6800GT or X800 Pro?

With the extreme overclocks people are getting, I went with the Pro (just ordered today). It's a decent amount less than the XT's will be for quite some time, so I'm not worried if it drops $20-$30 in the next few months. Also, I don't want to risk getting a card from the 2nd batch, which may have all the great performing chips sorted out to become XT's :)

But back on topic, an overclocked Pro should easily be able to hang with the Ultra/XT. It's possible that the GT will overclock well too, but I just decided to go with a (pretty much) sure bet.
 
In that case, you should get a Sapphire. Sapphire success rate - 100%; Other - 0%. Go figure.
 
Sandman said:
With the extreme overclocks people are getting, I went with the Pro (just ordered today). It's a decent amount less than the XT's will be for quite some time, so I'm not worried if it drops $20-$30 in the next few months. Also, I don't want to risk getting a card from the 2nd batch, which may have all the great performing chips sorted out to become XT's :)

But back on topic, an overclocked Pro should easily be able to hang with the Ultra/XT. It's possible that the GT will overclock well too, but I just decided to go with a (pretty much) sure bet.

An overclocked X800Pro will never keep up with a X800XT clock for clock. Even at the same speeds or higher it won't have the fill rate that the X800XT has due to the fact that it has physically less enabled pipelines. However if you ordered a Saphire card you should be able to unlock those pipelines. In which case assuming your card can run at the same speeds as the X800XT you would get the same performance.
 
eraser_16 said:
1. if 16 pipes is what you're looking for, spend the x-tra dough for an X800XT, 2. PS 3.0 isn't really necessary on the X800, so ATI didn't add it 3. the 6800 cards you will find are slightly faster in OpenGL applications than the X800, however it's somewhat insignifigant. personally, i'm planning to get an X800XT this summer. i don't mean to nock the 6800 cards, Nvidia has made a major comeback from the FX series, but i just feel that the X800 cards have a good lead over the Geforce 6800.


I know what you meen man... Nvidia would have probably been more of a competition for popularity for the 6800 series vs x800 if the damn 6800 wasnt such a ps sucker upper lol...right?
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
An overclocked X800Pro will never keep up with a X800XT clock for clock. Even at the same speeds or higher it won't have the fill rate that the X800XT has due to the fact that it has physically less enabled pipelines. However if you ordered a Saphire card you should be able to unlock those pipelines. In which case assuming your card can run at the same speeds as the X800XT you would get the same performance.

Of course it won't have the fill rate of an XT, but that assumes that bandwidth is no issue. I'm betting that a Pro that OC's well will be able to "keep up" with an XT, especially considering the poor overclocking results of all the XT's I've seen benchmarked.
 
Eshelmen said:
I know what you meen man... Nvidia would have probably been more of a competition for popularity for the 6800 series vs x800 if the damn 6800 wasnt such a ps sucker upper lol...right?
lol yeah, that's what helped make up my mind. My 430 watt PSU is already pretty well loaded, and I don't have the dough for 2 upgrades.
 
Sandman said:
lol yeah, that's what helped make up my mind. My 430 watt PSU is already pretty well loaded, and I don't have the dough for 2 upgrades.

I said it before and I'll say it again, they've REVISED THE POWER REQUIREMENTS! 350/300

You guys are not up to date.
 
Going by the power readings on Tech Reports review, 350 Watt will have to be decent brand name power supply, and not some generic POS. Also it will depend alot on what else you are running, add a couple of drives etc., power hungry prescott and the total wattage would be too much for a 350 watt power supply. ;)
 
You guys are not up to date.
No one really knows how much power they are gonna suck? but at least be realistic :rolleyes:
120Watt now thats gonna at least need a bloody good quality 400Watt at least to be truely stable.
But i think the 6800GT being able to run one molex is at least better than the 2 config of the ultra version?
And one thing to watch also as has been stated on the net is Nvidia are shocking for there prerealise cards not showing the true retail product requirments

But if and when the 6800GT finally gets here its not looking to shabby and a couple like the asus even look to be single slot solutions :D
But enought of the rant X800 for me lol :p
 
oozish said:
I said it before and I'll say it again, they've REVISED THE POWER REQUIREMENTS! 350/300

You guys are not up to date.
I knew that 3 days before it became official, where were you? ;) :D

But as I said in my post, I have a loaded 430 watt supply. Meaning that I'm already putting a good strain on it. Sure, "any" 350 watt PSU will be fine if you've only got 1-2 hard drives, maybe 2 PCI cards, 1 stick of RAM, and one optical drive. But some of us just aren't that typical :)

For what it's worth, IIRC there was a website that did a power consumption test and the 6800u was pulling around 300 watts (total system consumption, not just video card) on a barebones system in 3dmark.
 
Back
Top