Picking x570 board for workstation build + WCing + 3xNVMe

lopoetve

Fully [H]
Joined
Oct 11, 2001
Messages
30,175
Workstation build, some gaming. Almost 100% decided that I'm going with the 3950X rather than Threadripper, although I'm still having brief debates on that. VMs, video editing, normal office-work stuff, and some podcast recording.

Need:
6x rear USB (key/mouse/cam/headset/mic/USB backup drive)
3x NVMe (Boot/VMs/Video)
2-4x SATA (Video dump, working space for a couple of things, probably in RAID1 or 5).
2.5-5-10G networking (NAS1 has 1G, but NAS2 has 10G, and I have 10G switching, although I'm not doing a ton of throughput so 2.5/5 is good enough).
Good audio DAC - I have a good 2.1 system I use when I'm not using the headset.
Wireless + Wired networking, wired networking I'd prefer to have 2.5/5/10G, but it's not technically ~required~.

Will have 64G of RAM, highly clocked if possible (I'm trying to figure out if this is going to play nice or not with the IMC, or if this is going to be what pushes me to TR).
May go AIO, may go hardline WC (why not?), haven't decided. GPU is a 5700XT that I already have.

I DO like shields on the motherboards - various reasons, but I do. Especially rear IO shields that I don't have to fuck with.

Here's what I've narrowed down to

MSI x570 Prestige Creation - 4x NVMe is nice, although it's an add-in card for the second 2. 10G is also nice built-in, rather than an add-on card. Expensive though, and I don't know how much effort MSI puts into their creation line vs the others. Bad - EATX, which becomes a pain in the ass to fit.
MSI x570 Meg Ace - 3x NVMe, enough rear USB, 2.5G LAN.
Skipped - Unify and Tomahawk, both look a bit cheaper but less on the wired networking, and worse quality on the DAC.

Asus - None have 3x M2 built-in, which sucks. I would have to copy the Prestige creation and buy an add-in card (several M2 -> PCIE slot adapters exist), and trust that it works well. Doesn't add a ton of cost, but mildly annoying.
Crosshair VIII Formula - Loaded, WC for the VRMs, but expensive
Crosshair VIII Hero Wi-Fi - See Formula, minus the water cooling cost. Still need the add-in card though.
Strix Gaming E - See above, more affordable still.

Gigabyte - I don't buy Gigabyte for AMD boards. (And before anyone questions - I buy them for Intel all the time, but I've had excruciatingly bad luck with them and AMD for over 18 years).

ASRock- Barely enough USB on any of them, and no advanced networking except on the Aqua (unless I missed something), and often no shielding - given that I don't have a ton of experience with ASrock outside of the server market, I tend to set these aside for this project.

Generally I'm leaning towards one of the MSI boards, with Asus as a close second (and just pick up an M2 adapter and put scratch space on it, or add some SATA SSDs in RAID). Anyone have any thoughts?
 

Starfalcon

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 7, 2020
Messages
380
I have the X570 creation board in my rig I built in november, been a problem free and stable board. Main reasons I went with it was due to the amount of USB it gives you along with having enough PCIe expansion slots, something a lot of the high end boards only had 3 slots.
 

lopoetve

Fully [H]
Joined
Oct 11, 2001
Messages
30,175
https://www.asus.com/Motherboards/Pro-WS-X570-ACE/

Look at that one? Looks pretty much the same as the Hero/Strix for features.

Gigabit lan, no IO shield, no motherboard shield, only one M2 ports, too few rear USB. Too many things missing.

edit: nevermind on the USB, but still only one M2. Definitely need at least two of those, and want 3 PCIE SSDs. Having to add in two add-in cards just to get to 3 is... nah. U2 is dying as a drive format.
 

tunatime

Well...OK
Joined
Sep 15, 2011
Messages
4,069
I think if you want 64gb and 4 drives you are better off going tr as everything you said can be easily found on tr boards also you probably have a better chance of clocked 64gb on tr then am4
 
Top