Thanks guys,
I did not have the SATA power connected, but this seems to happen even with nothing attached to the MB, so I can't imagine the PCIe port is drawing anything..
I guess I'll take the RMA advice. Sucks, cause this is my main machine and Gigabyte is on the other side of the...
Using a known good proc and two sets of RAM, tried multiple PSUs (650w initially, and a 450 spare later)...stumped.
At first, it booted up fine, and I was even able to get into BIOS to set boot priority, launch a win7 install from CD, but it blue-screed at 'starting windows' with a pci.sys...