A bit overwhelmed with making IPS decision....

Check out the 2690 thread. Toasty gave one the same treatment he gave the Planar and Doublesight (see their threads), and you probably won't find many reviews that comprehensive. He also compared all 3 of them, along with the 2490, in the mentioned threads.

26" is way better than a 24" because it's basically same pixel enlarged couple inches across the screen, it should be especially easy on the eye to read text.

Give you a perfect example, I have a 12" dell xps laptop with 1280x800 resolution, the pixel is so packed that it is very very hard for me to concentrate on the text displayed on the screen. My girlfriend have a dell 15" laptop with exactly same pixel count, guess what? Everything displayed on the screen is way easier to read. So go larger on same pixel count(26" instead of 24", or 22" instead of 20") if you want to save your eyes.

I see in previous thread you don't want a wide gamut monitor, then I think 26 inch PX2611W by Planar would be a great choice. It uses same panel as NEC 2690, but Planar used regular florescent back light tube and this monitor is a regular sRGB color space tuned monitor. It's 26", it's S-IPS panel, and it's less than $800 shipped ($400 price cut got rid of NEC's backlight compensation, 12bit look up table, wide gamut back light, 12bit hardware calibration, A-TW Polarizer, ability to maintain consistent back light output thought out the life of LCD, and 1 year less warranty)... still a good deal in my opinion.

I would not recommend 24" NEC 2490 just because it's merely $100 dollar cheaper than it's 26" big brother and it's not even wide gamut, not worth it. The whole point of those pro-line monitors is to utilize the wide gamut capability for photographic editing or print proofs... There are much better options out there for 24" monitor.

My opinion is heavily based on each monitor's ability to handle color critical applications, and not gaming or video watching performance...
 
26" is way better than a 24" because it's basically same pixel enlarged couple inches across the screen, it should be especially easy on the eye to read text.

Give you a perfect example, I have a 12" dell xps laptop with 1280x800 resolution, the pixel is so packed that it is very very hard for me to concentrate on the text displayed on the screen. My girlfriend have a dell 15" laptop with exactly same pixel count, guess what? Everything displayed on the screen is way easier to read. So go larger on same pixel count(26" instead of 24", or 22" instead of 20") if you want to save your eyes.

I see in previous thread you don't want a wide gamut monitor, then I think 26 inch PX2611W by Planar would be a great choice. It uses same panel as NEC 2690, but Planar used regular florescent back light tube and this monitor is a regular sRGB color space tuned monitor. It's 26", it's S-IPS panel, and it's less than $800 shipped ($400 price cut got rid of NEC's backlight compensation, 12bit look up table, wide gamut back light, 12bit hardware calibration, A-TW Polarizer, ability to maintain consistent back light output thought out the life of LCD, and 1 year less warranty)... still a good deal in my opinion.

I would not recommend 24" NEC 2490 just because it's merely $100 dollar cheaper than it's 26" big brother and it's not even wide gamut, not worth it. The whole point of those pro-line monitors is to utilize the wide gamut capability for photographic editing or print proofs... There are much better options out there for 24" monitor.

My opinion is heavily based on each monitor's ability to handle color critical applications, and not gaming or video watching performance...

I appreciate the comments here, especially about the pixel size. However, I do think the Planar is wide gamut. I think it's essentially the same monitor as the Doublesight DS-263N.
 
The questions now are .... any reasons to not get one of these monitors? Does one have more anti-glare (sparkle) than another? Is the NEC 2490 so superior in image quality and text clarity that it's worth shelling out more than twice the cost of the smaller monitors? If I end up getting another monitor in 4-5 years, it's harder to walk away from a $1100 monitor.

No reason not to, they have good bang for the buck. Weaker backlights mean you can get a comfortable viewing brightness as well (overpowered backlights tire my eyes in 10 minutes, but I can handle 10 hours at work on CRT) I had a 2007FP back when they were first released, but it had buggy firmware (A00 they are on A05 now which is fine) and a PVA screen, so I returned it. If it was not buggy and IPS, I probably would have stopped with that screen. Screen coating is almost certainly the same on both. We have the HP 2065s all over work for new people(so I dont' get one. :mad:). These look fine and I haven't heard a single complaint about the screens at all.

Note that the pixel pitch is again smaller on these 20" screens. But again eye comfort is a personal thing, no one can determine how this will work out. I don't see age being an auto-determinant. Late 40's to early 50's you may want "computer glasses" but with proper correction acuity shouldn't be that different. We have a number of developers at work, in this age range, using 20" 1600x1200 crts. An interesting anecdote; my 89 year old grandmother still reads regular print pocket novels. No big deal except one tiny detail. She has never worn glasses in her life.

Cheers and good luck in your search.
 
I appreciate the comments here, especially about the pixel size. However, I do think the Planar is wide gamut. I think it's essentially the same monitor as the Doublesight DS-263N.

Hi Dawgies, I think wide gamut is a vague terminology, a lot monitors now day which use PVS and IPS panel claim to be wide gamut, but they don't generally state to what extend it is wide gamut. I guess the measure of the percentage of Adobe RGB and NTSC color space coverage would be a more accurate determination of a monitor's ability to display color.

Here is the response I got from planar tech support, as you can see, backlight tube is an important factor in determining a monitor's ability to display color, same panel, NEC 95% but Planar only 80%.
*********************
Subject
Hello, I'm wondering what is the percentage color gamut coverage of Adobe RGB...
-------------------------
Response (Aaron Freund) 08/26/2008 02:54 PM
Hello,

We use standard CCFL's for our backlights which generally can only reproduce about 80%.

Thanks,
Aaron Freund
Planar Technical Support
*********************
 
Hi Dawgies, I think wide gamut is a vague terminology, a lot monitors now day which use PVS and IPS panel claim to be wide gamut, but they don't generally state to what extend it is wide gamut. I guess the measure of the percentage of Adobe RGB and NTSC color space coverage would be a more accurate determination of a monitor's ability to display color.

Here is the response I got from planar tech support, as you can see, backlight tube is an important factor in determining a monitor's ability to display color, same panel, NEC 95% but Planar only 80%.
*********************
Subject
Hello, I'm wondering what is the percentage color gamut coverage of Adobe RGB...
-------------------------
Response (Aaron Freund) 08/26/2008 02:54 PM
Hello,

We use standard CCFL's for our backlights which generally can only reproduce about 80%.

Thanks,
Aaron Freund
Planar Technical Support
*********************

Interesting. Thank you very much!
 
Just an update, got the NEC 2690 monitor today, just some first impression.

First of the first... it's got 1 dead pixel... :( Ohhh well, i'll live with it, don't really want to run into hassle of returning and waiting for new one.

2690's packaging is like a tank, the total weight is twice the weight of the monitor... no worry about the monitor been damaged during shipping, it shipped to me with freight service, lots scruffs and holes on the packaging but monitor is 100% safe.

Construction of this monitor is a OKAY, not excellent not bad. Seal between plastic parts are not even. It's made in China.

Input lag is very noticeable. I have a fast cheap 19" tn panel, that thing's response is like a CRT, this one, it feels like your mouse is lagging bad... I almost thought there is something wrong with my mouse but it's the monitor.

response time is also twice as slow as my TN panel, nec claim 6ms g2g, it feels like 15ms g2g... this is noticeable especially in fps games, it makes me quite dizzy after looking at screen for just a little bit... I think I'll keep my 19" for gaming.

Now the good part... WOW, black on this LCD monitor looks real black... no white blooming or light leak at all... I haven't got my spectraview ii calibration kit for hardware 12bit LUT calibration, so I used my spyder2pro to do a graphic card LUT calibration... The defult R,G,B value is right on the bet fresh out of the box... This is the professional performance that you'd expect from a specialized lcd monitor, I love it.

Gradient performance is almost perfect, still noticeable color shift/banding at gray areas (this might be due to the fact I didn't use hardware calibration). From whtie to mid gray it's a smooth gradient, no patch at all.

Wide gamut issue during normal non-photoshop use:

This monitor will render everything on your desktop, in your games, on a browser like IE or firefox 3 (with color management off) very very saturated. Indeed not a bad thing, color looks vibrant than usual.

Now this is all in default wide gamut settings. There is a setting in OSD control that allows you to select a sRGB color profile, which instantly converted this monitor back to a sRGB calibrated monitor, everything looked normal once again. So absolutely no worry if you get this monitor, as you can choose sRGB profile for all tasks that you do that do not require wide gamut (all Pro LCD monitors have this option).

These are my first impression of the NEC LCD2690WUXi, so to sum up:

I like it's color accuracy, gradient performance, ultra wide viewing angle.
I dislike it's build quality (1 bad pixel, lots un evenness near joints, too much plastic!), it's Input lag (very noticeable) and it's gaming performance (response time is below average)

Hope these helps
 
This monitor will render everything on your desktop, in your games, on a browser like IE or firefox 3 (with color management off) very very saturated. Indeed not a bad thing, color looks vibrant than usual.

Please realize this is a matter of opinion. I personally can't stand the over saturated looking colors that result from this. They look silly and fake to me. Sometimes they are almost painful to look at. This is highly subjective and different people will react differently to this oversaturated effect.

There is a setting in OSD control that allows you to select a sRGB color profile, which instantly converted this monitor back to a sRGB calibrated monitor, everything looked normal once again. So absolutely no worry if you get this monitor, as you can choose sRGB profile for all tasks that you do that do not require wide gamut (all Pro LCD monitors have this option).

This does not echo what others have said. This setting does tone down the saturation, but it is not that accurate and you lose the ability to hardware calibrate the monitor which is half the reason to get one of these monitors in the first place. If your goal is sRGB your are much better off getting an sRGB monitor.
 
Please realize this is a matter of opinion. I personally can't stand the over saturated looking colors that result from this. They look silly and fake to me. Sometimes they are almost painful to look at. This is highly subjective and different people will react differently to this oversaturated effect.

This does not echo what others have said. This setting does tone down the saturation, but it is not that accurate and you lose the ability to hardware calibrate the monitor which is half the reason to get one of these monitors in the first place. If your goal is sRGB your are much better off getting an sRGB monitor.

Yep, sRGB option is temp solution, not meant to be permanent... I don't mind inaccurate saturated color as long as it's not my own photographs :p

Just an update... there are actually 1 dead pixel and 1 stuck pixel on this monitor... I'm packing it for a exchange... Not good...

**Another update, the stuck pixel went back to normal, so it is officially 1 dead pixel on arrive.
 
I have 1 dead on mine (2490) as well. Dead pixels seem common on these. I don't know if that is sufficient grounds for an exchange.
 
I see.. provantage.com gave me an 30 day no questions asked policy on this purchase, I'll see if I can return it all together and get the SV version that came with colorimeter instead.
 
I assume you have to pay shipping though. I bought mine with my local shop, they don't have any kind of guarantee like that on special orders, which this was. One pixel doesn't really bother me. I almost never see it.
 
Yep I'm keeping it after all... 1 dead pixel, what the heck, i'll handle it.
 
The Planar has the same gamut as the NEC 2690. I measured them myself. Support representatives never seem to know anything about their own products.
 
The Planar has the same gamut as the NEC 2690. I measured them myself. Support representatives never seem to know anything about their own products.

If that's the case.. I might as well settle to Planar, the NEC 2690 I got yesterday, after further careful inspection, have total of 8 problematic pixels (0.5 dead pixel, 1 stuck pixel that sometimes works and sometimes not, and 6 pixels in a horizontal array that stays in gray no matter what...) That is horrible. I also found obvious screen unevenness when viewed in a darkroom with a black background displayed on screen. I start to have doubt about their monitor quality... It is already in UPS truck back to where it came from... Good buy NEC...

The one I got is Made in China... and I'm actually Chinese, I'm not proud of a lot of products quality while it was made in China, and I know the place it was made of (in GuangDong Province) is famous for making counterfeit products and inferior quality items...
 
The one I got is Made in China... and I'm actually Chinese, I'm not proud of a lot of products quality while it was made in China, and I know the place it was made of (in GuangDong Province) is famous for making counterfeit products and inferior quality items...

Maybe they are "made in China", but the manufacturing is being overseed by people chosen in Japan NEC, often they are Japans and other non-Chinese. And it is made on robotized lines, so let us not blame the Chinese workers. It is just fault of NEC that they let such horribly bad monitor into the market. I bet the H-IPS panel is not even manufactured in China, it is imported for the assembly.
I also have "Made in China" NEC 2690, no backlight bleeding, only one red sub-pixel, nearly invisible.
(I'm Czech, btw.)
 
Have been studying this long enough and have decided to try either the Dell 2007FP or HP LP2065.

I prefer the Dell for two reasons....I would rather have black over silver and my current soundbar would work on the 2007FP. I just called Dell Customer Care to find out the return policy. The salesperson spoke with a tech guy and assured me I would be getting the S-IPS panel. I asked for that in writing, but he referred me to Wikipedia for confirmation (I'm not kidding). I then explained I needed the return policy information, because I'm uncertain whether I will like the monitor's resolution and antiglare coating. Bottom line...while it's a 21 day return policy, there is a 15% restocking fee.

Looks like it's the HP LP2065 for me to try. Will likely order from B&H Photo, once I get confirmation of their return policy.

Thanks to everyone that stressed the importance of finding out about return policies.
 
Have been studying this long enough and have decided to try either the Dell 2007FP or HP LP2065.

I prefer the Dell for two reasons....I would rather have black over silver and my current soundbar would work on the 2007FP. I just called Dell Customer Care to find out the return policy. The salesperson spoke with a tech guy and assured me I would be getting the S-IPS panel. I asked for that in writing, but he referred me to Wikipedia for confirmation (I'm not kidding). I then explained I needed the return policy information, because I'm uncertain whether I will like the monitor's resolution and antiglare coating. Bottom line...while it's a 21 day return policy, there is a 15% restocking fee.

Looks like it's the HP LP2065 for me to try. Will likely order from B&H Photo, once I get confirmation of their return policy.

Thanks to everyone that stressed the importance of finding out about return policies.

Hello...me again. Forget the above about ordering the 2065. I opted for the Dell 2007FP and lost the lottery, so back it went (thankfully without a fee).

I'm not so overwhelmed with the decision anymore. However, it's a very frustrating search because there aren't places here to go look at any panels like the ones I'm considering. From what I'm reading on the forums, I'm certainly not the only person trying to do this "blindly".

Since the lottery issues are still a problem, I'm rethinking things. Still looking for something that isn't wide gamut. Right now I'm back to considering the NEC 2490 as well as one I haven't considered before now...the NEC 2190wuxi (the one with the IPS panel). The both have the same pixel size. I know I give up the widescreen, but it seems like 1600 x 1200 on a 21" monitor would be easier to see than the 1920 x 1200 on the 24".

Any thoughts? The 2190 has a NEC panel, which I've not read anything about. Do 21" panels have that same antiglare coating as the 20"?

Thanks again.
 
the 2490 seems to have much higher quality controls on the panels. imo i thought the 2490 was superior to the 2690.

I made a post about this earlier it just makes so little sense to me, that the only srgb, ips lcd you can really fine is the 2490. At least we can be thankful that our only choice happens to kick so much ass.
 
It took me a while, but I finally ordered the 2490. I just hooked it up and no dead pixels or banding (as far as I can tell at this point).

I did lower the brightness significantly. Otherwise, I think the color is on target. I toyed with increasing the font size to 120 dpi, but actually prefer the 96 dpi. My old eyes seem to do much better than I expected. Text is razor sharp. I'm blown away at the color and detail I can see in my photos!

I am so grateful to everyone, especially ToastyX and Snowdog, that answered my post and directed me towards this monitor. Y'all get so many requests for help in chosing a monitor and take a lot of time trying to help people like me and may not always hear that you've made a difference. I felt so extravagent ordering this and did not think it would be that much better than my 1905, but I was mistaken. I'm absolutely tickled!!

A very heartfelt THANK YOU!
 
Back
Top