Both the wife and I have Pixel 2XL phones that we really have no complaints with, outside of damaged screens. Both are paid for, both have insurance and both are over two years old. At this point we are leaning towards paying the deductibles and just having them replaced, but neither of us are really following the market. I have heard of crappy battery life on the 4, but is there anything out there that's worth buying into vs the $150 deductibles on our current phones?
![[H]ard|Forum](/styles/hardforum/xenforo/logo_dark.png){kind=logo}
Replace a Pixel 2XL for?
- Thread starter Nimisys
- Start date
OFaceSIG
2[H]4U
- Joined
- Aug 31, 2009
- Messages
- 4,040
If you feel the need to insure your phone, maybe you are buying phones that cost more then you are comfortable with. I would suggest buying cheaper phones, and forgoing the insurance. That's what I do.
The Pixel 3a is a fantastic phone for the money. The iPhone SE is reviewed very well and is also "cheap".
The Pixel 3a is a fantastic phone for the money. The iPhone SE is reviewed very well and is also "cheap".
Last edited:
A few questions to ask before making recommendations:
- How much do you prefer Android over iOS?
- What are you reasonably willing to spend (with a bit of wiggle room, most likely)?
- How much do you value camera quality, performance or (if going Android) a 'pure' interface?
- Are there any features you'd really like to have, like wireless charging or a headphone jack?
kirbyrj
Fully [H]
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2005
- Messages
- 30,693
What do they send you when you pay the deductible? Some sort of refurbished phone? Who is the insurance through? Google?
You can get a "replacement" Pixel 2XL for cheaper than $150 if you shop around is what I'm getting at, but if it's a refurb direct from Google, you'd probably get a higher quality replacement than a used or user refurbished one.
You can get a "replacement" Pixel 2XL for cheaper than $150 if you shop around is what I'm getting at, but if it's a refurb direct from Google, you'd probably get a higher quality replacement than a used or user refurbished one.
Domingo
Fully [H]
- Joined
- Jul 30, 2004
- Messages
- 22,638
I'm also curious to know what the insurance covers. With flagship phones doing for more than a grand, that might not be that bad of a purchase. At least depending on what it costs/covers.
I tend to keep a phone at least two years, sometimes as long as 5yrs. A lot can happen during that time, and I don't always have the capital at a moment's notice to buy another equivalent phone. So paying an extra 8$ a month of the device is paying extra that when/if something goes wrong, I am not beyond my ability to replace it. Case in point: 4 months after getting her phone, my wife's phone was stolen. At the time a replacement P2XL was still over 500 for near new, deductible was 150$.
Are either worth the difference in cost?
Android > Dumb Phone > IOS
~750$ each
Camera is very high, performance and Pure are close seconds.
Battery life equal to what we have now
I forgot the name of the company,, but we have both received replacements from them, both were Google Refurbs and maintained the original 2yr warranty.
8$ a month, 150$ deductible. Lost/Stolen/Damaged.
In the days of 300$ flagships, wasn't worthwhile, however with good/flagship phones being $600+ using it once pays for it.
T4rd
Fully [H]
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2009
- Messages
- 20,111
Still holding onto my 2 XL and its doing great still, but I've trashed a couple screen protectors on it too, so goes to show how important they are.
The only phones I'd consider right now to replace it are the S20/S20+, Pixel 3a or imminent 4a, OP 7/7T/Pro (hate the new designs and price of the 8/8Pro) or the iPhone 11 if you're not opposed to iOS. Current Pixel 4 might sell be available for $500, but I can't consider it at any price for its overall lack of hardware, but esp no wide angle camera, mediocre battery, and its face unlock still not being supported in a few of my apps so I'd rather have a fingerprint scanner still.
I almost got a S20+/Ultra, but I my 2 XL is still doing so well I can't bring myself to replace it yet. My son has had a 3a XL since it launched and its been great so far and camera is just as good as my 2 XL's.
The only phones I'd consider right now to replace it are the S20/S20+, Pixel 3a or imminent 4a, OP 7/7T/Pro (hate the new designs and price of the 8/8Pro) or the iPhone 11 if you're not opposed to iOS. Current Pixel 4 might sell be available for $500, but I can't consider it at any price for its overall lack of hardware, but esp no wide angle camera, mediocre battery, and its face unlock still not being supported in a few of my apps so I'd rather have a fingerprint scanner still.
I almost got a S20+/Ultra, but I my 2 XL is still doing so well I can't bring myself to replace it yet. My son has had a 3a XL since it launched and its been great so far and camera is just as good as my 2 XL's.
This makes it a bit tricky. I'd say OnePlus 8, but the camera system is a definite step backward from what you're used to -- and the older phones won't really be better. Maybe a standard Galaxy S20 if you can find a sale on it?
It's a shame that you're ruling out the iPhone 11, since you'd likely get the best overall camera quality (Pixels are lousy with video and some other cirucmstances), strong battery life and brisk performance.
Domingo
Fully [H]
- Joined
- Jul 30, 2004
- Messages
- 22,638
Hopping between iOS and Android has never been easier, honestly. They mostly work the same and things like your contact list, calendar, etc. are cloud-based for most people. The only huge difference at this point is how you move files around between your devices. If Google doesn't get their act together, I might go back to iOS.
Vengance_01
Supreme [H]ardness
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2001
- Messages
- 7,216
I would sell the phones and put them towards new 3a or 4a when they drop
cybereality
[H]F Junkie
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2008
- Messages
- 8,789
I still use a Pixel 2 XL and honestly I'm more than happy with it.
I've tried many of the newer phones in the store, and some of them are nice, but not that much nicer that it would be worth switching.
Maybe just getting the replacement would be the best choice for now until the new Google phones come out.
I've tried many of the newer phones in the store, and some of them are nice, but not that much nicer that it would be worth switching.
Maybe just getting the replacement would be the best choice for now until the new Google phones come out.
Domingo
Fully [H]
- Joined
- Jul 30, 2004
- Messages
- 22,638
In terms of pure features, there aren't many phones that offer significant upgrades vs. the Pixel 2 XL. At least assuming your battery isn't dying like mine was. You can only open Facebook or Chrome so fast and all of the Pixel phones take fantastic photos. Obviously there are specific cases where you might want a higher refresh rate or 5G, but for everyday use I doubt most people would notice much.
T4rd
Fully [H]
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2009
- Messages
- 20,111
Same here. The only thing I wish my 2 XL did better was have a brighter display, as it's pretty hard to see outdoors at all. But even the Pixel 4s are still pretty weak relative to other flagships in that area and that's one of the many areas Google skimped on hardware for the Pixel 3 and 4. Otherwise the phone is still great and gets me through the day just fine even with only charging it to 80% or so as I've always done to save on battery wear - Accubattery says it's still at 89% capacity after over 2 years and oddly enough it was only at 93% when it was brand new.
I would pick up a 3a or upcoming 4a before I'd replace my 2 XL with another 2 XL though, if just for longer software support, pretty comparable performance, and even better battery life.
Mad Maxx
Supreme [H]ardness
- Joined
- Apr 12, 2016
- Messages
- 7,322
I tried the OP 8 Pro. Liked it, but not enough to keep it at that $1000 price. Been using my 3XL since late 2018 and my only complaint is its battery life. I have chargers and power banks in my home office, bedroom, car, even on the boat, so that problem is under control. The Note 20 and Sony Xperia 1 ii look pretty impressive, but their price tags are frightening. I'll probably stick with my 3XL unless the 5XL kicks some serious ass.