I really don't get it.
The infrastructure google wants access to was most likely built using building permits based on each company's ILEC/PUC status, i.e. it was built for the public good and received special treatment and lower pricing as a result.
Google, get yourself a lawyer, pull the BPs...
You guys must live in some kind of protected bubble where information doesn't reach.
Both Internet and mobile phone services suck in the US, and they're more expensive.
There are no "excuses" to be found, except monopoly of one version or another, price fixing etc. Competition drives margins...