Blaming Violent Video Games For Everything

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
There is an editorial on the popularity of blaming violent video games for everything on Forbes.com today that is definitely worth reading.

Tens of millions of these games are sold and tens of millions of people play them on a regular basis and how many of these people become violent killers? It’s actually very similar to gun ownership stats: very few gun owners end up going on shooting rampages. Very few gamers go on shooting rampages. Neither guns nor video games cause people to be violent.
 
The weirdest guy i ever met that owned guns and that I had a 50/50 on him being a ticking time bomb was a big fan of my little pony, and Minecraft.

My little pony fans are freaking out there.
 
I think ratings by the industry groups are ultimately the best solution ... we definitely don't need the video game equivalent of the Hays Commission ... and most of the analysis of video game and media violence and its affect on society has the smell of the infamous "Seduction of the Innocent" study that led to the bans of violent comic books in the 50s ... ratings leave the choices in the hands of the parents (which is where they should belong) ;)
 
Nothing most of us can't surmise on our own.

Didn't know bot NRA app though. Retardation.... the lot of them.
 
0% of the people who don't have guns have gone to a shooting rampage lol. Statistics are a devils tool.

Then again banning guns didn't stop all the Chinese knife attacks to daycare centers etc. It seems that when guns go out of the equation the attacks are more often targeted against the physically helpless.
 
I think the point is fair that America is unique to these types of shootings and perhaps we should look at the other ways in which America is unique for answers.
 
In the 80s politicians and the media told me constantly that everything bad was caused by rock music. Now nobody seems to care about rock music, and games get the blame for everything. I wonder what the next scapegoat will be?

Why can't they accept that out of the 300million people in America a few of them will go mad and kill people. It's not the fault of the games industry, nor is it a problem with guns. It's a simple fact that with some many people a few are bound to snap.

If you ban games people will still go on a killing spree. If you ban guns they'll use a kitchen knife. Taking away the freedom of law abiding citizens is not the solutions, and yet it's what the government does as a solution to everything, be it school shootings, terrorism or child pornography. The government never solves any problems, it just creates new ones.
 
I think the point is fair that America is unique to these types of shootings and perhaps we should look at the other ways in which America is unique for answers.

America is not unique to this kind of shootings. Finland has a lot of them too compared to the population size. Then again there are 2 million guns in Finland with 5 million people...
 
0% of the people who don't have guns have gone to a shooting rampage lol. Statistics are a devils tool.

Then again banning guns didn't stop all the Chinese knife attacks to daycare centers etc. It seems that when guns go out of the equation the attacks are more often targeted against the physically helpless.

Adam Lanza didn't have guns, his mother did. Your statistics are invalid :p

A lot of people on the left seem to act like people only started being killed after guns were invented. We seemed to be doing a pretty good job of it well before then...
 
The NRA should really back off it's anti-video game stance and instead start creating allies in the game industry.

I can definitely see years of video game playing as creating responsible gun owners in real life. Play the game, now own the real thing!

Young people also seem to be very receptive to gun ownership:
http://www.american.edu/media/news/20120114_Gun_Poll_High_School_College_Students.cfm

I like how that article tries to tie "stressed out" as a mental problem... because, you know, life is so f'ing easy that nobody should be stressed :rolleyes:
 
In the 80s politicians and the media told me constantly that everything bad was caused by rock music. Now nobody seems to care about rock music, and games get the blame for everything. I wonder what the next scapegoat will be?

Why can't they accept that out of the 300million people in America a few of them will go mad and kill people. It's not the fault of the games industry, nor is it a problem with guns. It's a simple fact that with some many people a few are bound to snap.

If you ban games people will still go on a killing spree. If you ban guns they'll use a kitchen knife. Taking away the freedom of law abiding citizens is not the solutions, and yet it's what the government does as a solution to everything, be it school shootings, terrorism or child pornography. The government never solves any problems, it just creates new ones.

Actually, if you ban guns they'll still use guns. There will just be one extra crime to the list they committed.
 
Violent video games are making me FAT!
('course i suppose i could get outta my chair and do sumthin.....naaaaaah!)
 
America is not unique to this kind of shootings. Finland has a lot of them too compared to the population size. Then again there are 2 million guns in Finland with 5 million people...
There are more civilian guns (aka not police and not military) in the US then there are people 16 years and older (270 million civilian guns vs 243 million people 16 and older). Also another scary thought is that the US civilian gun population is 30.9% of the total world gun population (875 million total guns which includes civilian, police, and military) vs only having 4.5% of the world's population.

Sources: 2010 US Census and http://www.smallarmssurvey.org/fileadmin/docs/H-Research_Notes/SAS-Research-Note-9.pdf

People wonder why there are so many gun crimes in the US. Maybe because they are everywhere and easy to acquire? Na, that couldn't be it. :rolleyes:
 
There is an editorial on the popularity of blaming violent video games for everything on Forbes.com today that is definitely worth reading.

If you mean worth reading because the author is a blithering idiot... then yes.

If you meant worth reading because I thought he had something to say that was logical and made sense... then no.
 
If you mean worth reading because the author is a blithering idiot... then yes.

If you meant worth reading because I thought he had something to say that was logical and made sense... then no.

Really? What was idiotic about his article? I enjoyed it and felt like it was well done.

Though if you are an NRA member, you probably wouldn't like it.
 
Very few gamers go on shooting rampages. Neither guns nor video games cause people to be violent.

The point is you can't predict who's mentally unhealthy. Why games? Cause NRA likes to abuse this dead horse just to get people off their backs. But in the end a crazy person with a game disc is just going to at best cut you. A crazed person with a gun though is a different story.

When I went to school there was this guy who was quiet, and the kids in school would abuse him. They would throw stuff at him, and I would watch the guy. At some point I got sick of this, and defended the guy. The kids started picking on me but I'm 6ft 4inches, so they didn't get far.

I got to know the guy and found something scary. The guy had magazines of guns and knives. He was obsessed with them. He also played video games but he didn't have a stack of Nintendo Power. I then realized that bullying can sometimes push people into obsession towards weapons. From there, all it takes is one really bad move from someone to push him over.
 
[21CW]killerofall;1039523990 said:
There are more civilian guns (aka not police and not military) in the US then there are people 16 years and older (270 million civilian guns vs 243 million people 16 and older). Also another scary thought is that the US civilian gun population is 30.9% of the total world gun population (875 million total guns which includes civilian, police, and military) vs only having 4.5% of the world's population.

Sources: 2010 US Census and http://www.smallarmssurvey.org/fileadmin/docs/H-Research_Notes/SAS-Research-Note-9.pdf

People wonder why there are so many gun crimes in the US. Maybe because they are everywhere and easy to acquire? Na, that couldn't be it. :rolleyes:

There are other nations with extremely high gun ownership and very low gun violence. Again gun ownership has nothing to do with gun violence. There is no correlation there. Even saying the amount of guns makes it more prevalent has been proven incorrect when looking at empirical evidence suggesting otherwise. The author did a good job mentioning Sweden, but there are other examples of that too. Also note that countries who enact stricter gun control do not statistically have less crime. Nor do they statistically have less mass shootings. Australia has been set as a prime example of how gun control should be done, however, they haven't statistically had less mass shootings. It actually didn't impact mass shootings at all. Nor did it magically make crime go down. So there again is no correlation that either having more guns causes more problems, not that have stricter gun control lessens the problems.

0% of the people who don't have guns have gone to a shooting rampage lol. Statistics are a devils tool.

Then again banning guns didn't stop all the Chinese knife attacks to daycare centers etc. It seems that when guns go out of the equation the attacks are more often targeted against the physically helpless.

Statistically invalid. There are in fact many shooting deaths and a lot of gun violence that is performed by those stealing guns or borrowing guns to commit their crimes. In fact crimes by legal gun owners is quite low. In your example about non gun violence still being a problem, look up home invasions in the UK. Also you can look up the underground market for guns in China which is quite a racket.
 
Adam Lanza didn't have guns, his mother did. Your statistics are invalid :p

A lot of people on the left seem to act like people only started being killed after guns were invented. We seemed to be doing a pretty good job of it well before then...

The point about Lanza's mother is one that seems to be glossed over,and proves that bad judgment can be a major factor. She knew her son had problems,and tried to get help,but at the same time kept all those guns in the house.
And we seemed to be doing a good job of it long before video games were invented,as well.
 
The point about Lanza's mother is one that seems to be glossed over,and proves that bad judgment can be a major factor. She knew her son had problems,and tried to get help,but at the same time kept all those guns in the house.
And we seemed to be doing a good job of it long before video games were invented,as well.

Well it's not the only car glossed over. Consider the frezy about "assualt rifles" since this shooting because the shooter had an AR-15, but what the anti-gun media fails to mention is that according to the FBI that rifle was in the shooters car and was not used on his rampage and instead he used four pistols.

But of course if they reported the fact honestly there would be less support for an assault rifle ban.

As Rahm Emanuel said when he was Obama's chief of staff:

You never want a serious crisis to go to waste. And what I mean by that is an opportunity to do things you think you could not do before

Which is what all this is about, Politicians across the country and using the Sandy Hook tragedy to push their own anti-gun agenda through.
 
I think the point is fair that America is unique to these types of shootings and perhaps we should look at the other ways in which America is unique for answers.

This is pure ignorance.

America in not close to being unique to these types of shootings.

Second for those nitwits who want to blame gun ownership these things happen in countries with low gun ownership rates and tough restrictions. There vast vast vast majority of homicides in the US from all causes is directly related to US drug culture and the "War on Drugs".

There were about 400 people killed with all types rifles in the US last year, there were more people beat to death with hammers. You are more likely to be killed with a knife, club, or hammer than any kind of rifle.
 
As for games and violence, I can't believe people have such a hard to with the simple concept that games wont make someone into a mass murderer but it's only logical to think that someone prone to murder would gravitate toward violent games.

Consider Charles Manson, who someone managed to be a violent psycho long before videogames, and gave him a game console with two games, a Barbie game and Postal 2, which would you think he would spend more time playing?
 
Which is what all this is about, Politicians across the country and using the Sandy Hook tragedy to push their own anti-gun agenda through.

Thank goodness. The NRA has a stranglehold on American politics at every level, and this is finally an event that can break through their almost impenetrable wall.

It's terrible that it takes a group of mass shootings in one single year to finally promote sensible gun legislation, and much of it still won't pass, but at least its a start.
 
Thank goodness. The NRA has a stranglehold on American politics at every level, and this is finally an event that can break through their almost impenetrable wall.

It's terrible that it takes a group of mass shootings in one single year to finally promote sensible gun legislation, and much of it still won't pass, but at least its a start.

And will you be as supportive when they push through "sensible" internet regulations such as SOPA?
 
Then after SOPA they can work on some "sensible" regulation concerning freedom of speech, the press, religion, search and seizure, etc...
 
America is not unique to this kind of shootings. Finland has a lot of them too compared to the population size. Then again there are 2 million guns in Finland with 5 million people...

And let's not even get started on violent shooting tyrades that happen in African, Central American, South American, and Middle Eastern countries...and a fair amount of those with assault rifles.
 
So Erik Kain claims that "only place where regular mass shootings occur (at schools, theaters, etc.) is the United States." I don't believe that. I think it is more accurate to say that the only place where shootings are regularly reported and hyped by the media is the US. How many mass murders are widely publicized in the state media controlled "People's Reublic" of China? Does this guy have any idea how many mass shootings occur in third world countries across the globe every day? Apparently not.

Erik also says that he finds it "ludicrous" to have armed guards in schools. We protect the "VIPs" in our country with armed guards (e.g. Resident Obama, his family, members of congress). So why is it so ludicrous to do the same thing with our school children? I guess the children are way less important to us than politicians. In fact, school children must be subjected to "gun free zones" in order to tell the crazies where they can do the most damage.
 
And this thread is a microcosm of what freedom, liberty, and tyranny are all about.

1) Everyone here believes and agrees that violent video games don't make killers. There is ample and near infinite common sense stats to back this up.

We get upset when government, or others, tell us what kind of games we can play.

2) Some of those same people here won't make the mentally honest leap that guns don't make killers either. There is also ample and near infinite common sense stats to back this up.

Consider that those who like to remain free get upset when government, or others, tell them what kind of guns they can buy or if they can buy them at all.

Don't want a violent video game? Don't buy one.
Don't want a gun? Don't buy one.
Personal choice is what it is all about.

THIS IS FREEDOM AND LIBERTY FOLKS. ENJOY YOUR LIFE AND TO WHATEVER EXTENT POSSIBLE STAY OUT OF OTHERS. OTHERWISE, OTHER PEOPLE DECIDING EVERY ASPECT OF HOW EVERYONE SHOULD LIVE WILL COME FOR WHAT YOU LOVE NEXT.
 
Thank goodness. The NRA has a stranglehold on American politics at every level, and this is finally an event that can break through their almost impenetrable wall.

It's terrible that it takes a group of mass shootings in one single year to finally promote sensible gun legislation, and much of it still won't pass, but at least its a start.

First, the NRA does not have a strangle hold on politics. This is something many leftist liberals believe, but simply isn't true. They lobby just like the media lobbies. The thing is, the media has far more money than the NRA.

Secondly, it depends on what you consider 'sensible' legislation. Much of what has been proposed is not sensible at all. Including the absolutely staggering mandate for the Affordable Care Act saying doctors should now question people about guns in their homes. Really?!?! That is just absurd and is a complete invasion of privacy under the guise of medicine. Also, this is a very definite step forward to removing your doctor/patient privacy, which if you are not aware, has completely been broken down by the Affordable Care Act, as many provisions require doctors to feed the government more information. Almost all of the mandates passed by Obama are increasing the governments invasion into your privacy. It is just yet another step for the government to take more control of people's lives.

And has been shown over and over, more gun control does not equal less violence, less crime or less deaths. There is no simple solution, nor any gun control legislation that is going to fix the problem. Strict gun control measures would open up a huge black market that would make things even worse, a lot like the war on drugs only more dangerous. Also, it doesn't address the root problem at all, which is why are these individuals going on these shooting sprees? And what is really behind all the gun violence? That is what needs to be addressed. There were a few mandates involving that, but nothing concrete and barely anything that is going to really address the problem.

Also note, that the author was not at all encouraging more gun control legislation, but perfecting existing regulation. He was simply pointing out the hypocrisy in what the NRA is saying and doing. The author is actually for gun ownership, but more importantly he is for constitutional rights. This is why he is attacking the NRA in these articles.
 
They do the same things with guns and everything else. Politicians and their sycophants are true idiots.

"People die! OMG BAN SOMETHING!!!"
 
And let's not even get started on violent shooting tyrades that happen in African, Central American, South American, and Middle Eastern countries...and a fair amount of those with assault rifles.

There is NO link between accessibility to guns (or weapons/video games) and murder rates... there IS a link between poverty and lack of education and murder rates. Let the true believers stuff that in their pipes.
 
Thank goodness. The NRA has a stranglehold on American politics at every level, and this is finally an event that can break through their almost impenetrable wall.

It's terrible that it takes a group of mass shootings in one single year to finally promote sensible gun legislation, and much of it still won't pass, but at least its a start.

"Sensible gun legislation"? What was insensible about what we had before the media played up a couple of shootings for weeks upon weeks? What was sensible about things like the Assault Weapons Ban, which did nothing to stop tragedies like Columbine and the Hollywood bank heist shootout(in one of the most anti-gun states)?
 
Allowing research in gun related injuries is sensible. The NRA has effectively killed that from the CDC and the ATF.

Restricting the means to mass kill is sensible, like banning high-capacity magazines and restricting military-style weapons like the AR-15.

Americans have the lowest life expectancy of anyone living in a wealthy country, and guns are factor. We certainly don't need to ban all guns or ban owning multiple weapons. But changes should be made that help us all.
 
this has been going on since.I was a kid starting with night trap where they went kn to say ton of stuff about ghe game that was never in it. they never. played them. it goes.on every few years. hell thet have. been. doing it for so long the first set of kids they did. not want playing. them in the early 90s are sll adults and then some.
 
Allowing research in gun related injuries is sensible. The NRA has effectively killed that from the CDC and the ATF.

That is incorrect, there is tons of research into gun related injuries. There are tons of facts and figures out there by doing simple google searches. Also, that has no bearing on what other countries do and report. So there is literally a treasure trove of information and research on these issues. Almost all of it pointing to the same exact thing, that there is NO correlation between the amount of guns and mass shootings. NOR is there a correlation between the amount of guns and death or murder by firearms. ALSO there is barely any correlation between the amount of guns and gun violence. And there certainly is no correlation whatsoever between these events and the types of guns.

Restricting the means to mass kill is sensible, like banning high-capacity magazines and restricting military-style weapons like the AR-15.

So that would stop the biggest tragedy of all which was the Virginia Tech shooting how? He didn't use assault weapons, he didn't use high capacity magazines. Also Adam Lanza DID NOT USE an AR-15. There are even doubts whether the gun found in his vehicle was even an AR-15 or not. Many experts say it was a type of shotgun. In fact please list for me the percentage of these mass shootings that actually 'included' assault weapons with high capacity magazines.

Americans have the lowest life expectancy of anyone living in a wealthy country, and guns are factor. We certainly don't need to ban all guns or ban owning multiple weapons. But changes should be made that help us all.

Where to start on this statement... First, average life expectancy in the United States has absolutely NOTHING to do with guns. There is ZERO correlation to that at all. Second, our life expectancy is actually quite high considering how poor the average health is of individuals in the US. What makes our health system so well adapted to our culture is how effective it is at treating serious conditions. This is being undermined by the health care changes being forced by the government. Our average life expectancy is affected more by the amount of stress and lack of proper exercise and nutrition for the average person in the US. All things that are mostly personal responsibilities, not government or health industry responsibilities.
 
The government and society can always find someone else to blame for their problems:

In the 30's it was the movies so they created the Hays Commission to establish better guidelines to prevent the evil influences that might come from movies and later television

In the 50's Seduction of the Innocent pointed the finger of guilt at comic books (that were turning innocent young men into juvenile delinquents and innocent young ladies into lesbians and hussies)

In the 80's and 90's it was music that was the culprit

Now it is video games

There is always someone or something to blame so that individuals and society don't have to be held accountable on their own ;)
 
The gun industry needs to quit marketing assault weapon look-alikes to kids like Joe Camel.

Put a brown wood stock on a Bushmaster .223, the appeal goes way down.
Same gun, a wood stock has zero to do with how a firearm functions, but a lot to do with making it look black 'n scarey, evidently something bullied school shooters seem to need in a firearm.
 
America's gun laws are a joke. It's time to tell all these rednecks to get rid of their absurd machine guns which are used for "hunting" or whatever. The rest of the world is laughing at America's love affair with their guns and idiots like Alex Jones only add fuel to the fire.
 
Back
Top