Amazon Workers Reject Proposal To Form Union

RTW states have lower unemployment and lower taxes and lower cost of living.

Do you just say this type of stuff without checking? RTW States don't have the lowest employment. RTW has very little to do with that. The local economy, exports, etc have a much larger impact.

But here's the list:
http://www.bls.gov/web/laus/laumstrk.htm

You are correct though with the lower cost of living in RTW states. Then again they also have the lowest standard of living and the highest poverty rates. Meaning it's cheap to live there because the people are so poor.

Can you point to ANY COUNTRY ON THE PLANET that does not have inequality?
The question isn't do they have inequality. It's how unequal is it compared to the US. It's a good thing we have numbers for that. So we don't have to guess.

We rank number 54 for having the worst. That's not good by the way because we have the worst of ANY developed country.

I would argue our march toward socialism has created a greater disparity in income because those who would otherwise fail and be removed from the ranks of the rich are now just getting bailed out.

March towards socialism? LMAO We are THE least socialistic country of any of the developed countries out there. We have the lowest minimum wage of developed countries, our health care outcomes are laughable compared to other countries as developed as us, lol march towards socialism...lol.

Now if by march toward socialism you mean the way we socialize economic recessions caused by the rich, well then you may be onto something there.
 
If they are warehouse workers for amazon it's likely they are under duress no matter what ;)

I always found conservatives against unions to be a funny idea. What's more free market and American than a union, people hiring help and banding together in order to increase their bargaining value, e pluribus unum.

So in other words just like large corporations who prevent unionization. Also i think you confuse current unions with unions of the 70's and 60's. Modern unions by far put less pressure on people but then you'd have to know people who are in and run union chapters.

You obviously don't know any conservative people, and only have a small understanding of what a conservative actually is (not what we are portrayed as in entertainment, media and propaganda industry, but I repeat myself).

Unions such as the SEIU are political powerhouses, and contribute more to political causes than any right-leaning private entities, including those dreaded and oh-so-awful Koch bros. that the "progressives" love to pick on.

These politically powerful unions rival or surpass large corporations in lobbying the government, and more or less own the Democrat party. This is never pointed out, because that spineless, socialist, evolve-on-any-issue-that-makes-me-look-good and unprincipled band of useless human beings that couldn't work there way out of a paper bag must be presented as representing the "oppressed" and "the little man", even though they themselves also rake in millions from large corporations and Wall Street. (Did you know that Wall Street banks were 3 out of the 5 biggest contributors to Barack Obama's 2008 presidential campaign? You don't have to answer that, because I assume I already know the answer.)

Unions such as SEIU support socialism, which is not freedom or free market by any means. If they had there way, the government (and them of course) would set wages, control the hiring and firing of workers, and seize control of the entire economy.

The fact that you think that modern unions are anything to do with free people coming together to protect each other shows a complete lack of knowledge and naivety that normally is relegated to the pages of Daily Kos and the Huffington Post. You sir or madam, like so many people on the left who think they are moderate or centered, are living in a reverberating bubble of mis- and disinformation.

The only remaining political affiliations that are for liberty and freedom are conservatives and libertarians, NOT progressives, liberals or socialists.
 
If they are warehouse workers for amazon it's likely they are under duress no matter what ;)

I always found conservatives against unions to be a funny idea. What's more free market and American than a union, people hiring help and banding together in order to increase their bargaining value, e pluribus unum.

Burden of proof and all that...

I worked as a non-union warehouse guy when I was 19. Let's just say working at Amazon would have been a big step up in pay, benefits, representation and quality of employment. This type of job isn't easy; we can't eliminate all hard jobs in America because they are hard.


Unions are fine if they don't put business out of business and behave in a reasonable way. A company still needs to make a profit, which Amazon doesn't.
 
Burden of proof and all that...

I worked as a non-union warehouse guy when I was 19. Let's just say working at Amazon would have been a big step up in pay, benefits, representation and quality of employment. This type of job isn't easy; we can't eliminate all hard jobs in America because they are hard.


Unions are fine if they don't put business out of business and behave in a reasonable way. A company still needs to make a profit, which Amazon doesn't.

Amazon's could make a profit if they wanted to, and the reason they don't has a lot to do with their forward thinking business model.
 

What is your opinion on USA's interest rate manipulation?
This creates asset bubbles and malinvestment, but that props up the rich :)

We have had progressively more government control over our healthcare industry over the last few decades. And I agree, its laughable. :)

In recent months we had the executive branch dictate adhoc conditional terms with no warning to insurance companies and hospitals. Direct manipulation of the means of production for this industry.
 

Just proving my point about the reverberating bubble. :rolleyes:

If you find yourself awaiting your FDA approved and government mandated breakfast ration before heading off to your union approved and government assigned job from your EPA approved and government assigned apartment, I sincerely hope you lol as well as you do now.
 
Amazon's could make a profit if they wanted to, and the reason they don't has a lot to do with their forward thinking business model.

Absolutely. I'm just trying to throw out the "they are big and successful, so they are bad" mindset. They are actually making it harder for the other established warehouse type companies out there, because they pay more and treat their employees better than most of them.
 
Just proving my point about the reverberating bubble. :rolleyes:

If you find yourself awaiting your FDA approved and government mandated breakfast ration before heading off to your union approved and government assigned job from your EPA approved and government assigned apartment, I sincerely hope you lol as well as you do now.

Wow somebody is paranoid. Won't someone protect us from the horrible FDA, making sure our food isn't poisoned, and the horrible EPA, making sure the air isn't poisoned? What about my FREEDOM?!?!
 
images


"Not Parnoid, just thinking and looking ahead."

-Chicken Little
 
Amazon's could make a profit if they wanted to, and the reason they don't has a lot to do with their forward thinking business model.
It's a monopoly based business model which should be worry some. By not making profits yet not going out of business because of it they can list prices and services for less than any other business as other businesses need to make profits to stay afloat.
 
RTW states have lower unemployment and lower taxes and lower cost of living.

Can you point to ANY COUNTRY ON THE PLANET that does not have inequality?

I would argue our march toward socialism has created a greater disparity in income because those who would otherwise fail and be removed from the ranks of the rich are now just getting bailed out.

I think Steinbeck got it correct, in regards to socialism in America: “Socialism never took root in America because the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires.”
 
Unions such as the SEIU are political powerhouses, and contribute more to political causes than any right-leaning private entities, including those dreaded and oh-so-awful Koch bros. that the "progressives" love to pick on.

These politically powerful unions rival or surpass large corporations in lobbying the government

Prove it.
 
It's a monopoly based business model which should be worry some. By not making profits yet not going out of business because of it they can list prices and services for less than any other business as other businesses need to make profits to stay afloat.

Not necessarily. Amazon as a whole isn't profitable, but that is because they are investing their margins for future growth up to 10-20 years down the line. That would have to mean that they are selling things above cost or they would not have the money to make those investments from their sales.
 
What is your opinion on USA's interest rate manipulation?
This creates asset bubbles and malinvestment, but that props up the rich :)
Not a big deal because all of the countries since 2007 have been quantitative easing their asses off to prop up the financial sector (banks).

We have had progressively more government control over our healthcare industry over the last few decades. And I agree, its laughable. :)

You obviously haven't actually read what the ACA does. If you had you would be pissed but not for the reasons you state here.

In recent months we had the executive branch dictate adhoc conditional terms with no warning to insurance companies and hospitals. Direct manipulation of the means of production for this industry.

LMAO. You believe the ACA was crafted without industry input? WOW. This is what you should do. Read what the bill does and then get back to me. The ACA was written by the industry itself.
 
I'm not denigrating you. I'm mocking you.

Definition of denigrate (vt)

den·i·grate [ dénni gràyt ]
1.defame: to attack somebody's character or reputation
2.disparage and belittle: to disparage or criticize somebody or something, or make something seem unimportant
 
Definition of denigrate (vt)

den·i·grate [ dénni gràyt ]
1.defame: to attack somebody's character or reputation
2.disparage and belittle: to disparage or criticize somebody or something, or make something seem unimportant

So I'm "denigrating" the risk the horrid FDA and EPA pose to our freedom then?
 
So I'm "denigrating" the risk the horrid FDA and EPA pose to our freedom then?

1. I never said the FDA and EPA were "horrid", those are your words.

2. You took what I said, "Not paranoid, just thinking and looking ahead" and ascribed it to a picture of Chicken Little, who is infamous for predicting the sky is falling when it did not. Or in other words, your ascribing my statement to Chicken Little was an attempt to belittle my position and opinion.
 
You are correct though with the lower cost of living in RTW states. Then again they also have the lowest standard of living and the highest poverty rates. Meaning it's cheap to live there because the people are so poor.

The poverty thing doesn't have a lot to do with unions or rights to work. It's mostly an educated, prosperous North versus an uneducated, deprived South thing. Just listen to the differences in how people speak and what sorts of cars they drive. In the South, there are a lot of people who own SUVs and trucks. They also say things like "y'all" and "giddy up" to each other. That shows pretty big gaps in logical thought because of buying big vehicles to attempt to intimidate and gaps in overall intelligence because of an inability to even attempt to use English correctly. The same root cause explains why shows like Springer were really popular in southern areas of the US. There's just a big, I think, genetic difference in the rate of mental development among children that's partly inherited, partly culturally backwards, and might have something to do with hotter, more water scarce environments that lack modern infrastructure. To even try to link poverty to unionization does a huge disservice to the fundamental human created problems in the southern areas of the US. It's basically a symptom of a much, much deeper cultural disease that we've been ignoring for a very long time because corporate entities want to block uncovering the truth of stunted mental development and country lifestyle as those sorts of people are demographically better consumers of products due to their tendency to waste more, produce more children per family, and have more easily exploited mental shortcomings and vices.
 
1. I never said the FDA and EPA were "horrid", those are your words.

2. You took what I said, "Not paranoid, just thinking and looking ahead" and ascribed it to a picture of Chicken Little, who is infamous for predicting the sky is falling when it did not. Or in other words, your ascribing my statement to Chicken Little was an attempt to belittle my position and opinion.

To belittle something or someone is to make them seem unimportant. Your position is unimportant. I'm not belitteling or denigrating it because I do not seek to make it seem worse than it is. I am mocking it because of how bad it actually is.
 
You're conveniently ignoring a request to prove your statements, Mr. Conservative.

Where? I will gladly play any requests, but you must be willing to read and comprehend them. Did I miss a post?

To belittle something or someone is to make them seem unimportant. Your position is unimportant. I'm not belitteling or denigrating it because I do not seek to make it seem worse than it is. I am mocking it because of how bad it actually is.

In your first two sentences, you admit to belitting and denigrating my statement, then in your third sentence you say your are not?
 
Not necessarily. Amazon as a whole isn't profitable, but that is because they are investing their margins for future growth up to 10-20 years down the line. That would have to mean that they are selling things above cost or they would not have the money to make those investments from their sales.

Yep. I don't know why people like to spread FUD about Amazon. I think too many people just like to direct their ire at the big guy, just because he's big.
 
Do you just say this type of stuff without checking? RTW States don't have the lowest employment. RTW has very little to do with that. The local economy, exports, etc have a much larger impact.

But here's the list:
http://www.bls.gov/web/laus/laumstrk.htm

You are correct though with the lower cost of living in RTW states. Then again they also have the lowest standard of living and the highest poverty rates. Meaning it's cheap to live there because the people are so poor.

Don't we have to be careful of the post hoc ergo propter hoc effect here ... many RTW states were poor long before they implemented RTW ... has RTW made their situation worse or has it improved since RTW can provide employment where it didn't previously exist (or switch people from public assistance to employment)

The question isn't do they have inequality. It's how unequal is it compared to the US. It's a good thing we have numbers for that. So we don't have to guess.

We rank number 54 for having the worst. That's not good by the way because we have the worst of ANY developed country.

What is an "acceptable" distribution of wealth ... when the poor become wealthy they don't usually give all their money away because they don't want to be disproportionately wealthy ... the USA also has a disproportionate share of high income achievers (Actors, Entrepreneurs, Business Executives, Sports Celebrities, Musicians, Authors, etc) ... we also have a large welfare class (for a variety of reasons) ... that tends to skew our data ... we also have relatively open immigration policies compared to lots of the other developed countries ... if we wanted to have a closed monocultural society, like many in the EU, then we too could improve our numbers (but at the cost of our culture and identity as the Great Melting Pot of the world)

March towards socialism? LMAO We are THE least socialistic country of any of the developed countries out there. We have the lowest minimum wage of developed countries, our health care outcomes are laughable compared to other countries as developed as us, lol march towards socialism...lol.

Now if by march toward socialism you mean the way we socialize economic recessions caused by the rich, well then you may be onto something there.

We aren't as socialistic as some countries but we still have a large welfare state ... we need to reduce our reliance on some socialistic elements (welfare) and increase the effectiveness of others (social security and medicare)
 
Yep. I don't know why people like to spread FUD about Amazon. I think too many people just like to direct their ire at the big guy, just because he's big.

QFT. Amazon got big for a reason. They put a lot of work into taking care of their customers.
 
Yep, and their employees, hence the reason we are all in this thread to start with. ;)

For the most part, yes they do. Obviously there are going to be some shitty warehouse managers here and there, but, like I said before, Amazon is also crushing competition by offering better wages, benefits and education than the rest.
 
Yep, and their employees, hence the reason we are all in this thread to start with. ;)

Well this was only one factory, the workers were under pressure from Amazon, which is heavily anti-union, not to unionize, and most unionization votes fail on the first election, so I don't really see how its evidence of that.
 
Don't we have to be careful of the post hoc ergo propter hoc effect here ... many RTW states were poor long before they implemented RTW ... has RTW made their situation worse or has it improved since RTW can provide employment where it didn't previously exist (or switch people from public assistance to employment)

There is empirical data supporting RTW reducing unemployment. As an example of RTW helping a state, you can consider South Carolina, who's unemployment rate has fallen 2.3% since it was enacted.

There is a fundamental misunderstanding of what a Right-to-Work law is that has been perpetrated and spread by union-loyalist politicians and media.

Right-to-Work laws, such as the one in South Carolina, makes it illegal for a union to force itself onto the workers and siphon money out of their paychecks, it does not make a union illegal. You can read South Carolina's and all others from here: http://www.nrtw.org/c/scrtwlaw.htm
 
Well this was only one factory, the workers were under pressure from Amazon, which is heavily anti-union, not to unionize, and most unionization votes fail on the first election, so I don't really see how its evidence of that.

I certainly believe it's indicative of how they treat their employees. If working there was so bad, why would they vote down the unionization if there is federal and state protection guaranteeing them they wouldn't lose their jobs?

Why is it, that when employees deny joining a union, they have always been pressured by the company, but when employees approve joining a union, they have never been pressured by the union? :confused:
 
Well this was only one factory, the workers were under pressure from Amazon, which is heavily anti-union, not to unionize, and most unionization votes fail on the first election, so I don't really see how its evidence of that.

The union leader said they were under pressure to vote no. He has no reason not to run a propaganda campaign, everything to gain and nothing to lose.
 
The union leader said they were under pressure to vote no. He has no reason not to run a propaganda campaign, everything to gain and nothing to lose.

Amazon has always been anti-union. They hired Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, and were having "information sessions" with the workers to teach them how bad unions are for the country.

I don't think Unions are necessarily the end-all solution for everything, but there are some cases where they work and some cases where they are needed. Its fine for me if they voted this down and maybe it was enough to send Amazon a message about their labor conditions and/or pay if they had a problem with them.

I just don't think its some sort of validation of Amazon's employment conditions of the workers voted this down. They obviously had enough of a problem with them to call a vote in the first place.
 
Amazon has always been anti-union. They hired Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, and were having "information sessions" with the workers to teach them how bad unions are for the country.

I don't think Unions are necessarily the end-all solution for everything, but there are some cases where they work and some cases where they are needed. Its fine for me if they voted this down and maybe it was enough to send Amazon a message about their labor conditions and/or pay if they had a problem with them.

I just don't think its some sort of validation of Amazon's employment conditions of the workers voted this down. They obviously had enough of a problem with them to call a vote in the first place.

All of the modern west coast silicon valley and other start up companies are not in favor of unions (Intel, Google, Facebook, Starbucks, Microsoft, Apple, Oracle, NVidia, etc) ... they have all experienced a variety of market ups and downs and they all consider their lack of unions a competitive advantage since it allows management to make work force adjustments that benefit the overall company (without having to endure the complex labor problems that the east coast companies have had to endure ... Automakers, Airlines, etc) ... given that the Airlines all had to declare bankruptcy to change their union policies, this is probably a valid point
 
Amazon has always been anti-union. They hired Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, and were having "information sessions" with the workers to teach them how bad unions are for the country.

I don't think Unions are necessarily the end-all solution for everything, but there are some cases where they work and some cases where they are needed. Its fine for me if they voted this down and maybe it was enough to send Amazon a message about their labor conditions and/or pay if they had a problem with them.

I just don't think its some sort of validation of Amazon's employment conditions of the workers voted this down. They obviously had enough of a problem with them to call a vote in the first place.

Of course they are anti union.

As for the "information sessions", the union did the same thing. Unions like these approach employees, they don't sit around waiting for petitions. They are very aggressive in trying to crack a company open to insert their labor monopolies. There is no downside for a union.
 
Back
Top