 6 "regular SATA" slots, at a right angle, on the edge of the board - the P6T has two slots that are basically "RAID for dummies". I'm planning on 2-way SLI with PhysX, so I don't want a board that will drop my second video slot to x8 when I plug in a 3rd card. And finally, I want at least one eSATA port in the I/O panel, as I use this for external backups.

The only boards I know of besides the vanilla P6T that fill most of these requirements are MSI boards... So I'd sure like to hear from some MSI Eclipse owners, and specifically from some Eclipse Plus owners. And I thank you for your time.
 
I have the Eclipse SLI, and to be honest, I had a few issues when I first got the board, but a BIOS flash later, it's been gravy. I know Dan_D and Kyle had an issue with their Eclipse SLI and running memory at a certain timing with their corsair memory, but I could not replicate the issue with my OCZ DDR3.

All in all, I'd say I love this board. I can run my i7 920 c0@ 4.2 ghz with a xigmatek dark knight, and it holds it's own.

Here's a review on the overclocking prowess of the board:

http://www.neoseeker.com/Articles/Hardware/Reviews/msi_x58_eclipse/

I was looking for a company to replace abit for myself when they went under, and it looks like MSI is the front runner, although I've never tried a gigabyte board, which is another option that I'd leave open for myself.
 
I know Dan_D and Kyle had an issue with their Eclipse SLI and running memory at a certain timing with their corsair memory, but I could not replicate the issue with my OCZ DDR3.

How exactly did you "replicate" our testing when you seem to be a little fuzzy on what the testing was actually about?
 
Part of me wishes I hadn't held out on buying the EVGA Confidential Limited Edition. Because it has the NF200 chip. Along the same line, the Eclipse Plus has the same chip for a true x16/x16/x16 configuration. But I'm not sure some of the other features are as good.

On the other hand, it makes sense that different boards should improve with a few more BIOS updates. (And I can see that there is a 1.6 revision for the Eclipse SLI.) And since it has most of the things I want, it's still under consideration.

So I'll ask another more pointed question. Which you may, or may not, be able to answer... I want to water cool just the CPU with this system. I'll also have a set of Corsair memory modules with a fan on them. All in a CM HAF 932 case. How hot do the copper coolers get on the Eclipse SLI? I've heard the sinks on the Plus get pretty warm. But I don't really want to cool these areas with water because attaching those blocks can be a royal pain. So if the Eclipse SLI can get by with some extra air in that area. That would bump it up a notch in my estimation.

The one thing I don't like about the Eclipse SLI is those 4 SATA connectors mounted so the cables would stick out from the board. Cause I can tell you right now they'll never get used. Along the same lines, the Eclipse Plus has no PATA - something else I'll never use! Still I don't care about all the extraneous junk for overclocking outside of the BIOS, on either board. I'd be far more impressed if I knew the boards had a feature that prevented V-Droop. (But I'm not sure there is such a feature!)

I feel like I'm stuck. Most of the boards won't really allow use of 3 video cards. And if they do, it forces you into a x16/x8/x8 configuration with onboard sound. So I'm left making a choice between two boards that I'm just not sure about... That's why I'm hear asking for feedback. Seriously, I've read all the reviews I can find. So I'm asking owners, who only have a little pride at stake...

Oh! I know what I forgot to ask. Have you tried running without the "Green Power Gene" thing attached? I'm not going to use it! I mean if it was something that had a right angle, and plugged directly into the motherboard. That would be different. As it is that thing looks awful, and people will be able to see into my case. So if there are issues related to not using it... I'll just get a second P6T!
 
The Eclipse has 6 facing the front of the PC. I don't have the genie hooked up, it starved my CPU for power and my pc would reset when I was overclocking.

I threw it away.

[H] did a review about the nf200 vs no nf200 chip, and the nf200 chip actually slowed it down.
 
The Eclipse has 6 facing the front of the PC. I don't have the genie hooked up, it starved my CPU for power and my pc would reset when I was overclocking.

I threw it away.

[H] did a review about the nf200 vs no nf200 chip, and the nf200 chip actually slowed it down.

Doh! I missed that video... and that is extremely informative! Thank you for pointing that out to me. And thank you for letting me know about that Gene thing. I owe you one!
 
What Gene thing?

edit: You mean Greenpower Genie.

No problem.
 
http://hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1034070274&postcount=126

http://hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1034071463&postcount=129

I was going off of what you were saying at 8/8/8/24/1T, which I've been able to run fine. I was starting to wonder if you had a defective board or something.

Unless there's something here I'm totally not seeing.

"Going off of" or replicating?

Also, if you read the review you will see where this issue was specifically addressed with MSI. So please don't say you are replicating our testing when you are likely not, and you have not fully read the article that addresses this issue.
 
By replicating he means he never had the problem you guys had or was able to produce it with his experience with the board.
 
Well, I don't know how I missed the part about the NF200 slowing things down. I guess if I had paid more attention to the P6T6 Workstation board, I would have then taken a look at that article... However, armed with that info I went back to square one and decided to go for the one board that might actually compensate for VDroop - the EVGA Confidential. The other factor is that I do have more confidence in EVGA, especially when it comes to Customer Service. Also on the plus side, I know there will be water blocks designed for the Confidential if I decide to eventually go that route.

Still this doesn't mean that I think Asus and MSI boards are bad! But I think in the end I'll be happier with this particular EVGA. Even though it means I give up the BIOS based flash utility. Now I just need to decide what parts to get for water-cooling.

Thanks again RADEoN, you were very helpful. :)
 
http://hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1034070274&postcount=126

http://hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1034071463&postcount=129

I was going off of what you were saying at 8/8/8/24/1T, which I've been able to run fine. I was starting to wonder if you had a defective board or something.

Unless there's something here I'm totally not seeing.

Unless you have the exact same hardware we used down to the firmware levels of each piece of hardware, identical PCB revisions for all hardware, BIOS versions, BIOS settings, and identical software to that which we used, it would be impossible for you to "replicate" our testing. About all you can say is that the MSI Eclipse SLI doesn't have the same problems Kyle experienced with your hardware. His experience, and your experiences aren't going to match mine exactly either. So while you didn't experience the same problem did, and that in itself is useful, it doesn't diminish or invalidate our efforts or test results in any way shape or form. The results aren't directly comparable to ours. Also bear in mind that part of the reason why all the board reviews you see on this site go through the hands of two people is to give you a better idea and a better sampling of what one might expect with a given board. I use a different CPU, CPU cooling, hard drives, power supply, memory and software than Kyle does. When he set us up to do these articles he made sure what we had was different. As a result on occasion I'll get completely different results than Kyle did. Most of the time we have similar thoughts on a given board but every now and again I'll really like a board, he'll hate that same board or vise versa.
 
yes... I did mean Classified! I'm only suffering from minor sleep deprivation. I'll get over it by the end of next week. ;)
 
So far my experiences with the EVGA X58 3X SLI Classified have all been positive.
 
Actually, I never claimed to "replicate your testing", I claimed to be able to run my ram at the settings you were having problems with, without any error.

On the contrary, I said I was UNABLE to replicate the error, even though I tried to with those RAM settings you said here:

Well you are using OCZ RAM. I'm sure there is other RAM that will work just as well and there is probably other RAM that won't work so well if at all. Still, problems like this with Corsair RAM is really a difficult thing for me to accept given the popularity and quality of Corsair RAM today.
 
Well you are using OCZ RAM. I'm sure there is other RAM that will work just as well and there is probably other RAM that won't work so well if at all. Still, problems like this with Corsair RAM is really a difficult thing for me to accept given the popularity and quality of Corsair RAM today.

I totally agree, hence my post. I think you and Kyle were given a defective/problematic board from MSI. I was stating that because if there's a problem like that in a review, especially by reviewers as credible as you and kyle, there's possibly a big problem.

I think its an isolated incident related to a build problem on that board.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
I think I finally see what you're saying.

I wasn't trying to replicate your review of the board. I did however try to replicate an instability issue with the memory running at the same settings you noticed an issue with, which I could not do. Its been at these timings for months now, and under normal usage and up to prime95, I never have issues.

I understand it doesn't invalidate anyone elses experience.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
Back
Top