PlayStation Move vs. Project Natal

I am not sure who is going to come out ahead in this battle hopefully it is gamers.

If you wanted to play several different kinds of Move games, that could require a hefty hardware purchase.

IMO it's a bad comparison. Move is a wand-like motion sensor similar to the Nintendo Wii, while Natal is a free-for-all motion sensor based on your entire body movement.

It should have been a WiiMote vs Move battle. Natal would whip them both hands down.

As an owner of all three systems and a preferential PS3 player, I think natal has the most promise not to be a gimmick. However I really think the entire movement based gaming concept has been tried for its duration and proven ineffectual. When even nintendo who was forcing all initial games to exclusively use motion control has given up and allowed it to be entirely optional. I fail to see any compelling reason why developers would have any incentive to make it more then a gimmick for systems where it is only an optional accessory.

Move is just a terrible idea, compounded by a terrible looking product (looks like a vibrator) and further compounded with a high cost to get in.

Sony has always been stealing Nintendo's ideas ever since the Playstation came out.Thats just how it works. Nintendo makes a fortune off something Sony always copies it pretty similarly lol. Like they always say, "Imitation is the greatest form of flattery."

Here's to hoping 3rd parties can actually do something with the motion controls. Last thing I want to see is PS3 and Xbox360 owners having to go through what Wii owners did with only the first party and a sparse few 3rd party games being good and the rest being meh at best.

Originally Posted by Azhar

IMO it's a bad comparison. Move is a wand-like motion sensor similar to the Nintendo Wii, while Natal is a free-for-all motion sensor based on your entire body movement.

It should have been a WiiMote vs Move battle. Natal would whip them both hands down.

What? Move looks way better than Natal.

Maybe I'm the only one that hates the Wii's controls and thinks that Natal and Move is just more "Wii-like" bullshit allowing more shovelware to degrade the 360 and PS3.

I think it's all a terrible idea.