Mousemagician
Limp Gawd
- Joined
- Feb 13, 2010
- Messages
- 326
Hi guys,
Like many of you, I’m a victim of the “SFF fever”.
I built MINI ITX systems in the past, and I got plenty of satisfaction! As an example, I had a lot of fun building a Zotac GF9300 WiFi with Intel E3200 oced at 3.6 GHz inside an Antec Mini-Skeleton:
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?p=1035348050#post1035348050
After the SandyBridge came out, with SATA 6GBs, USB3.0, Intel 2600K support, and new integrated video, I couldn’t resist to the temptation to build a kickass gaming Mini-ITX!!!
The result is that, in a wave of excitation, I sold ALL the components of my beloved gigantic gaming machine on eBay (see specs in my signature), to invest the earned money in the SB ITX.
The aim is having at the end of the day a tiny, silent, and powerful gaming machine…
First step (and the really most difficult one): to find the right MoBo.
You all know what I’m talking about: an ITX MoBo bearing the Intel P67 chipset.
In fact, because of the crazy marketing decision of Intel to commercialize the H67 (with integrated video but no ocing abilities) and the P67 (with ocing abilities but no integrated video), Mini-ITX manufacturers were forced to produce the most sellable one: the H67. The reason seems to be that the major use of ITX systems is as HTPC. That’s perfectly understandable!
Thus, I NEED someone producing a P67 ITX!!!
Another possibility could be to wait for the Z68 chipset to come out, and then hoping that some manufacturer makes an ITX with that! I other words: it’s a matter of time!
Time is something people crazy for computer building like me cannot stand at all!!!
Finally, I decided to ask directly to the major MoBo manufacturers out there. Here you are the kind of email that I sent:
· Zotac
· Asus
· Gigabyte
· ECS-USA
· MSI
· Asrock
The most interesting answers came from ECS and Asrock:
Reply rom ECS-USA:
[FONT="]MSI reply:[/FONT]
Do you know what I got from Zotac and Asus? NOTHING!!! This is very unpleasant, since these are the most important ITX manufacturer, along with Gigabyte that was wrong and telegraphic.
I can understand that they want keep their marketing secret, but an answer to a customer is just matter of good manner.
Shame on you Zotac and Asus, most of all since I was tempted to purchase the Zotac H67ITX-C-E before any P67 would have been available.
As a result of this correspondence, I probably will purchase the ECS H67H2-I. Thus I can patiently wait until a Z68 comes out.
I like the ECS H67 ITX because:
1. There is an empty mini-PCIe slot, for a wifi, a TV tuner, or a mini-PCE SSD (when it will be available). Many others don’t have any mini-PCIe slot (Gigabyte and Asrock H67M-ITX), or bear a half height one (such as the Asus P8H67-I DeLuxe and Asrock H67M-ITX/HT), or have a full length mini PCIe slot occupied by a cheap WiFi card (such as the Zotac H67ITX-C-E).
2. All solid capacitors. Important for such a small form factor.
3. 240 pin ram (instead of the 204 pin SDRAM of the Asus).
4. It will be cheaper that similarly equipped ITX from the other manufacturers (see the case of the H55H-I).
5. The communication with the ECS representative has been compelling and rich of information.
The only limitation with the ECS ITX will be the absence of a USB3.0 header. The Zotac and Asus ones have them. Anyways, today there aren’t any cases supporting front UBS3.0 that can be connected to the header, but only to the USB3.0 in the rear I/O by USB adapter (see the LianLi cases, as an example).
I think this is the first list of ITX manufacturer official responses to our questions...
What do you SFF fanatics think about that?
Like many of you, I’m a victim of the “SFF fever”.
I built MINI ITX systems in the past, and I got plenty of satisfaction! As an example, I had a lot of fun building a Zotac GF9300 WiFi with Intel E3200 oced at 3.6 GHz inside an Antec Mini-Skeleton:
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?p=1035348050#post1035348050
After the SandyBridge came out, with SATA 6GBs, USB3.0, Intel 2600K support, and new integrated video, I couldn’t resist to the temptation to build a kickass gaming Mini-ITX!!!
The result is that, in a wave of excitation, I sold ALL the components of my beloved gigantic gaming machine on eBay (see specs in my signature), to invest the earned money in the SB ITX.
The aim is having at the end of the day a tiny, silent, and powerful gaming machine…
First step (and the really most difficult one): to find the right MoBo.
You all know what I’m talking about: an ITX MoBo bearing the Intel P67 chipset.
In fact, because of the crazy marketing decision of Intel to commercialize the H67 (with integrated video but no ocing abilities) and the P67 (with ocing abilities but no integrated video), Mini-ITX manufacturers were forced to produce the most sellable one: the H67. The reason seems to be that the major use of ITX systems is as HTPC. That’s perfectly understandable!
Thus, I NEED someone producing a P67 ITX!!!
Another possibility could be to wait for the Z68 chipset to come out, and then hoping that some manufacturer makes an ITX with that! I other words: it’s a matter of time!
Time is something people crazy for computer building like me cannot stand at all!!!
Finally, I decided to ask directly to the major MoBo manufacturers out there. Here you are the kind of email that I sent:
Here you are the list of the manufacturers that I sent the message to:Dear ___ customer service,
I was wondering if you are working on a mini-ITX motherboard with the Intel P67 chipset.
I'm interested on the overclocking features of the P67, in the small form factor mini-ITX for a powerful gaming small system.
There are many customers of yours like myself that will jump on that platform as soon as it will be available!
If you are working on such a platform, could you please indicate me the estimated release date? If it's not, do you forecast any Z68 ITX in the future?
I'd prefer to wait for the P67/Z68 than invest now on the H67!
Waiting for your answer.
Thank you in advance.
· Zotac
· Asus
· Gigabyte
· ECS-USA
· MSI
· Asrock
The most interesting answers came from ECS and Asrock:
Reply rom ECS-USA:
My 1st reply to ECS:We have no current plans to start a Mini ITX P67, while that is a great idea. There is some, while small, design consideration as the mini ITX motherboard have very limited space for cooling and also for components.
The Mini ITX Form factor itself is more about conserving space, energy, so the limited space is a hard one when you need it both to add power for performance and cooling it down. However the technologies have enable us now to start putting in more power in smaller package and possibly to come out with MiniITX with good O.C. capability, and we have done it a few times now as you can see with our H55H-I.
I don’t want to go too deep now, but I guess the only thing stopping ECS from producing one really, is the video capability that P67 does not have which is what most of user are looking for in smaller package since it would be hard to insert a nicer graphic card, some case even restrict so much space for Mini ITX, it’s not possible to add graphic card. So at this time I would suggest to go with a H67 if you really want Mini ITX.
Thanks!
Then, from ECS-USA:Thank you very much for the time you spent answering my email.
If I would summarize, even about what you wisely didn't say:
1) No P67 MINI ITX, because of the absence of integrated video
2) If you want overclock on SandyBridge with ITX form factor, wait for the Z68, but it will take months (or also more than a year) to have them appear on the market.
Am I right? I would really appreciate your verdict.
Thus, I likely will go with H67 ITX, since stock SB such as 2600 would be better than any oced H55 ITX.
Anyways, will you produce a Z68 ITX ever? THAT would be interesting!
Footnote: your H55H-I is a great MoBo; you kicked some asses out there, as on the Thom's review on February 2010.
Thank you.
[FONT="]My last reply to ECS-USA:[/FONT]1. Not entirely, but YES! But once again possible scenario may be using a MXMII for Video, but unlikely at this time.
2. Z68 … MAYBE … Mini ITX, very plausible… depending on CPU pricing however, IMO. If all its CPU pricing is higher than 250… mini itx, will be less likely.
I say if you really really want a p67 mini itx.. wait about 2 months just to see if anyone offer it.. providing you can wait.. or contact other manufacture like you contacted me. IF they are willing to let you in on their plan.
I do see a market for it, its just a concept ECS don’t see a BIG market for yet, but it surely is there and offering of its kind may just be around the corner and maybe not.
[FONT="]Here there is the Asrock reply:[/FONT]Mmm...
I probably understood what you meant.
Thanks a lot; it has been a pleasure talking to you.
And thanks ECS!
Enjoy.
[FONT="]Gigabyte has been a little bit disappointing, since it’s the most probable producer of a P67 ITX platform:[/FONT]Hello,
we thank you for your suggestion and we will evaluate the Z68 solution.
But right now, we cannot say if and when it might be available and what kind of spec it might have…
Best regards,
ASRock Support
[FONT="]The same day I got this reply, the GA-H67N-USB3 went available on Newegg! I suppose they intended the GA-P67N-USB3…[/FONT]Dear customer,
We currently do not have an ETA on the release of the GA-H67N-USB3. Please check our website for updates. WWW.GIGABYTE.US
Thank you
[FONT="]MSI reply:[/FONT]
Thus, no P67 from MSI.Right now there are no plans for this product due to the chipset licensing and our manufacturing ability. We are actively looking for new ways to take advantage of the growing mini-ITX market, so we may try to find a solution that meets your needs – unfortunately, there is no ETA at this time.
If anything changes, you will definitely see a press release about it, though!
Thanks for your inquiry.
Do you know what I got from Zotac and Asus? NOTHING!!! This is very unpleasant, since these are the most important ITX manufacturer, along with Gigabyte that was wrong and telegraphic.
I can understand that they want keep their marketing secret, but an answer to a customer is just matter of good manner.
Shame on you Zotac and Asus, most of all since I was tempted to purchase the Zotac H67ITX-C-E before any P67 would have been available.
As a result of this correspondence, I probably will purchase the ECS H67H2-I. Thus I can patiently wait until a Z68 comes out.
I like the ECS H67 ITX because:
1. There is an empty mini-PCIe slot, for a wifi, a TV tuner, or a mini-PCE SSD (when it will be available). Many others don’t have any mini-PCIe slot (Gigabyte and Asrock H67M-ITX), or bear a half height one (such as the Asus P8H67-I DeLuxe and Asrock H67M-ITX/HT), or have a full length mini PCIe slot occupied by a cheap WiFi card (such as the Zotac H67ITX-C-E).
2. All solid capacitors. Important for such a small form factor.
3. 240 pin ram (instead of the 204 pin SDRAM of the Asus).
4. It will be cheaper that similarly equipped ITX from the other manufacturers (see the case of the H55H-I).
5. The communication with the ECS representative has been compelling and rich of information.
The only limitation with the ECS ITX will be the absence of a USB3.0 header. The Zotac and Asus ones have them. Anyways, today there aren’t any cases supporting front UBS3.0 that can be connected to the header, but only to the USB3.0 in the rear I/O by USB adapter (see the LianLi cases, as an example).
I think this is the first list of ITX manufacturer official responses to our questions...
What do you SFF fanatics think about that?
Last edited: