AMD Suspending Several Phenom CPUs?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
DigiTimes is reporting that AMD has suspended several Phenom processors until the company makes the move to 45nm process technology. Some processors are reportedly being shelved altogether. Thanks to forum member pxc for the tip.

AMD originally planned to launch two 65nm dual-core Phenom processors codenamed Kuma for the desktop PC market in May or June this year, however the company has recently suspended the plans and will let its Athlon X2 5600B processor cover the market until the company enters 45nm production, according to sources at motherboard makers.
 
All i can say is Bummer I guess, or good that they have decided not to waste resources on such products. Amd is betting the farm on its 45nm process and it better deliver results soon.
 
i say this is a big mistake, its just another way for intel to make more money
 
i say this is a big mistake, its just another way for intel to make more money

umm no i think it is very good they are not wasting resources on a processors that are on a old process. everything new from amd minus the new mobile chips will be 45nm and with 45nm amd should be in a competitive position with intel even after intel's new monster is out.
 
Their current X2 line up is enough for the price point of the dual core CPUs.
 
Doesn't sound good. i prefer AMD/ATI but the last few months has been really ruff for us. This is just another dagger in my back. I am really wanting to upgrade to Quad core but I would really like to get one thats at least 3ghz and I dont want to have to overclock.
 
I don't think there would be much performance difference between a dual-core Phenom and the X2 5600B.

Sounds like a good business move. What's the point of buying a Phenom if you're not going triple or quad-core? None.
 
Sounds likely that the 45nm process is progressing well if they do this. Although it could be purely cost motivated.
 
I guess there aren't many Phenoms with two defective cores?

The Phenom is significantly faster than the X2 clock for clock, so from a performance perspective, a dual-core Phenom makes sense.. I hope the transition to 45nm is a smooth one so they can start delivering again, at least in the low-end and mid-range segments.
 
Its good that they recognize the fact that they are trailing behind Intel. What isn't good is the fact that its now going to take more time and money to get these things on a 45nm process, unless they miraculously have it ready by the end of the month, and it turns out to be a swift kick to Intel's balls. I don't think AMD can hold out much longer if they don't start offering up something good.
 
Just when you think AMD can't shoot themselves in the foot any more... A cheap dual-core Phenom is really the only thing that would keep AMD competitive now, considering they're almost as fast clock-for-clock as the C2Ds whereas the A64 X2s are completely outclassed. Right now AMD is doing well in the low-end market on price alone, but with a dual-core Phenom they could compete in terms of both price and performance.

The longer they wait to bring out chips to compete with Intel, the more time Intel has to push out their next generation of chips and render anything AMD has to offer obsolete. Once Nehalem comes out, chances are that current-generation quads will drop to current dual-core pricing and dual-cores will become very cheap, and then AMD will have lost their edge in price as well.
 
Well it could be that the dual core Kuma's just don't scale that well on the 65 nm process. AMD wanted to have 3GHz Phenoms but they just haven't been able to do it on 65 nm unless they dump massive amounts of electricity into it (yielding lots of heat and pushing what many motherboards can handle). The bottom line is that their 65 nm process is holding them back. The 65 nm X2s are a good value and have good power usage characteristics within a certain envelope, but there is a reason that the fastest X2s (i.e. 6000+ and above) are still on 90 nm. The 65 nm Phenoms look to be officially limited to the 2.5 GHz range, though the overclocking crowd can push it higher.

If AMD has a decent 45 nm process, then it makes sense to move to it as fast as possible. The big question is whether they can somehow limit the electricity leakage problems at that level or if we will be stuck with another family of power efficient chips below 2.5 GHz and hungry beasts above that. It's my understanding that this is why Intel switched to their High-K dielectric process for their 45 nm chips.
 
From here:
Now, AMD being a smaller company than its competitor in both resources and finances, it has to optimize the use of its engineering resources. So while they would like to make a 3GHz Phenom right now, they've tradeoffs to make. Right now, its OEM partners/customers just want more processors, but they aren't asking for a 3GHz Phenom since they don't sell such high-speed quad-core machines and only those who deal in the boutique end of the market selling $3000 to $4000 machines to gamers really deal with this sort of needs. AMD explained that their major partners like HP, Dell, Lenovo and others aren't asking for 3GHz quad-core Phenom processors. However, they are requesting for ever more energy efficient chips, so that they can keep making machines smaller and cooler.
 
Regardless of their inability to produce a high-speed quad within a reasonable power envelope, there's nothing preventing them from producing a decent dual-core part which would obviously require substantially less power than a similarly-clocked quad. They're just continually delaying all their products, but eventually they'll reach the point where they just can't delay any longer and their products won't be competitive. If they wait until 2009 to bring out these chips, Nehalem will already be available and there won't be any compelling reason to buy AMD's chips with cheaper and faster alternatives from Intel being readily available.
 
The 65 nm X2s are a good value and have good power usage characteristics within a certain envelope, but there is a reason that the fastest X2s (i.e. 6000+ and above) are still on 90 nm.

There must be something wrong with AMD's 65nm process. The CPUs (Phenom and Brisbane X2's) just don't seem to like clock frequencies above 3 GHz. In the X2 line, the fastest CPUs have always been the 90nm ones which is really strange. It seems 90nm X2's overclock better too, as long as you have very good cooling to remove the excess heat.

Small, cool, energy efficient and quiet is the trend these days so it makes sense to move to the 45nm process as fast as possible. Maybe AMD isn't making enough profit from the 65nm Phenom chips, so it's better to just remove some of them from the lineup.
 
i hope amd comes back as i've been a big fan and most of my builds have been them :(
 
I've had to delay my most recent upgrade because 45nm is around the corner. Can't wait AMD get those chips made!
 
Back
Top