I love Newegg, tip-top service and great deals. But I've had an uncharacteristic set of bad drives from them recently. I'm not sure if the issue is the drives I'm choosing to buy (bare drives), the shipping method (maybe? I dunno), or if there is a industry standard problem with bad drives...
HDDGURU - Partition-Find-and-Mount
http://hddguru.com/content/en/software/2007.05.25-Partition-Find-and-Mount/
Although, a drive reporting the wrong size is not a good sign. I'm inclined to give your chance of success fairly low probability. This is likely an issue with the firmware, which can...