The 2.8s were great processors, but yeah they WILL throttle down to almost a crawl if you let them run too hot. But they do have a lot of potential if you have the hardware to use with em.
No he has a 12 series. I would say its just a bad drive and I would send it back and RMA it for sure. I'd also test ALL of the drives and make sure they are all working good. Cooling could be a issue and if they are in a rack setup try and see if you can get some active cooling on the drives...
Well if you do go for a seagate I would try at all possible to go for the 7200.12 series drives as they don't seem to have the firmware issues the 7200.11 series drives had. If you go with WD, that's a good option as well. I would guess it all comes down to preference, what do you think you...