7600GS or X1600Pro

NewMonster said:
black and white 2 at full setting? do u mean max setting by that? i played black and white 2 with my x700pro and its far from a decent performance... chunky... choppy..... even in med settings.... and bearly bearly super low settings! theres no way i can play black and white with x700pro

heres a comparison of 7600gs and x700pro there not to0 far off from each other.... and i dont think i can believe u that u can play black and white 2 with ur 7600gs on max settings.....

if u admit that u lied.... i would like to say this

"why lie jus to kick it?"

edit = 7600gs is a joke!!!! reall joke!!!!


Here's my compare url showing how my 7600GS performs with a mild overclock (just passive heatsink, no fan at all and the temps are still low).

http://service.futuremark.com/compare?3dm06=421710 (Here's my compare URL).

I think you'll find this one close enough to show that it's not a joke, especially for a ~$110 card. There are also models available that have a heatsink/fan that should allow the individual to push a much higher overclock and provide even higher results.

Guess my 1280x1024 game settings with "everything" on high details in all my games, including HL2:Episode one is also a lie to just kick it? I'd go higher, but that's the max resolution of my CRT without 60hz refresh.
 
PandaZ3 said:
Back to the poin!t the $119 X850 Pro AGP at ATI's Clearance center can easily run at X850XT PE speed, it will just have 12 pipes instead of 16 and is within $10 of the original budget
Make that $113.05 shipped with the 5% discount.
 
HighTest said:
Here's my compare url showing how my 7600GS performs with a mild overclock (just passive heatsink, no fan at all and the temps are still low).
What's your definition of a mild OC? That is, what are your core and ram speeds?
 
NewMonster said:
black and white 2 at full setting? do u mean max setting by that? i played black and white 2 with my x700pro and its far from a decent performance... chunky... choppy..... even in med settings.... and bearly bearly super low settings! theres no way i can play black and white with x700pro

heres a comparison of 7600gs and x700pro there not to0 far off from each other.... and i dont think i can believe u that u can play black and white 2 with ur 7600gs on max settings.....

if u admit that u lied.... i would like to say this

"why lie jus to kick it?"

edit = 7600gs is a joke!!!! reall joke!!!!

I quantified what I claimed by saying the resolution the card as running full to max settings in B&W 2 was 1024x768. Then I said that for 1280x1024 the settings would probably have to be turned down to recieve decent frames.

Other than becoming a troll b/c of this thread.... might I advise picking up a better video card so you - yourself, can stop whining about how people managed to make a better choice than the x700 :rolleyes:
 
NewMonster said:
heres a comparison of 7600gs and x700pro there not to0 far off from each other.... and i dont think i can believe u that u can play black and white 2 with ur 7600gs on max settings.....

if u admit that u lied.... i would like to say this

"why lie jus to kick it?"

edit = 7600gs is a joke!!!! reall joke!!!!
Against my better judgment, I clicked on the link above. First, I was morbidly curious as to who on the web would benchmark these two cards against each other. Second, I couldn't imagine how such a benchmarking run could possibly leave someone with the impression that the two cards were "not too far off from each other..." Imagine my surprise when the link led, not to a benchmark, but to a raw side-by-side feature comparison.

NewMonster, there is a reason that review sites do comparative benchmarks with real applications--raw feature numbers do not provide a picture of what a card can do.

There is also a reason why nobody has run benchmarks comparing these two cards--the x700 is not one, but TWO generations behind the 7600GS. If you really think that all the performance and feature improvements of the last 2 years are meaningless, I have 5 acres of property on the Moon that I would love to sell you for a modest fee.

.
 
NewMonster said:
heres a comparison of 7600gs and x700pro there not to0 far off from each other.... and i dont think i can believe u that u can play black and white 2 with ur 7600gs on max settings.....

NewMonster, I went back and looked at that GPUreview.com site again to check it out one last time.

What do you know? It shows the 3Dmark06 score of the 7600GS but shows the 3Dmark05 score for the X700pro. That is not a fair comparison because the benchmarks provide completely different scores.

If you want to put it into better perspective and also to illustrate how much the X700pro "Chokes" in comparison to the 7600GS, here's a better illustration:

evga 7600GS default run in 3dmark05: 4020. Link proof: http://www.gamepyre.com/reviewsd.html?aid=700&p=5

Gigabyte x700 pro default run in 3dmark05: 3275. Link proof: http://www.pcstats.com/articleview.cfm?articleid=1695&page=3

Now that we can compare an accurate stock speed comparison in 3dmark05 to 3dMark05, you'll see the 7600GS 4020 score is superior to the X700 Pro 3275 score.

The other reason you won't see a 3dMark06 score for the X700 Pro is that it cannot complete the benchmark on a default run, it has no SM 3.0 support which is required for a full 3dMark06 score.

In this perspective, the 7600GS is superior. Especially in light of the overclocks that take it even further. For example with my passive heatsink and "no fan", I'm getting 2651 (your GPUreview showed a score of 2100 to put it into perspective) in 3Dmark06 with my core overclocked to 515Mhz and the ram to 440Mhz, you could really push this card with some cooling and a voltmod (but why would you want too when the 7600GT is so close in price?)
 
Back
Top