Should AMD Have Made an RX 9080 XT?

Beaver LongTail

8-D
2FA
Joined
Dec 19, 2005
Messages
19,304
Hardware Unboxed hosts their November Q&A session to discuss recent industry product releases and hardware market trends. The team addresses viewer questions regarding potential future GPU lineups, the current state of artificial intelligence development, and how these factors might influence consumer hardware accessibility and pricing in the coming years.]


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hKr9PrKbqUU
 
Is everyone answering yes assuming AMD didn't release the absolute fastest they could? I ask because it seems to me, they honestly can't and haven't been able to for quite some time now.
 
Is everyone answering yes assuming AMD didn't release the absolute fastest they could? I ask because it seems to me, they honestly can't and haven't been able to for quite some time now.
Depend what one mean by could, they physically of course could have, the company that make Mi-450x and been making 3d gaming gpu since like the 3D rage could have easily made the fastest gaming gpu on earth would they wanted to loose giant money doing so.

There is not much indication RDNA 4 as some special scaling issue, a 840mm TSMC 3N-640bits-700 watt version would have been really fast and a more realistic 600mm-384 bits 6080xt probably have been fine to match-beat by a bit the 4090. I am not sure making bigger more performing card is much harder than smaller card at all, you have more space-power to play with (as long you do not mind bad yield and the terrible challenge to make it profitable).

Making it in a commercial viable way that a hole lot different question and AMD did not thought they had the ressource to do so right now.

Making a 9080xt could mean having to make a AMD Radeon Pro W7900 family successor with all it involve to make it work, you need to create such a giant volume of units on that die to make the giant R&D amortisation work.

Considering the ram price maybe they are happy they did not had to source 24-32GB of them for 9800xt, but considering the RTX 5500/6000 market right now, maybe they would have loved to have an up to date PRO w7900 successor for China and other markets, I would not imagine gaming halo card matter much in the regret or lack of too.
 
Last edited:
As an owner of a 7900xtx, I'm happy that they did not. There are a collection of cards all within about 10-15% of each other that are/were reasonably available. 4080 4080s 7900xtx 9070xt 5070ti 5080.

If there was a 9080xt somewhere between a 5080 and a 5090, it would just be scalped through the roof.
 
As an owner of a 7900xtx, I'm happy that they did not. There are a collection of cards all within about 10-15% of each other that are/were reasonably available. 4080 4080s 7900xtx 9070xt 5070ti 5080.

If there was a 9080xt somewhere between a 5080 and a 5090, it would just be scalped through the roof.
It's not scalping if it's companies doing it. It's just business as usual.
 
There is not much indication RDNA 4 as some special scaling issue

Well....there might be a pretty simple indication. Compare the power use of the RX 9070 and the RX 9070 XT. And then compare the average framerate.
It may not have been feasible to say......match an RTX 4090 on performance, for about the same power use as a 4090. Unless they heavily binned chips. And chip binning would mean they'd have to make another SKU between 9070 XT and 9080 XT, to sell the "garbage" chips which didn't bin well. Which could mess up the margins. Reportedly, margins on RDNA4 chips are very good, and they probably didn't want to mess with all that. Especially considering how tight supply is from TSMC right now.


1794616893027.png

1794616748045.png
 

Attachments

  • 1794616766485.png
    1794616766485.png
    205.8 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:
Well....there might be a pretty simple indication. Compare the power use of the RX 9070 and the RX 9070 XT. And then compare the average framerate.
It may not have been
that a different thing than the chip getting bigger and having issue to scale, the 9070 simply run at lower clock and power target out of the box to make the sku seperation better.

If you run the 9070xt at the same clock than the 9070 we would not see any efficacy gap... the 9070xt being wider should even get the edge in efficacity if we put than at the same performance level.

the Navi 44->48 family of GPU is a better indication of what a 480mm one would have done.
 
I think if AMD did release a RX 9080 XT, the power consumption would be up there between the RTX 5090 and RTX 5080, probably around 450W's. Plus, I think to match or get better performance, they'd have to increase the memory bandwidth and use GDDR7. I just don't think AMD wanted all of that.
 
Back
Top