So yeah... My long winded rant of what led an Apple hater to an iPhone. Who knows maybe the honeymoon phase will end and i will hate it and trade it but so far it just works when i need it to unlike so many android phones i have had.
It's always interesting reading vastly different experiences. I really love my Galaxy S and am surprised you weren't satisfied with it. I really can't imagine much it needs to improve on [for its age]. To be honest, I'll be sad to see the little guy go when it's time to upgrade.
But the iPhone is a great phone so if even that doesn't measure up, you're just a smartphone hater.