Amazon Criticizes Google’s Proposed Settlement

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Amazon doesn’t seem to be too happy with Google’s proposed settlement with book authors and publishers. Rumor has it that the dispute escalated after Jeff Bezos challenged Eric Schmidt to a 3 round pay-per-view mixed martial arts match with the proceeds going to charity. :D

Amazon's opposition was made public last week when it joined the Open Book Alliance, but the company filed its own brief with the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Tuesday arguing against making the proposed settlement final. In its filing (click for PDF), Amazon notes that it has also scanned books, but has not taken the controversial step that Google took in scanning out-of-print but copyright-protected books without explicit permission.
 
hmmm Google vs. Amazon? Godzilla vs. Rodan...Athletes foot vs the common cold...

it's all fun till someone looses an eye, then how ya gonna read the book? did anyone else hear that Adam Smith's theories have shortfalls, and only Lawyers make any money this way?
 
I'd agree with them though...

Google has gotten so big it's as if they think they're above the law. "Indexing Information", etc is fine on the public internet but not on copyrighted books.
 
I'd agree with them though...

Google has gotten so big it's as if they think they're above the law. "Indexing Information", etc is fine on the public internet but not on copyrighted books.

As long as the book wasn't already available on the internet in the first place. It's like people complaining you're listening to music playing off their boombox when they're playing it in public.

You don't want it indexed? Secure your site or take it off the internet.

It's not like Google host them anyways. They'll still take you to Amazon's service. Might as well consider Google a torrent tracker of sort.
 
Yes, they do. Google hosts scanned pages of books, and that's what they're talking about.
They took books from libraries, scanned them in without copyright holder's permission. That's the tiff, and it's entirely valid.
 
Well in that case Google has no rights to them at all. It's like any other copyrighted website - you need the owner's permission to use images or contents from their sites.

If it was anyone else, we would be served with a take-down notice. I guess Google's a special case.
 
Back
Top