They're both in the same PC so OS influence would be similar or the same. HDDScan limits OS influence by running with the process priority set by default to real time. I hope some Windows users will do similar tests. Come on people, don't be lazy... ;) Show your results, please!
@drescherjm
Why are the saw "teeth" in the second one much bigger than in the first one, and the same with the number of 500 ms surface access times?
Why are they so different, if they are the same disk models, different just by one digit in S/N?
Why does Caviar has so smooth (not "teethed")...
There are two Samsung 2TB HD204UI bought together (their S/N is different just by one digit at the end, so they had to be next to each other on the assembly line), but they behave very differently in tests, as you can see here...
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ibd/20110419/bs_ibd_ibd/569611
http://tech.blorge.com/Structure:%20/2011/04/19/seagate-buys-samsung-hard-drive-division/
Since there will be less competition than ever in the HDDs market, I suspect the prices to increase a bit.
From another forum:
"Have Samsung truly fixed SMART or have they implemented some kludge to work around the problem?
I have a pair of these HD204UI disks, with the 'fixed' firmware, manufacture date March 2011. Although I am not seeing data corruption (and I have done a lot of copying them...
Do PCI express x16 motherboards require mandatory PCIe graphics card to run?
I am trying to run Celeron D 3.20 GHz on MS-7187 ver. 3.C motherboard ( http://www.uktsupport.co.uk/advent/pc/t9207.htm )
with only PCI graphics card, as I have no PCIe graphics card.
The motherboard is from...
Ridiculous Samsung replies:
http://forum.hddguru.com/verbatim-usb-external-with-samsung-f4eg-hd204ui-t18455-20.html#p124735
http://forum.hddguru.com/verbatim-usb-external-with-samsung-f4eg-hd204ui-t18455-20.html#p124618
Thay claim that applying their patch won't change the firmware. LOL
Send it when it will be 100%. :) And also test it under MHDD as well, as under HDDScan the results seem always worse than in MHDD.
If you will get <500 ms and > 500 ms times in MHDD too, you may try to delete delays as described there:
http://hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1036852309&postcount=381
Perhaps the fact that HDDScan runs under Windows with other software in background interferes with the process, while MHDD running in DOS is not disturbed by anything. I do not know just guessing.
Still WD and Hitachi seems a bit better.
I wonder would the <500 ms dissapear if you would...
That's a graph. I would also want to see such a map:
In MHDD (text version of the map):
[SAMSUNG SP1614N ] [ 312,581,808] [ 312,581,807] [ EST: 00:01 ]
°±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±± ACT [ 33176 kb/s]...