AMD Ryzen 7 Review Roundup

I was really hoping AMD would come through for gaming. Looks like I might be picking up a 7700k.
Is anyone still optimistic about 4/6 core ryzen performance for gaming?

I find it funny that people are still whipping it out to piss on AMD since the Ryzen is slower on gaming in some respects than top Intel CPUs. But at the same time ignore the fact Ryzen was superior on serous applications like transcoding and rendering. This is where it REALLY counts. If you need CPU power for content creation , or for video and graphics rendering this is the big time winner. This is where you money is, and being 8 or 10 frames slower on certain games is meaningless.
Good grief, is playing games all that really matter?

-Your Dad
 
I find it funny that people are still whipping it out to piss on AMD since the Ryzen is slower on gaming in some respects than top Intel CPUs. But at the same time ignore the fact Ryzen was superior on serous applications like transcoding and rendering. This is where it REALLY counts. If you need CPU power for content creation , or for video and graphics rendering this is the big time winner. This is where you money is, and being 8 or 10 frames slower on certain games is meaningless.
Good grief, is playing games all that really matter?

-Your Dad


My dad doesn't stick his head that far in the sand.
 
After having gone through a lot of the reviews out there, the general message, objectively, seems to be if you really place a non-marginal value on gaming performance, stick to Intel. It is now and most likely will be better. What has changed is, if you're planning on building a workstation primarily, you should *not* buy an Intel right now. Productivity app numbers overall favor AMD at the high end (until prohibitively expensive) and will most likely be that way through the rest of the stack as they're released. You couldn't say this before (with a straight face). I do actually do a fair amount of db work and research at home and I've just accepted poorer gaming performance overall. The extra cost of platform jumping for moderate productivity gain and substantial gaming improvement always hung around, though. Now I can pick up even more substantial work throughput and still get a nice gaming bump without breaking the bank. The 1800X was never something I would seriously consider. My money is just waiting for reviews of the 1700X vs non-X, to see if the lower tdp is gimping the potential performance of the 1700.
 
AMD needs to release dual socket consumer boards. That'd be AWESOME and would really mess with Intel. 16C/32T for $1k....yes please.

BP
 
I find it funny that people are still whipping it out to piss on AMD since the Ryzen is slower on gaming in some respects than top Intel CPUs. But at the same time ignore the fact Ryzen was superior on serous applications like transcoding and rendering. This is where it REALLY counts. If you need CPU power for content creation , or for video and graphics rendering this is the big time winner. This is where you money is, and being 8 or 10 frames slower on certain games is meaningless.
Good grief, is playing games all that really matter?

-Your Dad

Yes, it is all that matters to me. Is that cool with you? If not, send me a list of parts in your rig so I can build something that will fit your needs for myself.
 
AMD could salvage the gaming market if the 6 core version is 400Mhz faster than the 1800X.
 
Nah, not interested. Having to buy a new mb and cpu just ain't worth it. Then there is the work to build it. I'm gaming fine with an i5 3570K@4.2ghz and a GTX1070@1920x1080. Don't need any better, IMO.
 
Lots of hype, not quite living up to it. That $400 and $500 price tag isn't exactly what I was thinking when everyone was talking this chip up. At $500 you'd need to have a specific workload for these to make sense. I'd say it would make a good server, but if I'm spending $500 on a cpu I'd probably get something that at least supports ECC. (And DDR3 ECC so I don't have to pay through the roof for it) Then obviously it offers nothing new for gaming that I had 6 years ago. So in my book the only real win would be encoding where I could take advantage of SMP but not be too concerned about data loss. That makes it a pretty hard sell when I just can deal with longer encoding times and save a couple hundred dollars and pick up an Intel chip which is better for everything else.

At $300? I'd be very interested taking a hit in a couple areas for some extra encoding speed, but there are much better choices in the price range it's at.
 
The benchmarks seem insanely fast for integer math, low complexity algorithms, hashing, and encryption tasks. I know that's not a big interest around these parts, but it is very impressive.

I don't need an upgrade right now, but I'll most likely go this route in the future. Still rocking the Vishera cores for now. :)
 
Well done AMD! Ryzen is definitely going on my list, but I don't need to upgrade right now. I would like to see a greater price differential but that may come in time.
 
As I have said in another thread, my main problem with Ryzen is that they are putting Extreme CPUs into motherboards from 2 or 3 gens ago. The chipset features look closer to my Z97 motherboard than Z270 motherboard, which is a minus IMHO.

CPU is a beast if you need the CPU, if you need anything else though, that's a different question.
 
NEXT, what else you got.

Not an AMD fan but had hopes they would really drop the hammer on Intel this time to force some competition, I stand disappointed. I stated before if they would give Intel a run for there money I would buy one and sit it on the shelf just to goad them along with much needed support, guess I'll pass on that and buy more fencing for my chickens. I just don't see AMD getting out of this second fiddle position and I find that very nfortunate for us all.
 
NEXT, what else you got.

Not an AMD fan but had hopes they would really drop the hammer on Intel this time to force some competition, I stand disappointed. I stated before if they would give Intel a run for there money I would buy one and sit it on the shelf just to goad them along with much needed support, guess I'll pass on that and buy more fencing for my chickens. I just don't see AMD getting out of this second fiddle position and I find that very unfortunate for us all.

I can't see how this is a FAIL for AMD.
The top chip equals or exceeds performance of Intels top chip for in some aspects for half the price. Considering the capital for R&D Intel has over AMD, this is NOTHING but a win. The increase in performance over the previous generation AM3+ CPUs is tremendous. And everyone is bitching an moaning about their disappointment. o_O
 
but too many strikes against Ryzen for my needs.
How many strikes? It doesn't perform as well as the 7700K at gaming, and mostly outperforms the 2600K at gaming. That's about the performance many people were hoping for a few months ago. In fact, many people were saying that they'd go buy one if it were "only" that fast. Plus, compared to the 6900K, it isn't that far behind in gaming. Sheesh - Intel's selling a $1000 processor that can't even come close to competing with a $339 processor in games - Intel should just shut down and quit selling processors right now....Oh wait, that $339 processor that beats Intel's flagship in gaming so bad is made by....Intel!

PCIe lanes - Genuine concern, but the the Ryzen CPU has more lanes than the i7. It's the chipset that is limited. And frankly, the number of people who really need the extra lanes are very few and limited. SLI/Crossfire gaming is dead, and if you're using productivity work that requires multi-GPU at full lanes, then none of these platforms are what you're looking for.

Just curious, how is Intel not "competitive on price"? $299 7700K beats a $500 Ryzen for the workloads most of us are interested in, excepting maybe video transcoding.
$299 only if you live close to a MicroCenter. I live within "driving distance" - meaning it takes me just under 2 hours one way to get there. Factor in gas, sales tax, lunch, and if time is money, that makes it much more expensive than ordering online at the higher prices.

And if you are saying "workloads most of us are interested in" the only type that 7700K consistently beat even $349 1700 at was gaming. Again, if gaming is what you are looking for, you could take into consideration that Intel's $1000 CPU does not even come close to matching the 7700K, but destroys it in productivity. Ryzen is positioned against 6900K, and does quite well against that $1000 CPU

Few games really take advantage of more than 2 to 4 cores. Since Ryzen's weakness is in single core performance, it's doubtful a bios update or micro-code update will fix a thing. You need raw MHz here.

But I wouldn't worry too much. With this much horsepower, it's rare that a game will be held back that much with a decent GPU at hi-res.
While Ryzen is weaker than Intel in single thread performance, the difference there should not translate to the huge difference in 1080p gaming. If the gaming performance deficit of Ryzen was along the lines of the productivity single thread performance, there wouldn't be the complaining. It is perplexing, when looking at the results - either the gaming results should be better, or the other single thread benchmarks should be worse.

Now, I have a question/point of my own - I saw referenced in one of the other threads that there was a game test that, while the Ryzen chip showed considerably less FPS than the 7700K, the actual real gameplay was smoother. I just scanned results of the reviews, so I can't point to where it was. If this is true, and repeatable, wouldn't that experience be desireable for most gamers? I'd really love to see [H] do their normal gaming reviews and take that into consideration.
 
I'm so torn between going 1700x, or 6850k. Or waiting for the R5 6 cores and Skylake X...
 
Nah, not interested. Having to buy a new mb and cpu just ain't worth it. Then there is the work to build it. I'm gaming fine with an i5 3570K@4.2ghz and a GTX1070@1920x1080. Don't need any better, IMO.

The work to build it is the fun part, though. If you do not enjoy building the computers, I think you are missing out on one of the best parts of owning a computer. That and all I had to do is put my Windows 8 Pro key in and bam, it activated in Windows 10 Pro, no issues at all. :)
 
The work to build it is the fun part, though. If you do not enjoy building the computers, I think you are missing out on one of the best parts of owning a computer. That and all I had to do is put my Windows 8 Pro key in and bam, it activated in Windows 10 Pro, no issues at all. :)

F Win10, do not want. :p

I have built many computers and have 4 sitting here that I built myself but I see it as more of a necessity than fun.
 
Back
Top