What's the biggest benefit of SATA over PATA besides future compatability?

skippnr

Weaksauce
Joined
Feb 28, 2008
Messages
88
What's the biggest benefit of SATA over PATA besides future compatability?
 
Well, we can tell you some benefits and you can determine for yourself what's the biggest benefit.


A small and incomplete list:

hot swapping support
NCQ
smaller diameter cable
no master/slave jumpers to configure
higher bandwidth capacity
 
Cleaner wiring and simpler configuration (generally only one or no jumpers) - that's about it. NCQ slows things down for a single user. The transfer rate of the current physical design of the drives doesn't come near the available bandwidth of even PATA not to mention SATA 150. Even the perpendicular recording design just nudges to over 100MB/sec in spots on the 7200 rpm drives. If anyone else takes up WD's gauntlet and does some 10k SATA drives with perp., then there might be some advance at the cost of extra noise. But I probably won't buy another PATA HDD unless the one in my external enclosure craps out.

.bh.
 
Sockman summed it up well

not to oversimplify, but it's somewhat similar to "why is this USB keyboard superior to this PS/2 kboard?" ;)
 
You also can typically find the bigger faster hard drives in SATA formats much easier, from what I've seen. Aside from that, the cleaner cable designs make installing the parts easier and neater.
 
SATA is clearly the successor to PATA. Most motherboards today only have one PATA port but 6 or more SATA ports. It won't be too long before PATA disappears completely.

Another nice thing about SATA is you can convert it into external SATA (eSATA) with just a simple bracket... basically allowing you to use an external hard drive at internal speeds.

You're right about future compatability... if you start buying SATA drives now, you'll be set for a loooong time.
 
Well, the connectors on SATA drives and mobos are much more fragile than on the PATA drives and ports. They could be an order of magnitude (10x) stronger with a simple change, but IDK if any of the HD companies do it.

.bh.
 
Well, the connectors on SATA drives and mobos are much more fragile than on the PATA drives and ports.
That's, for the most part, just an opinion. I've broken many IDE cables in my day, but I've been very happy with the SATA cables, and to me, they feel quite a bit stronger. Also, because the plug itself sits up away from the drive or mobo, you have more to grab when you go to disconnect them, whereas IDE cables don't give you might to grab onto.
 
That's, for the most part, just an opinion. I've broken many IDE cables in my day, but I've been very happy with the SATA cables, and to me, they feel quite a bit stronger. Also, because the plug itself sits up away from the drive or mobo, you have more to grab when you go to disconnect them, whereas IDE cables don't give you might to grab onto.

Exactly! I always hated pulling IDE cables... there's nothing to grab except the ribbon cable itself. Who thought it was a good idea to make the IDE connector so small that it disappears into the socket? At least with Sata there is a plug that has some plastic to grab onto.
 
Pata is going the way of the DODO bird. Don't buy them now unless you have a specific need for one or it is a REALLY good sale.

My 7200.11 came configured in SATA I mode for compatibility. When I changed it to SATA II mode, the transfer rate stayed the same. but the Burst rate when from 105 MB/sec to 185 MB/sec. That prolly has little notice in day to day use. Just something to keep in mind.

Sata I is becoming saturated. It was good timing for Sata II to be released. :)

Don
 
Back
Top