Galaxy SIII or Motor Razr Maxx

Razr Maxx vs. GSIII

  • Razr Maxx

    Votes: 7 8.6%
  • Samsung GSIII

    Votes: 74 91.4%

  • Total voters
    81
There is a grey area that concerns me though, which is the period between when you request the pre-ordered device and when it actually comes in and ships. According to the droid-life article you are referring to "they" spoke to an unnamed Verizon "PR rep" who said if you pre-order you get to keep your unlimited data. But they weren't specifically talking in reference to the scenario I am referring to.

To put that statement in context, the question was raised as it was referring to the mouse type on the preorder page at VZW that says you can get it for $199 "on a two year contract renewal and that that price requires a data pak with 2Gb of data"

According to the VZW customer service rep I spoke to yesterday, he said when you call to pre-order there is no contractual obligation on either end. You simply get your name in the queue for one. When it actually comes in and ships is when you get billed, or you choose to not accept the terms as they are on the day they attempt to bill it. VZW's entire system works around transaction dates. You can walk in a store and they can tell you anything but what is on the receipt you sign is what you agree to. What they said be damned. Same goes for phone/internet transactions.

So the grey area is between 6-6-12 and the assumed ship date of 6-21-12. According to the rep I spoke to, although highly unlikely, if you pre-order and say on 6-18-12 they launch shared data and do impose the "no grandfathered data on subsidized devices" policy, then that will be the contract terms you will have to accept on 6-21-12 if you still want the device for $199 on a two year renewal.

I find his explanation much more accurate from personal experience. The unnamed PR rep in the droid-life article was probably speaking out of pocket (they are PR after all) and they were also referring to a somewhat different scenario.

I (like a lot of people, probably) would REALLY like to confirm the last part of your post. If you get the terms of when you pre-order, I'm going to pre-order the GSIII now. If you go by the terms of when the phone is shipped, I'm worried that if I pre-order now, then Verizon will implement the killing of grandfathered unlimited data, then I'll be screwed.


I talked with a Verizon Rep today and he said they got new spec sheets in for the S3 that they did not have till late yesterday. The 32GB model is all onboard so he helped me to cancel my 16GB preorder and set up my 32GB order. He also informed me that the onboard slot will have cards up to 64GB like the S2. This is the Verizon medels and may not be true for all Carriers. Some sites were saying micro slot would only handle 32GB. I still have my same unlimited data plan and its stated on the order confirmation.

So they put on the plan that you are guaranteed to keep your unlimited, even if Verizon implements that policy in the interim?

Also, when you pre-order, do you have to pay for the device in full at the time of order? Pay when you get the device? Or can you add it to your bill?
 
I (like a lot of people, probably) would REALLY like to confirm the last part of your post. If you get the terms of when you pre-order, I'm going to pre-order the GSIII now. If you go by the terms of when the phone is shipped, I'm worried that if I pre-order now, then Verizon will implement the killing of grandfathered unlimited data, then I'll be screwed.




So they put on the plan that you are guaranteed to keep your unlimited, even if Verizon implements that policy in the interim?

Also, when you pre-order, do you have to pay for the device in full at the time of order? Pay when you get the device? Or can you add it to your bill?

I have not seen a charge from my preorder on my credit card as of yet. I'm assuming it should charge when it's shipped.

Verizon Wireless - Your Order Confirmation said:
Samsung Galaxy S III 32GB in Blue 1 $249.99
UPGRADE FEE $30.00
Your Plan
Nationwide Talk & Text- 1400
Monthly Line Access $0.00
Plan Features
TXT MSG W PER MSG CHARGES
CONSUMER PDA
RTR FOR UNLIMITED PLANS $0
TEXT MESSAGING
FRIENDS & FAMILY ALP - 10
DYNAMIC-PRIVATE IP
CALLER ID
LINE ACCESS W/TEXT $9.99 0711
4G DATA TRANSPORT
4G APPLICATION ACCESS
4G INTERNET ACCESS
DATA ROAM USA/CANADA
VERIZON APPS $0
DECLINE EQUIPMENT PROTECTION
EMAIL & WEB UNLIMITED $29.99
SDM REMOTE QUERY ENABLED
BUSY TRANSFER
3-WAY CALLING
CALL DELIVERY
CALL WAITING
NO ANSWER TRANSFER
CALL FORWARDING
BASIC VOICE MAIL - $0
STREAMLINED BILLING - $0
PICTURE MESSAGE PROVISIONING
OTA SOFTWAREUPDATE-$0.00
Additional Items
DFILLSIM3FF-A $0.00
Shipping Fee $0.00

My pre-order shows unlimited email/web. Alas, I'm not primary on my account, even if I'm the one who pays it; so I don't get the $50 NE2 discount. We share an account with my parents as my mother works for a company that qualifies for a 22% discount on the main line.
 
I have not seen a charge from my preorder on my credit card as of yet. I'm assuming it should charge when it's shipped.



My pre-order shows unlimited email/web. Alas, I'm not primary on my account, even if I'm the one who pays it; so I don't get the $50 NE2 discount. We share an account with my parents as my mother works for a company that qualifies for a 22% discount on the main line.

This device doesn't get employee discounts, only NE2.
 
So they put on the plan that you are guaranteed to keep your unlimited, even if Verizon implements that policy in the interim?

Also, when you pre-order, do you have to pay for the device in full at the time of order? Pay when you get the device? Or can you add it to your bill?

My order states
TXT MSG W PER MSG CHARGES
UNL TEXT MESSAGING
CONSUMER PDA
RTR FOR UNLIMITED PLANS $0
TEXT MESSAGING
DYNAMIC-PRIVATE IP
CALLER ID
4G DATA TRANSPORT
4G APPLICATION ACCESS
4G INTERNET ACCESS
DATA ROAM USA/CANADA
VERIZON APPS $0
DECLINE EQUIPMENT PROTECTION
M2M NATIONAL UNLIMITED - $0
EMAIL & WEB UNLIMITED $29.99

along with other items. I also have confirmation from them that the order will be charged when it ships. I also have a $30 NE2 credit that was eaten by the new $30 upgrade fee.
 
FWIW, I just called Verizon to ask about the upgrade. The CSR that I talked to said that if I preordered the GS3, I would retain my grandfathered unlimited data, as it uses the terms that are applicable when I make the preorder. Take that for what it is worth, as I know that conflicts with some posts here, but would seem to support others.

What is your guys' opinion? 16GB or 32GB? I already have a 16GB mSDHC card. I don't have any music on it, but it is something I intend to do...but all of my music is no more than 5GB at this time. Is there any reason to get the 32GB, other than for possible resale value in the future?

I have a $50 NE2 credit due to me, so after the phone and upgrade fee, I get $20 knocked off the price of either phone.
 
I went for the 32gb as I like to load up on apps, and people have complained about not being able to store apps on their SD cards.
 
I went with blue for my preorder. It is closer to black, and doesn't look like Apple iAnything.

Anybody know why Verizon would say that my current SIM card is incompatible with the Galaxy S3? I currently have a Thunderbolt. I thought a LTE SIM care was good no matter which phone you go to?
 
I went with blue for my preorder. It is closer to black, and doesn't look like Apple iAnything.

Anybody know why Verizon would say that my current SIM card is incompatible with the Galaxy S3? I currently have a Thunderbolt. I thought a LTE SIM care was good no matter which phone you go to?

Because the SIM card in the Thunderbolt is a regular SIM card while the S3 takes a Micro-SIM card. That's easily fixed with this or a steady hand though.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Both are great phones and Both are major difference. I think Samsung Galaxy S3 is the better than the Motorola razr Maxx. Its include the important features like 8 mega pixel camera, 1.9 secondary camera, 32GB internal storage memory, 4.8 large screen, 1.4 Ghz processors, Multiple processors cores, built in FM radio, Fast data speed ect.
 
Back
Top