From what I have been reading, the difference from the 970 EVO plus to the 970 EVO is minimal at best. I am in the same position and I am leaning on saving the $40 or so and getting the EVO over the EVO Plus.
The direct contact heatpipes and dual fans will allow the card to run significantly cooler than reference designs and the DIGI super alloy with digital voltage regulators make it quieter and more efficient. Stellar customer service along with superb quality make this along with any other ASUS...