heatlesssun
Extremely [H]
- Joined
- Nov 5, 2005
- Messages
- 44,154
From a UI standpoint, my biggest gripe is the charms bar. It is annoying and shows Windows 8's lack of "polish" at this point. Far too many things are spread between the Charms bar Setting screen and the standard Control Panel UI. Some are only available from one, some from the other. If everything was still available in the old Control Panel UI, then I could just disable the Charms bar totally -- which would be my preference! On a multi-monitor setup, the Charms bar is a royal pain -- hitting the edge of the screen with a mouse isn't as simple as it should be. So, when I want the Charms bar to come up, it usually doesn't, but it seems like almost every time I go to close a maximized program with the "X", the Charms bar inevitably comes up instead.
There is a method to how this works I think. All of the options that have been available in the past along with new ones for things that would tend to be desktop oriented like File History are in the desktop Control Panel. New things that one would need quick access to on tablets are in the Settings Metro app like the lock screen, onscreen keyboard and Metro app settings.
Lastly, the Metro/Modern and multitasking sucks bad. The split screen interface just isn't efficient and looks crappy. Just make the Metro/Modern apps run in a standard Window and allow multiple ones at a time. I've actually got this more or less working with a customized video driver so that the Metro apps actually thing they are running full screen on a separate monitor, but it's still more wasteful of resources than I like and a bit buggy (which I haven't had time to work on fixing recently as I've been swamped with work at the moment [ARM Linux kernel drivers]).
The thing is though that when you add windowing you add a lot of other complexity on the UI and app side. Metro apps are meant to scale well across and defined set of resolutions and DPIs as perfect scaling across all resolutions and DPIs is a VERY difficult thing to do for all applications. Furthermore when you add resizable windows to a touch UI you end up with a desktop oriented UI that people have never been that found of on Windows tablets in the past. You could improve it but I think that you have to be very careful about doing something like that.
That said, I'm finding that Metro snap to be very neat on a tablet for apps that support the view well.