7600gt or 7900gt

MikeHunt988 said:
I would rather get a new proc with hsf. (i would buy used, but it would have to be a good deal) and i read some reviews, and the pd805 gets smoked by the 3500+. That is a good reason to buy evga, plus they are clocked a little higher than others. I'm still worried about power draw, heat, and stuff with the x1800xt. How long does the evga step up program last? if it is a decent amount of time, i think i would go with that. if its only a month or so, i wouldnt bother, and would just go with the x1800xt.

Thanks guys

MH

EDIT: Just looked at price drops, and i think that the final setup might be.......


eVga 7900gt, ecs mobo, and X2 3800+ (since it should only be like $20 more)

Does that sound like a good idea to you guys? And i'm pretty sure it will, but do you guys think this thing will be able to own source?


I wouldn't touch the X-2 3800+. I've got my Pentium D 805 at 3.8Ghz stable and it beats an X-2 3800+ straight over. I'd reconsider that. Maybe go PD805 (it's like 115, seriously on newegg) and get a decent 955X // 975X motherboard (80-120 for 955X board, 170-260 for 975X board) to get some good overclocks. Pick up some good DDR2 667//800 RAM (GeIL, OCZ, G.Skill, Mushkin, w/e) and choose what graphics card you want. You'll have more budget. the X-2 3800+ is about as much as a high end 975X motherboard (well, a little more). The PD805 and the motherboard will equal to the cost of that X-2 alone. Do that and get an X1800XT and I think you should be happy. =)
 
StealthyFish said:
I wouldn't touch the X-2 3800+. I've got my Pentium D 805 at 3.8Ghz stable and it beats an X-2 3800+ straight over. I'd reconsider that. Maybe go PD805 (it's like 115, seriously on newegg) and get a decent 955X // 975X motherboard (80-120 for 955X board, 170-260 for 975X board) to get some good overclocks. Pick up some good DDR2 667//800 RAM (GeIL, OCZ, G.Skill, Mushkin, w/e) and choose what graphics card you want. You'll have more budget. the X-2 3800+ is about as much as a high end 975X motherboard (well, a little more). The PD805 and the motherboard will equal to the cost of that X-2 alone. Do that and get an X1800XT and I think you should be happy. =)

Not a bad idea at all, if you want to go the Intel route
 
I had seriously thought about that proc, but was worried after i saw some benchies for the PD820, it got spanked in gaming by the 3500+!. I know they oc amazing (tomshardware) but i've never oc'd a thing in my life, and it scares me :eek: . I was goint the 939 or 775 route so i could use my old mem.
 
StealthyFish said:
I wouldn't touch the X-2 3800+. I've got my Pentium D 805 at 3.8Ghz stable and it beats an X-2 3800+ straight over. I'd reconsider that. Maybe go PD805 (it's like 115, seriously on newegg) and get a decent 955X // 975X motherboard (80-120 for 955X board, 170-260 for 975X board) to get some good overclocks. Pick up some good DDR2 667//800 RAM (GeIL, OCZ, G.Skill, Mushkin, w/e) and choose what graphics card you want. You'll have more budget. the X-2 3800+ is about as much as a high end 975X motherboard (well, a little more). The PD805 and the motherboard will equal to the cost of that X-2 alone. Do that and get an X1800XT and I think you should be happy. =)
you forget that the x2 3800+ can be overclocked too ;) either way you can go wrong though :) and i agree going with the x1800xt
 
StealthyFish said:
I wouldn't touch the X-2 3800+. I've got my Pentium D 805 at 3.8Ghz stable and it beats an X-2 3800+ straight over.

By straight over, do you mean with the 3800+ at stock speed? That's kind of a silly comparison. Most X2 3800+ will hit 2.6Ghz on air, and even a 4Ghz 805D won't touch that.

Give it two weeks and the X2 3800+ will be only $50-60 more than the 805D.
 
spicey said:
. The 3800+ X2 is like running a 3200+ judging by the mhz speed.


not much of a surprise since the 3800X2 isnothing more than two 3200 cores stuck together
 
Alright, I dont think that it would be worth it to get a 7600gt, as i am coming from an x800xt. So i think i have decided on the x1800xt/7900gt (there's a thousand threads on that, so i'll just look there) So what i'd like to know now is, when are the next gen cards coming (dx10)? as i have heard a couple dates/time frames. I ask because i would rather get next gens mediocre card than this gens top/near top card.

Thanks

MH
 
spicey said:
Head over to Tomshardware and have a look at The Mother of All CPU charts 2005/2006 under the CPU section The benchmark to note is the DirectX 9 comparisions. The 3800+ Venice outscores a 4800+ X2 Toledo in Farcry. The 3800+ X2 is like running a 3200+ judging by the mhz speed.

Far Cry is not SMP aware. Far Cry was released before dual core chips even existed.

Here's a better reference for you..

http://www.anandtech.com/guides/showdoc.aspx?i=2791&p=5

Keep in mind, SMP optimized games are going to become more and more prevalent as time goes on. Battlefield 2, Call of Duty 2, Quake 4 are all SMP aware.
 
SMP aware means they run better on dual core computer correct? So are you saying that i might be better off getting a cheap dual core and taking a hit on older games, becaues newer games might do better?
 
MikeHunt988 said:
SMP aware means they run better on dual core computer correct? So are you saying that i might be better off getting a cheap dual core and taking a hit on older games, becaues newer games might do better?

I think a small hit on older games is WELL worth having a dual core processor. The benefit is two-fold - you get better overall multitasking performance, and you get improved performance in newer games and future titles.

Also, for the most part dual core chips can be overclocked to match the clock speeds of less expensive single core chips and you can still attain compareable performance in older non-SMP optimized games.
 
I'd wait at least 2 weeks before buying anything. At that point, either get intel's E6300 or the X2 3800+ (both around $180).

One variable is that MBs will likely be more for Conroe chips...especially for the first month.
 
Alright, after re-doing my newegg cart for about the 300th time....


PD805 into an Albatron PX915P-2V, with an ATI Saphire X1800XT and 1 Gb of G.Skill Xtreme

Comes out to just a hair unde $600. Now all i have to do is sell my graphics card.

Anyone need an X800XT AIW?? :p ;)
 
Stellar said:
Far Cry is not SMP aware. Far Cry was released before dual core chips even existed.

Here's a better reference for you..

http://www.anandtech.com/guides/showdoc.aspx?i=2791&p=5

Keep in mind, SMP optimized games are going to become more and more prevalent as time goes on. Battlefield 2, Call of Duty 2, Quake 4 are all SMP aware.


That's a useless round up, what's the point in comparing a 3800+ X2 against a bunch of Sempron's!?
 
spicey said:
That's a useless round up, what's the point in comparing a 3800+ X2 against a bunch of Sempron's!?

Try reading the article.

They were comparing the cheapest Pentium D to the cheapest X2, which will be near in budget build price range come 1.5 weeks.
 
Somone told me that the date got moved up for conroe to the 14th, is that true!?

EDIT: Holy shit thats tomorrow!
 
I echo the suggestions of others to wait and look what's comin' on the horizon (price cuts and Conroe). As far as OC'd procs betin' out the X2 3800+, thatmay be. But I'm no OCin' expert and even I'm running at 2.5ghz on stock air. I also agree with some other folks abiut the proc not having as big an impact as the vidcard right now. Right now I'm running a 660oGT (Yes, I'm OCin' it as much as I can, too..) and I'd like to get a 7900GT to tide me over until the 2nd gen of DX10.

However, that's all my view. Do what works best for you, y'know?
 
I know exactly what you mean, and i think that waiting for the 2nd gen directx 10 cards is the way to go. (For many reasons) And I'm now going to try to sell a few more things, increasing my budget to $600 for gfx card, mobo, proc, and memory. So i have come up with a 3800+ AM2, ASrock mobo, Saphire x1800xt, and G.Skill 1gb pc6400. That comes to just under $600us, and it should rock.

EDIT: Yea, i dont think that i will order until conroe comes out, unless i sell my computer, in which case i'm not sure i could live without one for a few weeks :eek: :rolleyes:

Also, does anyone know for sure how much better a dual core proc will be for future games? It would be nice to have for multitasking, but i am making it just fine with a socket a proc still so...
 
If you really want to save some bucks I suggest the following (considering your 600 USD budget)

A64 3800+ X2 will be 169 USD on 24th July
Radeon X1900XT is around 326 w/ 30 MIR (Original Price ~ 360 USD w/ shipping)
Cheap Nforce 4 Motherboard ~ 60-80 bucks
Aspire 520W PSU ~ 60 bucks

Total comes to around 620-630 bucks which is excellent and your system will truly rock.

Lastly opting for a 7600GT was a mistake all along since its performance would be close or less than an X800XT. All you will get is SM3.0, HDR and a few other features.
 
MikeHunt988 said:
Also, does anyone know for sure how much better a dual core proc will be for future games? It would be nice to have for multitasking, but i am making it just fine with a socket a proc still so...
way better!! consider this, when u open acrobat on ur single core processor there's some sort of hang. but in dual core it is smooth as butter, like clicking on a webpage w/ 1000mbps connection, no drag or hang.
 
KickAssCop said:
If you really want to save some bucks I suggest the following (considering your 600 USD budget)

A64 3800+ X2 will be 169 USD on 24th July
Radeon X1900XT is around 326 w/ 30 MIR (Original Price ~ 360 USD w/ shipping)
Cheap Nforce 4 Motherboard ~ 60-80 bucks
Aspire 520W PSU ~ 60 bucks

Total comes to around 620-630 bucks which is excellent and your system will truly rock.

Lastly opting for a 7600GT was a mistake all along since its performance would be close or less than an X800XT. All you will get is SM3.0, HDR and a few other features.
bad suggestion man....aspire?! you wanna kill his new system?! :eek:
 
N H O said:
bad suggestion man....aspire?! you wanna kill his new system?! :eek:

I am using one in the system in signature. I've also used an X1800XT 512 MB w/ same specs (overclocked) and it worked out fine. If he is worried he can grab the 550 W version, since these are the only PSUs I could find to fit his budget. 520W does an excellent job and has been doing it for the past 8 months.
 
KickAssCop said:
I am using one in the system in signature. I've also used an X1800XT 512 MB w/ same specs (overclocked) and it worked out fine. If he is worried he can grab the 550 W version, since these are the only PSUs I could find to fit his budget. 520W does an excellent job and has been doing it for the past 8 months.

They're fine if you wanna play "hit or miss" with your system.

You get what you pay for.
 
Alright, This thread is getting old, and getting somewhat off the topic it was created for (my fault) And now here's another variable... I have decided that a 7600gt would NOT give me enough of a performance increase, so i decided on either an x1800xt or 7900gt. I chose the x1800xt for $230. Now i have an offer for a 7800gt for $180 (after some trades). The 7800gt has an aftermarket cooler on it, and could be oc'd if i would like. So tell me peeps, is the x1800xt worth the extra $50? Or would the 7800gt be able to oc a little and be on par with it?

Thanks

MH
 
the x1800xt is definitely worth the extra $50, and it can be oc'ed to insane levels too
 
KickAssCop said:
I am using one in the system in signature. I've also used an X1800XT 512 MB w/ same specs (overclocked) and it worked out fine. If he is worried he can grab the 550 W version, since these are the only PSUs I could find to fit his budget. 520W does an excellent job and has been doing it for the past 8 months.
im not juss talking about the power it delivers but its quality, i wouldnt want one in my system after seein a cheap power supply destroy itself and taking other components with it, for $10 more the OP could get this which is alot better than the aspire in quality and power delivery
 
So you guys think that 400-450 watts will be enough power for 1x3500+, 7900gt/x1800xt, 1x120gb, 1x40gb, 1 dvd burner, 1 dvd drive?
 
Ok, well after tons of shopping, and plenty of help (thanks guys) i think i have it figured out.

Thanks

MH
 
I would go with the 7900 GT. You won't see a lot of performance increase with 2 - 7600 GT over 1 really. 7900 GT FTW. Head over to Monarch. They normally have some good prices on these cards.
 
Back
Top