Hi, I have the same board. Be sure the chip is aligned correctly. There will be some resistance when you go to close the metal plate over processor. Just go ahead and close it and place the lever under the hook and you should be fine.
I am trying to figure out what would be the best way to go. I am looking at the Gigabyte P35 board or the Gigabyte P31 board. Other than the south bridge, P35- ICH9, P31-ICH7, what other differences are there? Any help would be appreciated.