I have an HD2 - I think it's perfect sized. I should have been more clear in my post. I was thinking of tablets that are 9 or so inches and for some reason left that data out...
Well honestly I doubt the difference would be very noticable at all between 4.3 and 4.5. That said I wouldn't really want to or have the need to go any bigger than 4.5 for a phone.
Any bigger and you might as well do a tablet with a bluetooth ear piece because putting to your head will look...
I'm running the latest energy ROM on my HD2. It's pretty slick for the most part. I also have froyo running on it also but it's not as silky as I would like it to be so I don't run it often.