Seagate Debuts First 16TB Hard Drive

omegatotal

Gawd
Joined
Mar 15, 2002
Messages
672
WD is not a bastion of reliability either.

IDK man, they have done pretty well in the non-enterprise markets, I have 1/2 dozen WD drives that have seen 40k hours of 24/7 access on some drives, that have zero realloc sectors across all of those drives.

And a pair of WD 1tb blacks that were in my lan machine going everywhere with me instead of sitting on a shelf, zero realloc sectors in 70k hours one of them, the other has a few dozen but no other errors and no other slowdowns.

I have inherited a par of WD drives that were overheated and killed (wrong drive for the type of nas and they got to 60+C and eventually died), they were technically out of warranty (no Proof of purchase, and the MFG expiration date had passed a month or two prior to my warranty claim) but they still replaced them free of charge.

I have gone through a few dozen seagates over the years from the FW based fails on the 7200.10 and 7200.11 series to just plain insane realloc sector counts on DM001 series AF drives in workstations.

No drive is perfect and some drives even recover from some issues. I have a pair of HGST HDS series 7200 3TB's that both have realloc, one has in the 2k range, but it still works, sometimes reads slow, they are both getting replaced soon (un-important data storage like downloads and tv shows that I have original discs or that are recorded/time shifted by my plex server via OTA HDHomeRun tuners).

WD has had a few hiccups that they were quick to fix from my understanding.

All of this is from a (pro)consumer/SMB product standpoint, not enterprise.

The current report is interesting tho. looks like seagate has made some serious improvements.
https://www.backblaze.com/blog/2018-hard-drive-failure-rates/
 

M76

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Jun 12, 2012
Messages
11,481
IDK man, they have done pretty well in the non-enterprise markets, I have 1/2 dozen WD drives that have seen 40k hours of 24/7 access on some drives, that have zero realloc sectors across all of those drives.

And a pair of WD 1tb blacks that were in my lan machine going everywhere with me instead of sitting on a shelf, zero realloc sectors in 70k hours one of them, the other has a few dozen but no other errors and no other slowdowns.

I have inherited a par of WD drives that were overheated and killed (wrong drive for the type of nas and they got to 60+C and eventually died), they were technically out of warranty (no Proof of purchase, and the MFG expiration date had passed a month or two prior to my warranty claim) but they still replaced them free of charge.

I have gone through a few dozen seagates over the years from the FW based fails on the 7200.10 and 7200.11 series to just plain insane realloc sector counts on DM001 series AF drives in workstations.

No drive is perfect and some drives even recover from some issues. I have a pair of HGST HDS series 7200 3TB's that both have realloc, one has in the 2k range, but it still works, sometimes reads slow, they are both getting replaced soon (un-important data storage like downloads and tv shows that I have original discs or that are recorded/time shifted by my plex server via OTA HDHomeRun tuners).

WD has had a few hiccups that they were quick to fix from my understanding.

All of this is from a (pro)consumer/SMB product standpoint, not enterprise.

The current report is interesting tho. looks like seagate has made some serious improvements.
https://www.backblaze.com/blog/2018-hard-drive-failure-rates/
I don't think your sample size of 6 drives is big enough.

Seagates are the worst, we can agree on that, but also the cheapest anywhere, so we keep using them. But the second largest failure rate is WD in my experience. Those greens keep dying. And some of the reds as well. Of course AFAIK they only differ in FW. We use consumer drives mostly at work, so I have a pretty large sample size.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mikeo
like this

Eshelmen

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Feb 3, 2004
Messages
4,928
Here I am sitting with like 8 tb of total space, and I feel like a god....

YOu guys are crazy for needing so much, lmfao
 
  • Like
Reactions: mikeo
like this
Top