Yeah. I gotta feeling it is the first batch of those cards or something. I got two from newegg and both were bad. The one from eVGA works fine and plays like a champ.
I didn't read entire thread, but since your current PSU has the quad rail junk, make sure you have the card on a separate rail with nothing else. If this was already suggested, forgive me.
Edit: nm i see you are up and running fine now with third card from evga. Gl man.