Microsoft Will Separate Edge Browser Updates from Windows 10 with Redstone 3

Exactly my point... it was around the same time MS was making stupid claims. Clearly they where MS (Edit: I meant to type BS, clearly a Freudian slip). Since then google has released 53 which added a bunch of power state improvements. If PC world where to re ran those tests with up to date software MS wouldn't even have the 30min advantage they showed a year ago. So still claiming that Edge is a better choice cause power reasons... well its what you have to say if you work for MS I guess.

Microsoft already did an update of this test just weeks ago: https://blogs.windows.com/msedgedev...tery-life-microsoft-edge/#mYeKCH9aDgf3kGzL.97. I use both Chrome and Edge constantly and it's kind of obvious that Edge is just lighter on resources, it's quite noticeable particularly when using them on Atom tablets.
 
I've made my point, Chrome as well as Firefox have mobile browsers and it's obvious Edge is specifically designed to be a mobile browser - So compare it mobile browsers that prioritise efficiency as opposed to desktop browsers that do not. There's not much more to argue here.
Actually there is your claim that edge is a mobile browser is off point because it's far more feature rich than any mobile browser, also the fact the only non-desktop environments it's in are windows 10 mobile which is dead and XB1
 
Microsoft already did an update of this test just weeks ago: https://blogs.windows.com/msedgedev...tery-life-microsoft-edge/#mYeKCH9aDgf3kGzL.97. I use both Chrome and Edge constantly and it's kind of obvious that Edge is just lighter on resources, it's quite noticeable particularly when using them on Atom tablets.

This is the test I'm talking about, nowhere in there does anything indicate that Edge is being compared to Chrome and Firefox mobile browsers.

Actually there is your claim that edge is a mobile browser is off point because it's far more feature rich than any mobile browser, also the fact the only non-desktop environments it's in are windows 10 mobile which is dead and XB1

It's more feature rich? In what way?
 
Exactly my point... it was around the same time MS was making stupid claims. Clearly they where MS (Edit: I meant to type BS, clearly a Freudian slip). Since then google has released 53 which added a bunch of power state improvements. If PC world where to re ran those tests with up to date software MS wouldn't even have the 30min advantage they showed a year ago. So still claiming that Edge is a better choice cause power reasons... well its what you have to say if you work for MS I guess.
https://blogs.windows.com/windowsexperience/2016/09/15/edge-battery-anniversary-update/
https://microsoftedge.github.io/videotest/2016-09/WebdriverMethodology.html
Ut7ZPof.png
 
Okay, it's a mobile browser that runs on the desktop and supports extensions and runs in a sandbox. So it's no different than Chrome really.

With the exception that Chrome and Firefox run separate mobile browsers! Edge is designed to be a 'one solution fits all' type of product, therefore it is designed from the onset with efficiency in mind for when it is being used as a touch browser on mobile devices. You cannot directly compare it to products that have separate browsers for desktop and mobile application, especially when you're comparing it directly to desktop solutions.

Like all Microsoft's claims, this one is also flawed. The graph above, is most likely flawed.
 
It's more feature rich? In what way?
https://www.w3.org/TR/pointerevents/
Pointer events:p
With the exception that Chrome and Firefox run separate mobile browsers! Edge is designed to be a 'one solution fits all' type of product, therefore it is designed from the onset with efficiency in mind for when it is being used as a touch browser on mobile devices. You cannot directly compare it to products that have separate browsers for desktop and mobile application, especially when you're comparing it directly to desktop solutions.

Like all Microsoft's claims, this one is also flawed. The graph above, is most likely flawed.
Trapped yourself Edge is not the same on desktop and mobile, there are different builds for Windows 10 mobile and XB1
 
Okay, it's a mobile browser that runs on the desktop and supports extensions and runs in a sandbox. So it's no different than Chrome really.

Heatle its all about install base and ecosystem for me really. There just isn't anyone using Edge... I mean its only 3% of the install base. I mean if I could do all the things I want it to do I would use Edge. In a second its not that I don't want MS stuff to work... its just chrome does everything I need all in one. If Edge was capable of doing those things I would use it. As it is everything web related is designed for Chrome.... its the industry standard and that isn't going to change. Their are more Chrome extensions released in a week then Edge will see all year. How can I seriously switch to a browsing platform that has no industry support. Edge is niche software and that isn't going to change as long as Chrome just does everything average people need it to do.

lmao.... I couldn't resist.
 
Heatle its all about install base and ecosystem for me really. There just isn't anyone using Edge... I mean its only 3% of the install base. I mean if I could do all the things I want it to do I would use Edge. In a second its not that I don't want MS stuff to work... its just chrome does everything I need all in one. If Edge was capable of doing those things I would use it. As it is everything web related is designed for Chrome.... its the industry standard and that isn't going to change. Their are more Chrome extensions released in a week then Edge will see all year. How can I seriously switch to a browsing platform that has no industry support. Edge is niche software and that isn't going to change as long as Chrome just does everything average people need it to do.

lmao.... I couldn't resist.
Then what are your essential functions and extensions that Edge is missing vs Chrome.
 
https://www.w3.org/TR/pointerevents/
Pointer events:p

Trapped yourself Edge is not the same on desktop and mobile, there are different builds for Windows 10 mobile and XB1

No I didn't!

Windows 10 is designed for Surface devices as well as 2 in 1 laptops, therefore the OS is designed with desktop and touch use in mind. Surface products are marketed as mobile devices, these are the devices I'm talking about. Therefore it's obvious that from the onset Edge was designed with Mobile use in mind and therefore prioritises efficiency, hence comparing it to desktop browsers that leave efficiency to their mobile counterparts is a flawed comparison.

Dear gawd.
 
Okay, it's a mobile browser that runs on the desktop and supports extensions and runs in a sandbox. So it's no different than Chrome really.

No, not at all.

There are two variants of Chrome, a desktop variant and a mobile variant. The desktop variant obviously does not prioritise efficiency, the mobile variant obviously does. When you consider that Edge is being compared to the desktop variant it actually makes Chrome look quite good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChadD
like this
No I didn't!

Windows 10 is designed for Surface devices as well as 2 in 1 laptops, therefore the OS is designed with desktop and touch use in mind. Surface products are marketed as mobile devices, these are the devices I'm talking about. Therefore it's obvious that from the onset Edge was designed with Mobile use in mind and therefore prioritises efficiency, hence comparing it to desktop browsers that leave efficiency to their mobile counterparts is a flawed comparison.

Dear gawd.
So you're saying Chrome and Firefox ignore laptops? Pretty strange considering that personal laptops outnumber personal desktops pretty steadily since like 2008
 
So you're saying Chrome and Firefox ignore laptops? Pretty strange considering that personal laptops outnumber personal desktops pretty steadily since like 2008

No, not at all. I'm saying that the desktop variants of Chrome and Firefox obviously do not prioritise efficiency like Edge would being a 2 in 1 solution, therefore the comparison is flawed.
 
No, not at all.

There are two variants of Chrome, a desktop variant and a mobile variant. The desktop variant obviously does not prioritise efficiency, the mobile variant obviously does. When you consider that Edge is being compared to the desktop variant it actually makes Chrome look quite good.

Again, Chrome and Edge are similar. The mobile version of Edge doesn't support extensions. You've just not shown any areas where there's any structural differences.
 
No, not at all. I'm saying that the desktop variants of Chrome and Firefox obviously do not prioritise efficiency like Edge would being a 2 in 1 solution, therefore the comparison is flawed.

And how many laptops run on batteries, like all of them? PCs benefit from power efficiency so just not sure what point you're making.
 
Again, Chrome and Edge are similar. The mobile version of Edge doesn't support extensions. You've just not shown any areas where there's any structural differences.

What?! They're not comparing the strictly mobile version of Edge! Did IQ's just drop suddenly?

Edge is a 2 in 1 product on the x86 platform, in comparison Chrome and Firefox are strictly designed with desktop use in mind on the x86 platform. You cannot compare Edge to desktop variants of Chrome and Firefox, the testing is flawed.
 
And how many laptops run on batteries, like all of them? PCs benefit from power efficiency so just not sure what point you're making.

Once again, the point is not that that browsers run on laptops as well as desktops, the point is that the desktop variants of Chrome and Firefox are not specifically optimised for efficiency in mind.
 
At the end of the day... who cares if Edge is 10-20% easier on the power depending on the test. Its not exactly relevant. MS is never going to retake the browser market. Edge still fails some major web benchmarks... it looses in HTML5 compliance tests and bottom line is MS can no longer rely on a massive install base to force the web to play by their non-standard compliance BS.

MS has lost the browser wars and we are all better off for it. The only thing Edge will be good for going forward will be as the first program to run if you buy a Windows running machine to download Chrome or Firefox.
 
Edge is a 2 in 1 product on the x86 platform, in comparison Chrome and Firefox are strictly designed with desktop use in mind on the x86 platform.

Both FF and Chrome support touch on Windows, Chrome is basically as touch friendly as Edge, Edge is smoother with touch however.
 
Both FF and Chrome support touch on Windows, Chrome is basically as touch friendly as Edge, Edge is smoother with touch however.

I'm curious, as you keep saying edge is somehow better with touch then other software. How exactly ?
 
At the end of the day... who cares if Edge is 10-20% easier on the power depending on the test. Its not exactly relevant. MS is never going to retake the browser market. Edge still fails some major web benchmarks... it looses in HTML5 compliance tests and bottom line is MS can no longer rely on a massive install base to force the web to play by their non-standard compliance BS.

MS has lost the browser wars and we are all better off for it. The only thing Edge will be good for going forward will be as the first program to run if you buy a Windows running machine to download Chrome or Firefox.
https://html5test.com/compare/browser/chrome-57/edge-15/firefox-53/safari-10.2.html
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChadD
like this
I'm curious, as you keep saying edge is somehow better with touch then other software. How exactly ?

Touch scrolling and pinch zooming are much smoother in Edge compared to FF and Chrome across all the devices I've used. One nice touch Chrome has with backwards/forwards flicking is a grayed out preview of the page while refreshing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChadD
like this
Both FF and Chrome support touch on Windows, Chrome is basically as touch friendly as Edge, Edge is smoother with touch however.

It's the brainfade again!

The desktop variants of Chrome and Firefox are not designed with efficiency in mind like Edge as a 2 in 1 solution, there are mobile versions of Chrome and Firefox so efficiency is not a priority on the desktop variants in relation to x86! Of course you can use desktop Chrome and Firefox under a touch interface, the fact is the interfaces are not specifically designed with touch operation in mind as the browsers are not designed in any way whatsoever with mobile operation in mind. Under x86, Chrome and Firefox are designed as desktop software applications, while Edge is designed for use on mobile Surface products as evidenced by it's specific touch oriented interface - therefore it is not at all surprising that using Edge results in better battery life as it is designed from the onset as a 2 in 1 solution, unlike Chrome and Firefox.

The testing is flawed.
 
Touch scrolling and pinch zooming are much smoother in Edge compared to FF and Chrome across all the devices I've used. One nice touch Chrome has with backwards/forwards flicking is a grayed out preview of the page while refreshing.

However, under x86 Chrome is not specifically designed for mobile devices, Edge is.
 
MS is never going to retake the browser market.

Ok. And desktop Linux will never become the #1 PC gaming OS. But you still use it like many people say around here to game because it suits your purposes. It's Windows, use whatever the hell you want, that's what's great about it.
 

Thanks for proving my point... Chrome is the most compliant browser, and partly why it is well liked with people that work with the web. Average users we all know don't care about standards compliance unless stuff stops working.

No longer having to maintain terrible web code to support stupid IE has made a lot of people very happy. To be completely honest right now I don't care if MS put out the most compliant fastest bestest most fantastic browser the world has ever seen. I still won't use it and I will still suggest every client I have not use it, and every person who will listen to me not use it. MS can't be trusted to code to standards... and its why no one should ever touch their web software >.< MS new found standards compliance has 100% to do with their current install base. They will play nice with standards until it suits them to not play nice. If MS ever was to find themselves with a 20% or better Edge usage I would give it 1-2 updates before they started extending and messing with standards. I don't ever want to go back to having to maintain multiple versions of complex web code. No thanks... MS has proven they are not worthy.
 
Of course you can use desktop Chrome and Firefox under a touch interface, the fact is the interfaces are not specifically designed with touch operation in mind as the browsers are not designed in any way whatsoever with mobile operation in mind.

So FF and Chrome x86 work with touch but "are not designed in any way whatsoever with mobile operation in mind". That literally makes no sense because at one point NEITHER worked with touch without extensions and then not so great.
 
Ok. And desktop Linux will never become the #1 PC gaming OS. But you still use it like many people say around here to game because it suits your purposes. It's Windows, use whatever the hell you want, that's what's great about it.

Here we go....

ChadD had a valid point, MS are never going to retake the browser market. This childish remark is just baseless ranting in an attempt to stir up shit.
 
Touch scrolling and pinch zooming are much smoother in Edge compared to FF and Chrome across all the devices I've used. One nice touch Chrome has with backwards/forwards flicking is a grayed out preview of the page while refreshing.

Fair enough thanks for answering. It does make me wonder why that is exactly the case though... I can't imagine those features would be hard coded to one piece of software and not as an OS system. Of course we are talking about MS... so fair enough.
 
So FF and Chrome x86 work with touch but "are not designed in any way whatsoever with mobile operation in mind". That literally makes no sense because at one point NEITHER worked with touch without extensions and then not so great.

Because they're designed as desktop products! This comment highlight's this point! Thanks!

Gawd!
 
Ok. And desktop Linux will never become the #1 PC gaming OS. But you still use it like many people say around here to game because it suits your purposes. It's Windows, use whatever the hell you want, that's what's great about it.

I already made this joke a page back... I guess you didn't see or get that. :)

Thanks for making one Fantastic point as to why Chrome crushes edge.

Chrome... runs and syncs with. Windows 10, 8 .1, 8, 7, Linux, MacOS, OSX, Android, iOS, ChromeOS.

Edge runs in Windows 10 >.<

For that reason alone Edge will never break a couple % usage.
 
I already made this joke a page back... I guess you didn't see or get that. :)

Thanks for making one Fantastic point as to why Chrome crushes edge.

Chrome... runs and syncs with. Windows 10, 8 .1, 8, 7, Linux, MacOS, OSX, Android, iOS, ChromeOS.

Edge runs in Windows 10 >.<

For that reason alone Edge will never break a couple % usage.

One correction. Chrome and Firefox mobile run under Android and iOS, two segregated products in comparison to their desktop counterparts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChadD
like this
Because they're designed as desktop products! This comment highlight's this point! Thanks!

Gawd!

So Chrome is a desktop browser that now works with touch similar to Edge which was designed for mobile but Chrome wasn't? Chrome has been supporting touch before Edge even came out.
 
One correction. Chrome and Firefox mobile run under Android and iOS, two segregated products in comparison to their desktop counterparts.

Fair enough and your correct.

Still all I and most end users care about is that if I bookmark something in one its done in the other... if I visit a site on one the other remembers. When I get a new phone I sync and when I type H in the add bar it autocompletes hardocp.com :)

We don't live in a world where everyone runs nothing but windows... MS has ensured that by killing off their mobile OS. Even someone like Heatle can't get by without at least one device running a nix OS anymore. Chrome in one version or another works on everything sold and syncs without having to install third party junk. Edge could be the best browser ever made, without that true cross platform capability it will never gain market share.
 
I already made this joke a page back... I guess you didn't see or get that. :)

Thanks for making one Fantastic point as to why Chrome crushes edge.

Chrome... runs and syncs with. Windows 10, 8 .1, 8, 7, Linux, MacOS, OSX, Android, iOS, ChromeOS.

Edge runs in Windows 10 >.<

For that reason alone Edge will never break a couple % usage.

Fair enough. But if you're away from a power plug that extra battery life might be the important thing. I have FF, Chrome, IE, and Edge on all my personal systems. I used Edge primarily, Chrome when I need an extension like downloading video. Not really a big deal. My only thing about this is that I don't see Edge and Chrome on the desktop as intrinsically different. Chrome doesn't use more resources because it's an inherently better desktop browser. Indeed, I thought software that uses less resources was generally preferable.
 
So Chrome is a desktop browser that now works with touch similar to Edge which was designed for mobile but Chrome wasn't? Chrome has been supporting touch before Edge even came out.

Oh my god.

Edge is designed with touch interaction in mind, the layout of the product supports this. In direct comparison to Edge and even when compared to it's specific mobile counterpart (as there are two separate products unlike Edge), it's obvious that the interface of desktop Chrome is not specifically designed with touch interaction in mind as it is a desktop product, not a mobile product.

The point that Chrome now supports touch operation is completely irrelevant, in fact the point that it didn't support touch from the onset highlights that Chrome under x86 is designed as a desktop product with different priorities to a mobile product. Edge is designed as a 2 in 1 mobile/desktop product, that's why it's battery life is better, compare it to the mobile variant of Chrome and the results may sway in favour of Chrome.

The testing is flawed.
 
Even someone like Heatle can't get by without at least one device running a nix OS anymore.

If you don't need a mobile ecosystem, it's easy to get by a Windows Phone, just like it would be getting by without much of desktop ecosystem with desktop Linux.
 
Chrome doesn't use more resources because it's an inherently better desktop browser.

On a desktop machine, I find Chrome to be a far more suitable product in direct comparison to Edge due to Edge's 2 in 1 application - Edge is just too simplistic, too stripped out. It's a compromise of touch and desktop.
 
Back
Top