A Twitter Hole Lets You Google Protected Tweets?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Wait a minute, is this really a problem? I could be wrong but this looks like Google just indexed tweets from public accounts before they went private. The article makes it seem like there is a huge security hole that allows people to see private tweets. Anyone else want to weigh in on this?

Google's search crawler, called the Googlebot, appears to be given an unobstructed view into Twitter's more than 5 billion messages, including supposedly protected tweets. It seems Googlebot can crawl through the doggy door and access private profiles without permission. Many of those protected messages can be found through Google's search engine. The results page shows an index of the tweets it has logged, and for more recent tweets, a cache of the page as it might appear for someone who has been granted access.

*Update: I was right, false alarm
 
Last edited:
I didn't interpret it the same way as you did Steve.

It appears that Google's bot can crawl protected accounts, even after they are protected. At least that looks like what the article is claiming.

Google's search crawler, called the Googlebot, appears to be given an unobstructed view into Twitter's more than 5 billion messages, including supposedly protected tweets. It seems Googlebot can crawl through the doggy door and access private profiles without permission.

If this is true, then I think there is a genuine security hole here--I can see why there's a fuss about it anyway.
 
... who would trust a social networking site to keep anything private? Do you put crap on MySpace that you don't want the world to see?
 
I use Google to get behind some protected websites, especially in www.experts-exchange.com

It's really simple: go to www.experts-exchange.com and search your IT question. When you find the result you want, put in the title of the result you want from experts-exchange in Google search and it will unlock the replies for you.
 
I use Google to get behind some protected websites, especially in www.experts-exchange.com

It's really simple: go to www.experts-exchange.com and search your IT question. When you find the result you want, put in the title of the result you want from experts-exchange in Google search and it will unlock the replies for you.

That is because experts-exchange wants Google's crawler to index the solutions. It isn't google sneaking into places it shouldn't ;)

That is also why the solutions are at the far bottom of the page, as most people won't think to scroll that far down :)
 
That is because experts-exchange wants Google's crawler to index the solutions. It isn't google sneaking into places it shouldn't ;)

That is also why the solutions are at the far bottom of the page, as most people won't think to scroll that far down :)

Solutions don't show up at the bottom of the page if you search in experts-exchange without an account. You only see the colored bars with something like "join us to see solutions".

Googling experts-exchange results will open up the solutions at the bottom of the page. The middle of the page will still show the colored "join to see solution" bars.
 
Solutions don't show up at the bottom of the page if you search in experts-exchange without an account. You only see the colored bars with something like "join us to see solutions".

Googling experts-exchange results will open up the solutions at the bottom of the page. The middle of the page will still show the colored "join to see solution" bars.

This is true, I double checked since its been awhile since I was on the site. However, you used to be able to scroll down past the JOIN NOW AND SEE!! stuff and see the answers as the other guy mentioned.

Thanks for the tip to get around that.
 
Solutions don't show up at the bottom of the page if you search in experts-exchange without an account. You only see the colored bars with something like "join us to see solutions".

Googling experts-exchange results will open up the solutions at the bottom of the page. The middle of the page will still show the colored "join to see solution" bars.

Actually, try again, scroll to the very bottom of the page past the ads and you'll see the solutions that people have submitted. Google most definitely isn't required here.
 
Actually, try again, scroll to the very bottom of the page past the ads and you'll see the solutions that people have submitted. Google most definitely isn't required here.

I can try again until the cows come home and the results are still the same. No results unless I use Google.

And yes, I did try again just before I posted this.
 
No one cares about what you are currently doing. Twitter is gonna die a horrible, but slow death. It's a mass marketing machine. Sign up for this quiz and give all your personal information away? That's a great idea! It's going to be like myspace; after a while, no one will care.
 
Back
Top