i think the buzzing sound is a defect in some of their 200mm fans. i have the Corsair 600T too, and while the front 200mm fan does not buzz and is virtually silent at low rpms, the top 200mm fan had the buzzing sound. so i replaced it with this 200mm Xigmatek fan, which i've had great...
you have to remember that these testimonials are coming from different people w/ differing priorities, differing hardware configurations, differing ambient room temps, etc. if you were an extreme/hardcore OC'er, then perhaps every little bit of help you can get would make a difference. but for...
the 212 EVO is essentially a "new and improved" 212+...the only real difference i know of is in the base itself (where it makes contact w/ the CPU). you'll note that the heatpipes of the 212+ are distinct as they run through the base plate, leaving unwanted grooves where air pockets can form...
in for one...and first post :)
i've got 3 machines, all powered w/ SeaSonic units (S12II 620, X-650, and X-750). they're the cream of the crop and i wouldn't risk anything less...