AMD, Intel Team to Improve Game Physics

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
We posted the press release on this earlier today but I want to see what you guys think today's AMD / Havok deal means to PhysX? With both Intel and AMD going with Havok, things aren’t looking too good for team AGEIA.

"By working with the clear market leader in physics software, AMD can optimize our platforms to consistently deliver the best possible visual experience to the gamer," added AMD graphics product VP Rick Bergman.
 
This is purely my opinion, but PhysX was already hovering over the grave and this will surely push it into the grave. I always thought it was an overpriced product that just never got the mass market appeal from the developers and the gamers. Put it on the shelf of other failed products.
 
This is purely my opinion, but PhysX was already hovering over the grave and this will surely push it into the grave. I always thought it was an overpriced product that just never got the mass market appeal from the developers and the gamers. Put it on the shelf of other failed products.

The hardware yes, not the software, which NVIDIA transfered to CUDA. Any CUDA GPU will be able to process physics, as long as there is support from the developers. Since NVIDIA's TWIMTBP program is so vast, I'm sure they'll push their API for physics, to developers.
 
plus, why would AMD or intel go with AGEIA? its a competeing product

havok is a software suite that uses CPU to calculate physics, and AGEIA's libraries use it's own hardware (CPU and mem) of what benefit would it be for a CPU maker to back them?
 
This is purely my opinion, but PhysX was already hovering over the grave and this will surely push it into the grave. I always thought it was an overpriced product that just never got the mass market appeal from the developers and the gamers. Put it on the shelf of other failed products.

I think the main reason PhysX wasn't successful is because it's additional (and expensive) hardware, and the fact that it's optional. I hope AMD and Intel will integrate PhysX into their processors so we won't have to waste a PCI or PCI-E slot on PhysX cards. Hopefully this way, developers will make more PhysX games too due to not having to worry about alienating AEGIA or Havoc's fan base by choosing one over the other.
 
I should have said "integrated Havoc's software into their processors similarly to how they have 3DNow! and SSE instructions.", not hardware.
 
plus, why would AMD or intel go with AGEIA? its a competeing product

havok is a software suite that uses CPU to calculate physics, and AGEIA's libraries use it's own hardware (CPU and mem) of what benefit would it be for a CPU maker to back them?

I think you missed the point. Havok is a subsidiary of Intel. By using Havok, AMD is literally giving Intel money and Intel is AMD's biggest competitor. I don't see the logic in doing this, because as soon as Larrabee is out, I'm not sure what kind of support AMD will have from Havok, especially considering Intel's less than stellar practices of excluding who they want from whatever they want.
 
Precisely. NVIDIA purchased AGEIA so that they could port PhysX to CUDA, meaning they will have hardware-based technology that already exists and has been shown to work (although it hasn't even been used to half of its potential). This, combined with the mass-market appeal of a GPU with CUDA means advanced physics computation will be more easily accessible to every developer to implement in their games, instead of making AWESOME EXPLOSIONS :)rolleyes:) for a small group of people with PhysX cards.
 
So both AMD and Intel are going to push Havok... which is available for free from Intel if I remember correctly.

And both Nvidia and ATI are going to use CUDA for PhysX.

Why not have games/apps that would support both?
 
i would say it is a good move for amd, nvidia is erratic atm who knows what the hell is going on there. amd and intel must cooperate yes they are competitors but amd still has to license x86 from intel. this just shows the ati portion of amd is playing the market to its advantage you want crossfire on with Nehalem you got it hell i would not be to shocked if intel's gpu does crossfire since it is already supported on their platform
 
So both AMD and Intel are going to push Havok... which is available for free from Intel if I remember correctly.

And both Nvidia and ATI are going to use CUDA for PhysX.

AMD and Intel are going to push Havok.......Nvidia is going to continue with PhsyX.
AMD/ATI do not have CUDA, they use CAL, which is not interchangable with CUDA.
 
AMD and Intel are going to push Havok.......Nvidia is going to continue with PhsyX.
AMD/ATI do not have CUDA, they use CAL, which is not interchangable with CUDA.

the only way i see cuda on amd gfx cards is nvidia has to port it plain and simple
 
Its not like ATI/INTEL are going to make the Havoc engine non-nvidia compatible. Its just now it looks like these cpu companies are going to collaborate on making games with the havoc engine better.
 
This is pretty much a "no duh" moment. Havok is just a software engine. All the press release really says is that AMD/ATI are committed to putting a few people on the job of making sure it functions properly on their hardware. This would happen no matter what anyway.

And as stated above, it's not like titles that use the Havok physics system won't run on Nvidia or something.

In short, a good excuse for a press release on a slow thursday especially with everyone holding their breath for Nvidia's new cards to release.
 
Well, they had to pick a side.

Supposedly AMD and nvidia already had been working on a hardware implementation of the havoc engine. Since nvidia bought Ageia they had to shift development and implement physx via CUDA.

On a side note both Xbox360 and PS3 support both physx and havoc engines, but none are gpu accelerated.
 
AMD and Intel teaming up? What's next? Dogs and cats living together? Mass Hysteria?

In all seriousness, this seems like a good idea. Ageia had the right idea when they proposed a dedicated physics processor, but their implementation of that idea fell flat. Hopefully this team-up of epic proportions will make good on the promises Ageia made years ago.
 
The simple fact of the matter is that Intel and AMD both see Nvidia as being too hostile in this region and are teaming up to beat them back.

Keep in mind that Intel and ATI have had their cross-license deals before ATI was bought by AMD but even after AMD buying ATI, those licenses were kept intact. Hence we still see crossfire on Intel boards with the appropriate PCI-E slots.

As far as Nvidia pushing PhysX into games via TWIMTBP, I don't know just yet. Havok has A LOT of titles already:

Pre-2006 Titles: http://www.havok.com/content/blogcategory/44/84/

Recent Titles: http://www.havok.com/content/blogcategory/29/73/

Upcoming Releases: http://www.havok.com/content/blogcategory/37/78/

Look at some of those names.. Half Life 2, FEAR, Company of Heroes...

And upcoming titles: Fallout 3, Starcraft 2...

HUGE sellers - AMD's press release also stated that they are looking into porting their capabilities to their GPU's and with Intel coming out with Larrabee in the next year, both are likely to port them to GPU purposes.

Look at it this way - AMD might be paying $ to Intel for the rights, but considering the # of titles using Havok, the opportunity to slap on a logo saying "Optimized for AMD CPUs" or "Optimized for ATI Graphics" on titles like Starcraft 2 could mean HUGE returns

It's a smart move
 
With both Intel and AMD going with Havok, things aren’t looking too good for team AGEIA.

For Ageia? Or nVidia? This is the curtains continually dimming on the nVidia stage act. I can already see the man with the long white cane creeping up to snatch nVidia off the stage.
 
Back
Top