New LG 32UD99 vs Me Old Dell U3011

Tanquen

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Feb 15, 2005
Messages
1,225
Just some random thoughts. Not sure I’m keeping it.

The included cables are way too short. Better than nothing but you best be using them with a laptop right next to the display. They should have done better on a $1k display. It seems they had to make the USB-C cable beefy and short as my other USB-C cable that I just upgraded to because my new Pixel 2 don’t like the poorer(?) quality older ones I had that worked fine with the Pixel 1 don’t work with the LG. The calibration has issues with the included USB and even the Windows app had issues.

The USB connection, while troublesome did finally work and the screen adjustment app is cool and I was able to update the displays firmware. Never done that with a display before.

It’s flat screen! Yeah! Not sure why everyone seems to be into pinching the middle of the screen and flaring the corners when we finally got rid of this type of distortion moving from CRTs?

It’s 16:9. Boo. The only option for 16:10 are other 30” displays like the newer U3017 but none I can find with a res higher than 2560x1600.

The Vesa Mount. It has one but it’s off center and mounts too high on my Ergotron arm. Boo! I know they want to put the hardware and stuff low on TVs and such too make the top look so thin but I’d rather have the vesa mount centered. Looking at getting a new TV and will have to redo the wall mount. :(

May try one of these on this display:

https://www.ergodirect.com/product_...x9_SZgwtY21GVa1c8oSqP8r4Gzk06RQUaAgHTEALw_wcB

https://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod...cCdSXCAMdHOdAebexS8aAlaNEALw_wcB&gclsrc=aw.ds

Size. Not a full 32” but that is how they do it. The small bezel is nice. No logo is nice too but, the display adjustments are on the bottom and this limits your multi mount options.

Built in speakers. Not the best sound but handy if you move the monitor around or in years to come when you just want simple sound without setting up extra speakers.

Anti-glare coating. Maybe it gets them a brighter screen but the LG shows way more than the Dell. Not mirror like but I see lots of light sources like me and my desk in the LG.

The display was shipped in a metallic bag with a lining but no extra screen protection. There are some permanent spots seen when cleaning and it’s much harder to clean. Like the coating is more porous. It took me some time to clean my finger prints off. Never wanted a pair of kit gloves before.

Calibration. The whites are more so then the Dell but a bit blue for me. The built in calibration sounded good but it’s next to imposable to get running and when you do, it adds banding.

Power. See this more and more but it has an external AC adapter. So my existing power cables won’t work. I did find an IEC Socket C14 to Cloverleaf Plug C5 Adapter but still had to mount the power brick.

It has some response time adjustments but I can’t see the difference between any of them and the motion blur is noticeably worse than the seven year old Dell.

Freesync. Glad it has it but can’t seem to get it to work.

HDR. Again, glad it’s there but none of the games I have support it and I can’t see anyway to play an HDR video to try it out. :(

The extra res is good and bad. The Dell U3011 30” at 2560x1600 is a good spot to be as I can run at 100% PDI and still read everything. With the new 4k display I’d need it to be 40” or something. With this 32”-ish display I have to up the DPI and still in 2018 Windows 10 has some issues scaling windows. Some apps or windows ignore the DPI setting or look like scaled bitmaps.


4aQd2rzrYidz4TKIFeypwSlnfrX_TsPc6pJfOPm40CVYcowamdtc9ipkaj8IowZeoP8_QRiL9-IUAXx7bCcYvXYJUcwiZQeJFPNRjnBuJw223PGzf_okarLeBTvzHcHo9p6rt71pQIVKCHMV7g73Rtt2RkxUrnL3xm8hm3RCKi-ajoN059FR5ZoeKU2MV5C4pi28yM1SqVUs0skCa8E3vGnlJ6a8dw9XkD0hbY5XUMGXKDNFeSLLenGzmcPKJHS0v_bzHVXM21IVlGNeFjjQKtT7ciSDFPsi5QcrgWp_HZH-h5g7yTvD4vzUcXPxIiRGT7uURxmZ4HXqkV_ZmilvUOKS9M4lAlFiHZAPQc81IQtReGaEkfPEWTDnhxj3SwDwTotfRDGN-EsTxt8QVE5eHePUdNZeNIyEIYNW3xeqeggd0PGxDag3R4xFGMTQFPls_cfC77yHxKxs-sq_dRJ-H8T3he8Ahn-lVK6_BHDTIGxVYo-ZbwHjjFbBODHaBeVb5N720PiYraknasvqt0I1W5ohjawSfq9Qw8vKdCMYVGg7NXvXfwiJ2n48CKIflTafFBs8jVMdYAmHppIAL-l5eO3QUAC7AT7YUBEriwY=w1602-h1202-no
 
Last edited:
How was the IPS glow? Any dead pixels, exaggerated back light bleed?
 
The IPS Glow is a bit worse than the 6-7 year old Dell but this may have something to do with the coating and the much greater focus on brightness and HDR. It takes some getting used to. The whites are also a bit blue.


And twice today there was a slight popping sound and an onscreen glitch to go with it. Got it from B&H for $880 or so and it's a good price at the moment. So, I can return and wait for them to get them in stock again or just return it. Thinking I should just return it.

Can't even try out Netflix 4k HDR as AMD has no Display Ready 3 or whatever. :(

Overall, I'm disappointed. The one game I could try with HDR (Hitman) seems like nothing changes with it on but you can’t just toggle it back and forth.

Freesync also doesn’t seem to work and it has more motion blur eventhough its listed as being faster than my old displays.

nywcNc00jOXfm8K2iuBwEEcCGszhzbXklLLD5p0xb916WpvuwjCeOTKvvFu9ilp3jCVHpA-7Q_66L59rYLsYiw8_14W_r6lUSEflqjOJvcxWnXJr8FnFRyce6E48rZRdg7Rqq4FrWqxkwP3E1LWLLygU7zqID7aE11WXaLQz1U-nZqCZhOKK69r0BNGk0am2O-_zEXEIl4Q47Tl_Envrbb7mfamTS21TYnhHJ7nHu4buK-2nxnDSgrg5bmPE0blGUQFGtQSy8mfKYDutWa-FelHsDKJ_kVo2KvEH93HxgGs3zjkgbnNI6zId2D4NWEx6aJm75xiMnjZY1UQM2vrDBpWx1PZx3RkUdX_kQ0k46fBWiXesLFPWsp7vBNRTfOIdrRGl7te-roGZcRl89NeDO-aXDD2RVZXYVv1YEEcV-EGaxvwQnAci_QLiJi4-Phf-B06TeIdboWxqAHz4IS0Ifg_1QCR2pvLCPcdbS2JzpNjV03rCZjzj49dwPOD4Rc99BSHHJYZgCRxwIrgDZwWbnHpVj3TMrV_GXlAaTR__RSLgghgrjTYiqzMQywGhZ8mc02Kqq4DkQgY0fwmbpCg0drEkbiQn_v3Tgc8Ezz4=w1299-h974-no
 
Last edited:
Good to see the Dell still holding its own many years later. Just picked up a u3014 (because they prices have finally come down to affordable) and couldn't be happier.
 
At the same time it's kind of disappointing that there hasn't been a bigger jump in image quality.

I went ahead and returned the LG as I was worried about the quality vs the price paid and the video dropouts.

Funny you mention the 3014 as I ended up getting one for work last year the price was pretty good. But it's the first LCD display I've ever had where there's burn in or image retention after just a few minutes. It even has a mode built into the menu settings to help clean it up. I'm just wondering why after so many years does an LCD have that issue I didn't think LCDs had that issue.
 
regarding the vesa mount issue. Get yourself an aluminum plate and mark out the offset from the center of the VESA to make an adapter. I have done this a few times with monitors that don't even have normal VESA mounts. Works really well and is practically unnoticeable.
 
Thank you for this. Ive been looking to replace my old Dell 3007 and 3011. But from this, I might just keep them a little while longer.
 
regarding the vesa mount issue. Get yourself an aluminum plate and mark out the offset from the center of the VESA to make an adapter. I have done this a few times with monitors that don't even have normal VESA mounts. Works really well and is practically unnoticeable.

I thought about doing something like that but I don't have the equipment to make sure the holes or Square and level and all that plus then there's the issue of of a plate that's going to be rigid enough so the monitor doesn't want to like bend forward or something. I wish they just center the dumb things.:(
 
Thank you for this. Ive been looking to replace my old Dell 3007 and 3011. But from this, I might just keep them a little while longer.
I have a 3007 along with the 3014 and I actually like the 3011 a bit better for its matte smoothness and the 3014 for its slightly popping picture due to the backlight. Both are super monitors that I can stare at for many hours without an issue. (y)
 
I also have a U3011 and recently I bought a 32UD99.

Image quality
- Colors are nice, but they are only accurate on a couple of limited modes.
- Lots of IPS glow, specially in the top corners. It's way worse than the U3011. I'd even say terrible for such a modern and high end display. Doesn't matter how good the contrast ratio is, because the IPS glow ruins it.
- Frameless/infinity display design causes the side borders to have an internal shadow over the image, visible if you are at less than 30in from the screen. For me this is very distracting, but nowadays a lot of manufacturers make monitors with this defect.

Design/build quality
- The monitor is well built and beautiful but the stand is... well, typical LG. The vertical rotation mechanism is nice, but in the supposed horizontal position the panel is crooked.
- The backside in white glossy plastic looks cheap.

In the end I returned the LG too. It's not worth it, the quality doesn't match the price tag.
 
The IPS glow (pic relinked above) was way worse than the U3011 and much more random but I don't think it's that big a deal but I don't use my displays in the dark. Day to day stuff I did not see it and the brighter colors were nice but it was all the issues together that made me send it back. Now LG has a newer 32UK950-W coming that is more like what 32UD99 should be so why even have the 32UD99… Oh, it’s another $450 more. Man, the display manufactures are really milking us, there is no reason every display above $500 should not have all the inputs, Freesync and refresh rates you want. :(
 
Back
Top