Never built a rig; from 939 Single Core to C2Q or i7 920

Infantwar

n00b
Joined
Jan 2, 2009
Messages
45
Happy New Year everyone! First, something I need to get out right off: I have been reading the [H]ardforums for about a year-and-a-half now, drooling over the 'show us your setup/display' threads and learning as much as I can from everyone's experiences here. I'd like to thank Tirades, Danny Bui, Enginurd and Silent-circuit to name a few (but not excluding the rest of you!) for actually helping me with my old build until it's final days without even really knowing it and showing me what's what when it comes to a decent rig. Thanks everyone [H]ard for setting the bar!

With that holiday sap out of the way I'll cut to the chase. I've had my computer since the FX-53 first came out and was the new hotness and PCIe was the slightly more expensive, yet unaccepted alternative to AGP. It has given me many moons of good times but finally gave up the ghost for everything but safemode (where I'm posting from now). I'm at my wits end and have decided it's time to retire the old girl. Finally registered and here I am.

For a while I thought about using a boutique such as Ava or Puget but the more I read these forums, the more I got the courage to just do this on my own. I know there are many posts semi-similar to this but I don't want to hijack someone else's thread and steal thunder from their rigs-to-be. My apologies for any redundancy but I wanted to get your thoughts on what you would do in my situation and if this looks okay:

1) What will you be doing with this PC? Gaming? Photoshop? Web browsing? etc
Primarily gaming. IL-2, BF2 and Supreme Commander are oldies I'd like to play full bore, and I would love to play L4D, Fallout 3, GTAIV (I know, terrible port), and WiC in all their full-detail glory, amongst so many others I missed thanks to this old machine. Also this will be my main movie watching device when I want to view a good manly flick sans girlfriend.

2) What's your budget? Are tax and shipping included?
Anywhere from $1600 up to $2000 Shipping/Tax included. I'm flexible, just don't want to break that 2 large cap if I can help it.

3) Where do you live?
Eau Claire, WI (keeping parts cool will not be a problem!)

4) What exact parts do you need for that budget? CPU, RAM, case, etc. Please be very specific.
Everything but input devices, speakers, case and monitor. Will pick up 22"-24" for birthday in February unless I can eek enough money out of this build to justify it early.

5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing?
The only parts I'm keeping are the monitor, keyboard/mouse, speakers, possibly the 74GB Raptor for a game drive if it's not silly to have, and the case, though the V2100 is WAY more than I need anymore, and the pseudo BTX upside down situation (hitting the divider) may cause issues with a decent HSF?. Too bad I know no one who will buy the beast. Gonna look into a CM690 or P182 (small but great ventilation) down the line though I'll miss the Lian-Li quality.

6) Will you be overclocking?
Never oc'ed before, but read the i7's have a pretty easy learning curve as long as you don't have high-in-the-sky hopes for 4Ghz+ where you have to tweak more. I just don't want to hurt my new baby!

7) What size monitor do you have or plan to have?
Currently have 19" that does 1280x1024 comfortably but pains my eyes at 1600x1200 due to 60hz refresh. Shooting for a 22" but would go 24" in the next two months. If a good deal on something quality for ~$300-400 comes along maybe earlier. (BenQ G2400WD has been teasing me for ages).

8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC?
Would start buying core things (CPU/MOBO combo listed below?) as early as today. Rest when next paycheck hits this Friday. This has been a long time coming!

9) What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Crossfire or SLI support? etc.
I come from a land just before SLI and CF, so very unsure of rocking two cards. Was thinking GTX 260 55nm now and use EVGA step-up to something more beastly (or tread waters I haven't since my Voodoo 2 and get another 260?) if the new monitor demands it? No RAID, no special connection needs.


I went whole horse and early adopted on Socket 939 back in the day and got bit in the ass by the AGP situation, early BIOS issues etc., but in the end it lasted me a LONG time. Would love to save money on a 775 rig very similar to this but don't want to hinge everything on overclocking a q6600 only to find I can't do it! And if I get a higher clocked stock quad, from what I've read the price difference is so close to i7 there's not much point. C2D seems like an iffy proposition at this point since games are finally starting to have quad 'optimizations' which leaves:

CPU/MOBO - Core i7 920 / EVGA SLI X58 combo @ NCIXUS for $570 shipped
(read EVGA support is excellent and I have none of the games bundled, good deal?)
HSF - Thermalright Ultra-120 Extreme 1366 RT @ Heatsink Factory for $84 shipped
(is there anything cheaper but near as good for keeping things cool if I oc?)
RAM- G.Skill 3 x 2GB DDR3 1600 @ Newegg for $185
(would jump up to Corsair if truly that much better, or down to 1333 G.Skill if 1600 isn't worth it since I don't want to go nuts on the overclocking)
GPU - EVGA GTX 260 Core 216 55nm @ Newegg for $265
(Seems to give some of the best performance for the money returns compared to say 280. Would go 4870 1GB but I like the thought of the step-up plan if the 260 doesn't cut it within' 90 days.)
HD - Western Digital Caviar Black 64001AALS 640GB @ Newegg for $80
(More capacity for all the games I hope to play! Giving the 250GB to the girlfriend, using the 74GB Raptor for boot and a few heavier duty games)
DVD-RW - Samsung TS-H653N @ Newegg for $23
(2x slower than the SH-223Q and $8 cheaper, every little bit helps I suppose!)
PSU - Corsair 750-TX @ Newegg for $120
(More than enough for a single card now and possibly SLI/CF or a heavier duty single card and/or overclocking the cpu later {thanks guys!})
OS - Vista 64bit OEM @ Newegg for $100
(First time with the new OS, how limited are the installs if I mess something up and have to start fresh?)

Ends up around $1440 for everything shipped if I do my hurried math correctly. And that is minus a case and minus a new monitor. Does this sound reasonable or should I lay off the Core i7 kool-aid, tighten the belt, and get a cheaper C2Q set up? Like I said this is my first TRUE build, the last one was done years and years ago by a friend while I assisted with minor things after the CPU and motherboard install so it's a semi-terrifying prospect to have all the responsibility on my hands now! But I'm very excited to get things moving with your help! Sorry for the excess of minor questions and if this seems convoluted at all!
 
You can reformat and reinstall Vista as many times as you want. ;) :)

I'm also running a 6400AAKS/74GB Raptor. I have my OS and a few games on my Raptor and everything else on the 640GB. I'm not sure how much the difference in speed is, though.
 
You can reformat and reinstall Vista as many times as you want. ;) :)

I'm also running a 6400AAKS/74GB Raptor. I have my OS and a few games on my Raptor and everything else on the 640GB. I'm not sure how much the difference in speed is, though.

You can't move it to another computer, though. If you want to have that option, you need to buy retail. I bought retail, and it's saved me about $160 over how much I'd have paid for 4 different OEM copies.
 
I'm not too concerned about moving the OS to another computer. Ideally it'll sit with this new one for a good long time. I just didn't want to have to reformat for some reason and be stuck. The 74 as a slightly faster boot and the 640 for data sounds like a great idea.

Any thoughts on the rest of the build? Does anyone know if the TRUE would cause clearance issues in my case where the divider is between the main mobo compartment and the PSU/HDD compartment?

So far I'm taking the lack of "don't go i7, go C2Q instead, dummy" comments as a good sign as that's my primary concern here. If I stick on the i7 route then I guess my only final concern short of the HSF clearance (I think I may have enough money left over to snag a different case even if I can't sell this one off so maybe that isn't even too big a problem) is the power supply being enough for now with a little room to grow on the video/oc front. Thanks everyone for the helpful input! :)
 
I was debating something a little higher wattage, but was hoping to maintain the modular cables. Sadly for Corsair anyway, you have to jump to the 1000w which would not only be overkill, but wouldn't fit in the case I have right now.

Maybe I'll just bite the bullet and get the 750w and make do without a little more cable clutter...
 
Did a bit more looking into the PSU side of things and this Antec Signature 850w seems to be an excellently reviewed power supply and is still modular without drawing more power than I need. (though it's significantly more expensive, however I know the importance of this component and ideally it could last me quite a while) Maybe I should ask about this part off in the power supply subforum.
 
+1 for the Corsair 750W.

Get the ASUS P6T Deluxe motherboard...excellent for overclocking and very stable. Great all-around motherboard.

If spending that much money, either get the 4870 x2 (my choice) or the GTX 280.

Also get the WD 640GB AALS...no big difference in performance but I saw it do slightly better in several benchmarks and there's only a $10 (or so) price difference for an additional 16mb cache.

If you don't feel that you'll be utilizing all the power of the i7 (i.e. serious multi-tasking, video encoding,etc), I'd recommend saving money and going with a C2Q build around a Q9550. The i7 isn't as easy to overclock as you think.
 
Changing out the AAKS hard drive for the AALS. Read up a bit and the extra cache definitely doesn't hurt. Also after some hedging it looks like the Corsair 750W is the best bang-for-the-buck solution power-wise. I've never had a modular PSU so I'm sure I won't miss what I've never had, especially if it saves me a few bucks and buys me some future upgrade potential at the same time! Thanks PC_User and jterp7!

I guess the reason I was initially swinging towards the EVGA board was because of the NCIXUS bundle that would add up to approximately the same price as a P6T and a i7 920 (if using the deal from Amazon for ~$270 shipped from this thread) but getting me a few games free to boot (really excited about playing WiC either way, the other two I may give to my brother). From what I understand, the EVGA board is still quite good and they have great support via their forums. If the ASUS were better in some tangible way (price, better stability than the EVGA for what is still a relatively new crop of motherboards, etc.) then I'd have no problem swinging that way and ditching the bundle.

I don't plan on doing any serious multitasking since I've been so ingrained with doing only one or two things at a time from years of single-core use. I understand that coming from a C2D or C2Q there isn't going to be a tangible difference in moving to a i7 but I'm concerned about having gone this long between upgrades (mostly due to the AGP situation making any upgrade require a new cpu/mobo/video and psu) that if I go 775 now, I'll be setting myself up for a similar disaster again? Or is that more or less just new rig jitters and I should save myself the extra cash and put it towards a better GPU?
 
If I ended up forsaking the true new hotness of i7 and instead went for a Q9550-based build, keeping non i7-related components, I was looking at something like this:

CPU - Intel Q9550 Retail ($320 @ Newegg)
HSF - Xigmatek HDT-S1283 and retention bracket(~$46 @ Newegg with bracket)
Mobo - ASUS P5Q Pro ($130 @ Newegg) or Gigabyte GA-EP45-UD3R ($120 @ Newegg)
RAM - G.Skill 4GB (2 x 2GB) DDR2 1000 ($50 @ Newegg)

Which would put me at about $1154 with everything shipped from the 'egg. Well below budget, leaving room for a new case in there AND a nice 24" LCD monitor (not NEC nice per se, but nice compared to my CRT) as well. Maybe even an upgrade from the GTX 260 to a 280 sooner rather than later for said new screen? I know the 4870X2 is king of the hill, and I do miss the days of turning all settings to full, but over half a grand is a lot to swallow for one component these days - at least for me anyway - even though I know that probably doesn't sound too [H]ard to you guys. :(

The i7 isn't as easy to overclock as you think.

Well no processor is easy to overclock to me since I haven't ever oc'ed one, but I guess from Kyle's i7 videos it didn't look to be as complicated to learn as doing the same mild oc's with a C2Q. The will is there, just not the experience. That's why I got the FX-53 back in the day. I thought getting the best there was stock would be better than getting something a fraction of the price and bricking it by accident. Of course this was several years ago, I was dumb kid with graduation money to blow. Times have changed, I have a set budget and a fountain of knowledgeable people to tap into for help.

So the seed of doubt is planted with regard to the i7 scenario. At least it's a potentially cheaper, but still powerful seed of doubt. Crap.
 
Back
Top